Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Note to Jason Rapert: Planned Parenthood vindicated

Posted By on Sat, Dec 29, 2012 at 6:57 AM

JASON RAPERT: His star witness repudiated in federal court.
  • JASON RAPERT: His star witness repudiated in federal court.
I noted the dog-and-pony show arranged recently at the Capitol by the demagoguic evangelist who represents Conway in the state Senate, Jason Rapert. He proposed to block federal money for programs aimed at fighting sexually transmitted diseases in Arkansas because the programs were provided by the Arkansas affiliate of Planned Parenthood.

Rapert was going to bring in an anti-abortion warrior from Iowa, a former Planned Parenthood employee, who was going to talk about her allegations of fraudulent Medicaid billing practices there. She was unable to make it, but that didn't stop Rapert from commandeering the newsprint acreage he craved and to bray later on Twitter about his campaign against Planned Parenthood. He hates it because it provides a full range of medical services for women — general health services, birth control pills, emergency contraception following unprotected (and sometimes unwanted) intercourse and, yes, abortions (though not with public money).

By the time Rapert put on his little media circus, state and federal officials had already found no ground to pursue the claims made by the Iowa crusader (though the mere allegation was enough in the limited mind of Jason Rapert to block funding for unrelated purposes to an Arkansas agency with no direct connection to the Iowa program except through a shared corporate parent.)

Now the rest of the story from the Des Moines Register:

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit that alleged that Planned Parenthood’s affiliate that operates in Iowa had defrauded Medicaid of almost $28 million.

The lawsuit was filed in March 2011 by Susan Thayer, a former Planned Parenthood clinic director from Storm Lake. It was sealed for 16 months to give state and federal authorities time to decide whether to bring criminal charges, which they declined to do.

The original lawsuit alleged that the nonprofit Planned Parenthood of the Heartland illegally billed Medicaid for services related to elective abortions. Elective abortions, defined as abortions in which the mother’s life is not threatened, are not covered by Medicaid under federal and state law. The document also claimed that Planned Parenthood “unbundled” services related to elective abortions — such as blood pressure tests, blood tests and other procedures — and billed those to Medicaid, but not the actual abortions.

A ruling filed Friday by U.S. District Judge John Jarvey says Thayer’s lawsuit did not identify “a single example” of a specific fraudulent claim.

Thayer, an abortion opponent who believes life begins at conception, worked at Planned Parenthood in Storm Lake for nearly 17 years before her job was eliminated amid budget cutbacks. Thayer said she believes her stance against so-called telemedicine abortions, in which doctors remotely dispense pregnancy-terminating drugs to clients via an online video connection, led to her dismissal.

In a news release, Jill June, president of Planned Parenthood of the Heartland, said, “We are happy the Court dismissed the allegations made by Ms. Thayer with prejudice, recognizing the lack of substance in the complaint.”

Being Jason Rapert means never having to say you're sorry.

UPDATE: Rapert responds on Twitter in his customary fashion. He changes the subject. He avoids the utter repudiation of his star witness from Iowa and points instead to Oklahoma, where a federal judge has said it was legal to stop funding a nutrition program for women, infants and children administered by Planned Parenthood. Planned Parenthood believes, with good justification given the Oklahoma legislature, that it was punished for political reasons. But the federal judge said PP didn't present sufficient proof of Oklahoma's political intent (you need not state your real motivation to hit an unpopular agency; just as Rapert is trying to do in Arkansas.) But it's worth noting what the judge DID say about the pretext Oklahoma used and which Rapert tossed around as evidence of foul deeds in his legislative Elmer Gantry-style tent revival in Arkansas:

The judge said Planned Parenthood's performance shortfalls - mostly drops in caseload - did not themselves seem to be problems that could lead to a cut in ties.

"But a routine, solvable problem can become a justifiable basis for strong action when it is compounded by persistent unresponsiveness in addressing the challenge," Friot wrote in his decision.

Losing the contract will force Planned Parenthood to close one of its three clinics in Tulsa, according to Penny Dickey, the organization's chief operating officer


Back to Iowa, from the opinion, not that facts matter to Rapert's blind faith:

Notably, Thayer’s 126-paragraph Second Amended Complaint fails to provide a single specific example of a particular fraudulent claim Planned Parenthood submitted to the government, let alone any representative examples. It fails to identify any particular false claim submitted to the government, any particular date on which Planned Parenthood committed fraud, any particular patient related to fraudulent claims, any particular instance in which regulations were violated, any particular caretaker who falsely reported information, or any particular claim that the government wrongly paid. Even after Planned Parenthood’s motion to dismiss challenged the Second Amended Complaint’s specificity, Thayer’s resistance failed to proffer any additional, specific instances of Planned Parenthood’s alleged fraud. Instead, Thayer’s resistance merely restates truncated versions of the “four fraud schemes” discussed in the Second Amended Complaint.

Tags: , ,

Speaking of...

  • Hobby Lobby invests in contraceptive makers

    June 30, 2014
    Hobby Lobby, which won a Supreme Court ruling that it need not cover certain forms of birth control, invests its retirement money in funds whose holdings include makers of those forms of birth control, as well as insurance companies that cover abortions. /more/
  • Rapert's latest grandstanding; he honors a kindred spirit at Boys State

    May 29, 2014
    Bro. Jason Rapert got to grandstand at Boys State today about that liberal bully down in Little Rock — me. He might have had the crowd with him on abortion, but I think he might have found a different response on marijuana and Faulkner county beer sales. /more/
  • The Boys State open line

    May 27, 2014
    The open line begins with a discussion of my annual trip to Boys State. Attitudes are softening on gay marriage, I detected. Legal marijuana, you ask? Pass the doobie, brother. /more/
  • Dustin McDaniel continues to do Jason Rapert's dirty work

    May 27, 2014
    The state of Arkansas has filed its appeal of Judge Susan Webber Wright's finding that the 2013 law prohibiting most abortions after 12 weeks' gestation is unconstitutional. You wonder how McDaniel and his staff sleep at night filing this kind of balderdash. /more/
  • The abortion prohibition movement advances

    May 22, 2014
    The New York Times notes the spread in Southern states, including neighboring Mississippi, Louisiana and Texas, of laws aimed at requiring abortion providers to have hospital admitting privileges. The laws are under challenge. If allowed to stand they will, as designed, wipe out the availability of abortion in broad swaths of the country. /more/
  • UPDATE: Catholic bishop voices reservations about QualChoice acquisition, completed today

    May 1, 2014
    Bishop Anthony Taylor of the Little Rock Catholic diocese has expressed reservations about the acquisition of the QualChoice insurance company by Catholic Health Initiatives, which operates the St. Vincent Health System. The issue would appear to be insurance coverage of reproductive care. Despite the bishop's concern, the deal has been done, it was announced this morning. /more/
  • Reproductive rights and the Cotton-Pryor Senate race

    April 16, 2014
    U.S. Rep. Tom Cotton, you may remember, was a co-sponsor of the "Life at Conception Act," a so-called personhood measure which would give full constitutional rights to each "preborn human person" at the "moment of fertilization. In addition to being a frontal assault on Roe v. Wade, the bill (likely unconstitutional) could ban certain forms of birth control such as IUDs or the morning-after pill. The Washington Post's Greg Sargent speculates that Democratic Senate candidates may try to make this a wedge issue to help them appeal to women: /more/
  • The coming political fallout on gay marriage

    April 12, 2014
    We could be fast approaching a national decision on gay marriage from the Supreme Court. If the Supreme Court disallows states from banning gay marriage "the political fallout will be enormous," writes Paul Waldman at the Washington Post. Republicans in Arkansas and elsewhere might hope to take advantage of a base-motivating backlash — but that's a strategy that could come with long-term costs. /more/
  • More »

Comments (25)

Showing 1-25 of 25

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-25 of 25

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Stealth politics at grassroots in Arkansas

    A funny thing happened shortly before vote-short developer Dickson Flake got a three-month delay from the Little Rock City Board on considering his widely panned proposal to install a MAPCO filling station and 24-hour convenience store at the dangerous Third and Broadway intersection, just a block and a half from a $70 million Robinson Center Music Hall redo.
    • Jul 10, 2014
  • Property purchases recommend on Main for LR Tech Park: UPDATE

    A consultant has made his recommendations for property to purchase for the Little Rock Tech Park.
    • Jul 9, 2014
  • More »

Readers also liked…

Event Calendar

« »


  1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31  



© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation