Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Republicans react to Medicaid 'circuit breaker'

Posted by on Tue, Jan 15, 2013 at 12:13 PM

House Speaker Davy Carter image

I mentioned earlier that even Arizona Republican Gov. Jan Brewer had decided the economic argument in favor of accepting Medicaid expansion was too powerful to ignore. She has proposed there a "circuit breaker" provision that would automatically shrink the Medicaid program if federal support dropped. As it stands, the federal government is to pay the entire cost of Medicaid expansion for three years, then gradually pass along a small percentage to states, with a 10 percent cap in 2021.

The chance that the feds might back away from that level of funding some years from now has been a primary argument by Arkansas Republicans against taking expansion at all.

David Ramsey asked two legislators about the Arizona idea today.

House Majority Leader Bruce Westerman said:

"I’ve heard that concept tossed around. My understanding, the case law is once you start a government program you can’t just kick people off it, specifically here in the 8th circuit. My understanding in Arkansas if we expand Medicaid program we’re probably expanding it for good."

An important case indeed says Arkansas cannot stop a Medicaid program once started. But I think that's a separate question from, for example, altering the eligibility levels to reduce costs by covering only the poorest.

Westerman mostly stuck with his familiar refrain: "We don't have to do this now, there's no deadline."

Absent an alternative proposal, it still sounds to me like delay for the sake of delay; resistance for the sake of continuing committed resistance.

Ramsey also talked to Sen. Cecile Bledsoe, a doctor's wife who's emerged as a leading Republican spokeswoman on health issues, and asked about Beebe's reference to projected savings on the Medicaid expansion for the state.

"Not that I don’t believe it, but the federal government has to do their part," she said. "If we put all those people—250,000—on Medicaid and then we can’t afford it that would be a travesty."

This is a weird argument, isn't it? It would be a "travesty" to get free or almost free federal coverage for years and then lose some of it. But it would NOT be a travesty to decide not to take any expanded coverage ever, from day one.

As for a circuit breaker, she echoed Westerman:

"Does that mean people on the program would be kicked off? That's a problem we hope we will not have to face, we want to be sure. Since there’s no time certain, what’s the harm of waiting?" She added the legislature will "absolutely" decide this year.

House Speaker Davy Carter talked about Medicaid at his news conference. He complimented Beebe's speech and also said that he agreed with Beebe, despite remarks last week that sounded a little different, that solutions to the federal debt were Washington's, not Arkansas's. But he also continued his focus on fear about the state finding itself with more than a 10 percent match someday. (He and other Republicans rarely emphasize that the 10 percent match is eight years off.)

"... 10 percent of a dollar is still 10 cents. That's real money we’re adding to the money we’re already spending on Mediciad. It’s real money in addition to what we’re already spending. That’s the way I’m coming at this. That’s the current rules. Everybody in this chamber knows at some point someone in Washinton is going to come together and address the spending problem. Problem then becomes what happens when the rules here change. We’re one congressional compromise away from that changing. We have to make these long term decisions with all of that in the back of our minds. In that context federal deficit and debt does matter, it matters here, not any guarantees that it’s going to be a 90/10 split forever. I think they’re going to have to address that."

Similarity in talking points noted, along with the similar inclination to sacrifice health coverage today because of a concern that a law passed by Congress might not be in effect eight years from now. Still sounds like sugar-coated massive resistance to me.

Tags: , , , ,

Speaking of...

  • Conservative chutzpah on Obamacare, part 50

    April 14, 2014
    The New Republic's Brian Beutler flags the latest concern trolling from Obamacare critics. Taking the see-what-sticks approach to new heights, the latest complaint is that people won't be able to sign up until next year once open enrollment is over. It's the Latest Obamacare Surprise! Only, this isn't surprising. It's how the law works. But you might be surprised if you were getting dangerous misinformation from anti-Obamacare advocacy groups. /more/
  • Congressional Budget Office: Obamacare costs $100 billion less than projected, still reduces budget deficits on net

    April 14, 2014
    The new report from the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) found that the coverage expansion under the Affordable Care Act has a lower price tag than what the CBO projected in February, to the tune of $104 billion over the ten-year period 2015–2024. For 2014, the cost is now projected to be $5 billion less than what was projected in February. /more/
  • Millions of mentally ill Americans without health insurance in states that refused Medicaid expansion

    April 11, 2014
    Nearly 4 million Americans with serious mental health conditions have been left without health insurance by the decision of 24 states turn down federal money to expand Medicaid. Yet another example of the human costs of refusing to expand Medicaid, and reason to be thankful that the Arkansas legislature found a way forward to do right by its neediest citizens. /more/
  • Republicans don't like Obamacare whether it's working or not

    April 11, 2014
    One frustrating feature of the endless debates over the Affordable Care Act is that the positions of Obamacare opponents often turn out to be unfalsifiable articles of faith. I think it's helpful to think back to November and December, when wasn't working and the enrollment situation looked dire. If that had continued — if the worst predictions of Obamacare opponents had come true — the law would have faced a real existential crisis going forward. But that's not what happened. The number of people without insurance is going down. Enrollment met, or surpassed projections. And in the face of these events, the Obamacare opponents who predicted that the law was doomed to a train wreck — certain to collapse on its own, leaving its foes to bathe in the political sunshine of a nation's anger — well, they have adjusted their position...not at all. /more/
  • Sylvia Mathews Burwell and the coming confirmation fight

    April 11, 2014
    President Obama will nominate Sylvia Mathews Burwell, currently director of the Office of Management and Budget, to replace Kathleen Sebelius as Secretary of Health and Human Services. Sebelius announced that she is stepping down yesterday. Here's some good background on Burwell and some notes on the coming confirmation fight. What will Sen. Mark Pryor do? /more/
  • Number of uninsured is falling since enactment of Obamacare

    April 10, 2014
    Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius today announced that enrollment in the marketplaces created by Obamacare has hit 7.5 million, with 400,000 people so far taking advantage of the extension offered by the Obama administration to give folks more time to complete the process. Meanwhile, two pieces of data released this week suggest that when you add it all up, Obamacare is making progress toward one of the core goals of the law: reducing the number of Americans without health insurance. /more/
  • Enrollment in Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace tops 40,000

    April 10, 2014
    Through April 6, 41,402 Arkansans have purchased plans on the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace, the new marketplace created by Obamacare, according to information released yesterday by the Arkansas Insurance Department (see county by county map above). As in the rest of the country, Arkansas saw a surge in enrollment recently, with more than 7,800 people signing up in the last two weeks. But while national enrollment in the marketplaces across the country hit initial projections, Arkansas will fall well short. /more/
  • In Nate Bell's hometown of Mena, people are getting covered by Obamacare

    April 10, 2014
    An article in the Mena Star explains that — despite the efforts of state Rep. Nate Bell, the Mena Republican who has made it his mission to stop outreach informing people of their options for health insurance under the Affordable Care Act — citizens in Mena are getting covered under Obamacare. /more/
  • The human costs of refusing to expand Medicaid

    April 9, 2014
    Great story from the Orlando Weekly on Charlene Dill, a 32-year-old mother of three working three part-time jobs who died because of a documented heart condition. Dill fell into the "coverage gap" in Florida: She made a little too much to qualify for the state's existing Medicaid program but too little to qualify for subsidies on the newly formed health insurance exchange. When the state refused to expand Medicaid, that left a gap in coverage for low-income residents, and left Dill without options for health insurance. /more/
  • Medicaid expansion, the private option, and the remaining holdout states

    April 3, 2014
    With 24 states still holding out, some predict a coming wave of states expanding Medicaid. While the private option was a game-changer in Arkansas, nationally only two other states so far have gone that route. If political pressure mounts for expansion, will other red states take the Arkansas option? Stay tuned... /more/
  • More »

Comments (9)

Showing 1-9 of 9

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-9 of 9

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Connecting the dots

    There's ample reason for ethics, judicial and perhaps even prosecutorial review of the curious creation of a group of political action committees solely funded by contributions from Fort Smith nursing home magnate Michael Morton.
    • Apr 10, 2014
  • The real story about the judicial system in Arkansas

    The big story isn't campaign finance funny business except to the extent that it reflects a much larger story about justice in Arkansas. Gilbert Baker and co. have worked for year in the employ of forces who want to make it harder to sue for damages in Arkansas courts: the so-called "tort reform" campaign of big business.
    • Apr 4, 2014
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »


  1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30  



  • As part of Ball State University's BSU at the Games, Arkansas Times photo intern Matt Amaro covered the culture of Sochi during the Winter Olympics.

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation