Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

DHS issues correction on projections; bottom line unchanged

Posted By on Tue, Mar 19, 2013 at 4:07 PM

DHS issued a correction to reporters today — the per-person, per-year numbers provided to reporters yesterday for Medicaid expansion are not accurate.

The numbers related to the percentage differential between the cost of providing insurance for the expansion pool via the "private option" as opposed to Medicaid expansion remains the same: 13 to 14 percent. The total per-year incremental rise in cost also remains the same—somewhere around $100 to $120 million. The headline that DHS projects little to no increase in cost to the feds remains the same.

The error: Reporters were told that the per-person-per-year (PPPY) cost of offering coverage via the "private option" was projected to be $5,975 and the PPPY cost of offering coverage via Medicaid expansion was $5,200. These figures are not accurate and in fact DHS was not immediately able to give me an average PPPY for the entire expansion population.

Healthy adults who are not medically frail make up around 90 percent of the total expansion pool. The PPPY cost of just these non-medically frail, healthy adults would be $4,392 for Medicaid expansion in FY 2014. The PPPY cost for the same population via "private option" in FY 2014 would be $5,256. If you get out your calculator, you'll see that the difference is 20 percent, not 13-14. The issue is that the more expensive outlier populations (around 10 percent of the total pool) will be covered by Medicaid either way, so there is no price differential there. There are also different match rates for transfer populations that get missed if you simply compare the PPPY cost of a health adult in Medicaid versus the "private option."

DHS found that the total extra cost to covering the expansion pool via Medicaid would be $177 million (calculating with the old numbers yielded $193 million). That would represent 13.6 percent of the total projected spending under traditional Medicaid expansion in 2014 ($1.3 billion). If we subtract $70 million in projected savings from the 138-400 FPL group on the exchange (lower premiums so less subsidies needed from the government), we're at $107 million. DHS argues that when you also include the fact that Medicaid itself would likely have higher PPPY numbers under expansion than reported above because of access pressure, as well as offsetting tax revenues, the number could get close to zero.

Tags:

Speaking of Health Care

Comments (4)

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

More by David Ramsey

  • Free beer, 'New Flame,' 'Serial' the podcast and an Ohio mixtape

    Sarah Koenig, a longtime producer on "This American Life," is hosting a new podcast called "Serial" spun off from that show, the difference being that each episode here is a chapter in a single larger story which they'll tell over the course of a season — a kind of heavily reported, audio miniseries. Four episodes have been released so far and they've been great, really gripping and well-produced.
    • Oct 17, 2014
  • More than 38,000 consumers covered on the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace (Tom Cotton would kick them off too)

    We often mention the 211,611 who have gained coverage under the private option. Sometimes lost in the shuffle in these conversations is another group of Arkansans — around 38,000 people who have purchased health insurance on the newly created Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace, the health insurance exchange created by Obamacare.
    • Oct 17, 2014
  • More »

Most Shared

  • The martyr of Danville Mountain

    Jacob George, 'moral injury' and one soldier's losing struggle against the encroaching darkness of war.
  • Eugene Ellison: Little Rock's Michael Brown

    A couple of weeks ago I accompanied 10 students to St. Louis for a mass rally in support of indicting the police officer responsible for killing Michael Brown in mid-August.
  • Tom Cotton campaign's dirty telephone tricks

    A Democratic voter of my acquaintance who lives in Conway received a call this week that informed he was not registered to vote.
  • Clarke Tucker: a vote for the future

    If the Democratic Party of Arkansas has a future, it is in people like Clarke Tucker, the Democratic nominee to succeed term-limited John Edwards in representing House District 35 — the Heights and northwestern Little Rock.
  • Good news abounds even if you don't see it in the polls

    Ernest Dumas is back from vacation with a column that chronicles abundant good news in the land and an electorate that either pays it no mind or disbelieves anything could be good on Barack Obama's watch.

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Blogroll

 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation