Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Thursday, February 28, 2013

UPDATED WITH HHS RESPONSE Is new Arkansas Medicaid expansion deal legal?

Posted By on Thu, Feb 28, 2013 at 9:44 AM

Here's a simple question that's been nagging me about the Medicaid deal: Under what statutory authority are the feds subsidizing folks between 0 and 100 percent of the federal poverty level on the exchange?

There's been a lot of talk about what we should call this new plan, since it's not really Medicaid expansion. (My vote: "The Private Option.") Under this plan, the Medicaid program isn't expanding at all. Instead, the government is going to pick up the full tab for low-income folks buying private health insurance. Technically, this will be done with "Medicaid dollars" with the money running through the Medicaid program.

Here's the thing. There's nothing about paying for people below 100 percent of the FPL to buy health insurance in the Affordable Care Act. Particularly given that this new approach will almost surely cost more, why don't they need Congressional approval? Is the idea that funding folks on the exchange just IS "Medicaid expansion" — authorized by the ACA — because it's "Medicaid dollars"? In that case, the feds may be leery of a name change!

Seriously, though, this seems at first blush to be fishy. Congress approved funding for something specific, with its own projected costs: Medicaid expansion. Could HHS, under the ACA, authorize giving every low-income person in Arkansas $1 million to buy health insurance and call it Medicaid dollars? Keep in mind that we've been told all along by HHS that people under 100 percent FPL weren't eligible for subsidies on the exchange because it wasn't in the law.

Before expansion proponents get mad at me for stirring the hornets' nest, keep in mind that if I've thought of this, folks smarter than me will too.

I asked Gov. Mike Beebe's spokesman Matt DeCample and he referred me to HHS. I've got a line in to them and will update when I hear back.

I'm not an attorney. Anyone with legal expertise, please use the comments to explain why I shouldn't be worried about this.

*UPDATE: Slate's Matt Yglesias suggests one possible answer: Arkansas will get a 1915(b) waiver as part of the Medicaid expansion to use managed care to deliver coverage. This is the deal that Florida got. A little strange for Arkansas given that our state does not have a managed care system, but perhaps simply funding folks to buy insurance on the exchange counts. Of course, under this waiver, the state has to prove that the alternative system is cost effective, and everything we know suggests that it will cost more.

*UPDATE: Nope. DeCample told me that a 1915 (b) waiver was NOT part of the deal the governor discussed with Sebelius. Sarah Kliff of the Washington Post has a post on the Arkansas "private option" forthcoming but tweeted that a waiver is not part of the deal.

*UPDATE: An HHS spokesperson provided me with a statement that doesn't answer the question:

Our goal in working with states has been to be as flexible as possible within the confines of the law. In her meeting with Governor Beebe, Secretary Sebelius expressed support for ideas from the state that would take advantage of this flexibility and said she was glad to see the state considering an innovative, state-based approach.

*UPDATE: Sounds like Kliff has the answer in her excellent explainer on the Arkansas deal.

The states get authority to do this under part of the Social Security Act (Sec. 1905A, if you want to get really specific) that allows states to use Medicaid dollars to buy private coverage for enrollees. This is known as premium assistance and already happens in a handful of states right now, although usually on a small level. Sometimes, states will do this to help Medicaid eligible residents use federal funds to buy into an employer-sponsored plan.

I still have some questions...more updates to come.

Tags: , , ,

Speaking of...

  • Legislature discusses merging teacher and state employee insurance, but won't touch separate retirement systems

    August 26, 2014
    Combining the insurance systems for public school employees and state employees might help teachers with premiums in the short run, but unless it's accompanied by a big infusion of cash it will harm state employees. As for combining retirement systems for teachers and other public workers? Not happening. /more/
  • The Obamacare open line

    August 23, 2014
    Tonight's open line includes news that Arkansas Democrats are rallying around bread-and-butter populist themes — an increase in the minimum wage and support for expansion of health care coverage. (Pssst: That last thing? Just don't call it Obamacare.) /more/
  • Hillary Bus to join Democratic events today

    August 23, 2014
    The Arkansas Democratic Party will hold it state convention today at Philander Smith College and gather for the Jefferson-Jackson Dinner tonight at the Statehouse Convention Center, with remarks planned by Gov. Mike Beebe and Mike Ross, the candidate for governor, and Mark Pryor, the incumbent senator. A flavor of national politics will be added by the presence of the Hillary Bus. /more/
  • Obamacare and the Mark Pryor-Tom Cotton Senate race

    August 21, 2014
    Yesterday, Sen. Mark Pryor did something that got national attention: he released an ad that actually took credit for the benefits of Obamacare. Cotton's response was surprisingly muted. Could this be the latest sign that the Obamacare attack doesn't pack the punch it once did? One key question of the Arkansas Senate race will be what is more politically potent, the name "Obamacare" (which Cotton will repeat while dodging policy specifics) or the law's more popular component parts (which Pryor is beginning to highlight while avoiding actually naming the law). /more/
  • What is it with Arkansas Republicans and the homestead tax exemption?

    August 21, 2014
    Plus, few Arkansas bartenders, confident private option predictions from Gov. Mike Beebe, Arkansas Democrats weak stance on curbing carbon emissions and Bonnie Montgomery and Martin O'Malley. /more/
  • Tom Cotton and the Republicans get desperate

    August 19, 2014
    Tom Cotton and Karl Rove and Co. are growing increasingly desperate and incoherent in attacks on Sen. Mark Pryor, who's proving not so easy to defeat as Republicans once believed. /more/
  • Southern governors discuss efforts to contain health care costs

    August 17, 2014
    In addition to coverage expansion, there was much talk at the Southern Governors Conference on health care payment reform — Gov. Mike Beebe argued that while it has gotten less attention, the state's Payment Improvement Initiative is an equally important development in health care reform in the state. Beebe said he was "more convinced than ever that fee for service was an unsustainable model for the payment of health care in this country." /more/
  • Southern Governors Association talks private option

    August 16, 2014
    Gov. Mike Beebe, as well as governors from Maryland and Kentucky, discussed health care reform and the private option – the unique Arkansas version of Medicaid expansion – at a panel this morning at the Southern Governors Association meeting. Here are a few highlights, including the unique status of Arkansas and Kentucky, the possibility that the private option helped cut disability applications, and why Beebe thinks Arkansas got it right and Louisiana got it wrong. /more/
  • Beebe: minority of legislature won't run over majority to block private option in 2015

    August 16, 2014
    Gov. Mike Beebe hosted a panel this morning on the private option — the state's plan using Medicaid funds to purchase private health insurance for low-income Arkansans — at the Southern Governors Association meeting in downtown Little Rock. Beebe used the occasion to make a prediction — more bold, aggressive and blunt than we're accustomed to from Beebe, nearing the end of his term. The private option isn't going anywhere, Beebe said, because ultimately the overwhelming majority of the legislature supports it. /more/
  • Bill Clinton on private option and Sunni tribal leaders and genomics and Mike Beebe

    August 15, 2014
    Bill Clinton delivered the keynote address at the Southern Governors' Association this afternoon at the Little Rock Marriott. The theme of this year's conference is "Accelerating the American South's R&D Network", which of course Clinton interpreted as free license to riff on everything from welfare reform to the crisis in Ukraine. /more/
  • More »

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

More by David Ramsey

  • Obamacare premiums in Arkansas projected to drop 2 percent in 2015

    Insurance companies have proposed a net reduction in premiums of 2 percent next year for the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace, the health insurance exchange created by the Affordable Care Act. The Marketplace includes all of the plans used for the private option, the state's unique plan which uses Medicaid funds to purchase private health insurance for low-income Arkansans.
    • Aug 26, 2014
  • Art online, ILoveMakkonnen, Rosalia’s sunset tea, Fleetwood Mac

    A belated edition of Arkansas Times Recommends includes a possible jam of the summer, loose and jovial illustrations, Fleetwood Mac worship and the super-chill Pavlovian response to cherries.
    • Aug 26, 2014
  • More »

Most Shared

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Blogroll

 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation