Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Friday, April 5, 2013

The fight to protect the referendum in Arkansas

Posted By on Fri, Apr 5, 2013 at 7:13 AM

I noted recently objections to the effort by Arkansas's duopoly casinos at Southland and Oaklawn, in league with their friend Attorney General Dustin McDaniel, to make the referendum process prohibitively difficult in Arkansas so as to discourage future casino amendments, along with other potential laws unpleasant to the business lobby.

The item, quoting Paul Jacob, a term limits and referendum crusader, drew a rejoinder from the Friday Law Firm, which challenged Jacob's representation of case law in favor of a vigorous referendum process. (Free speech restrictions are not the only potential problems with the casino/McDaniel effort to limit the process, by the way. The Arkansas Constitution also suggests problems with the proposed legislation.) The Friday firm cited some law favorable to a more restrictive approach. Their law would make it impossible to hire canvassers on a per-signature basis on state campaigns, the most efficient means of gathering signatures.

Jacob has responded with a lengthy note. In the hopes that an open-minded legislator might take a look (and might I say that, to date, Rep. Nate Bell of Mena has been a noteworthy advocate of preserving the referendum process), I reprint Jacob's note below. Following Jacob's note is a note, too, from David Couch, a Little Rock lawyer following the debate, who debunks an inadequate fiscal impact statement on this punitive measure:

Enjoyed your piece on our sending the federal court decision on the Colorado pay per signature case to representatives and emphasizing its bearing on SB 821. The Friday firm lawyer is absolutely correct that an 8th Circuit case back in 1999-2000 held a North Dakota pay per signature ban (and a residency requirement) to be constitutional in a challenge that indeed I was involved in, with U.S. Term Limits one of the plaintiffs.

But he misses the forest for the one thin tree standing on the North Dakota plains.

That North Dakota case has been largely discounted by other federal circuits and even by at least one federal district judge in the 8th Circuit (as you'll see below), because there was no evidence introduced to show the burden the law places on First Amendment activity. I take my share of the blame for not having put together a more thorough challenge way back then, but live and learn.

On the other hand, the recent Colorado case, which Citizens in Charge Foundation spent a good deal of time working on over the last three years, was exhaustively briefed with numerous depositions and reams of evidence and then an eight-day trial — something I’d never before experienced, having been in a lot of constitutional court challenges.

The judge’s findings of fact and his ruling striking down Colorado’s mere 20% limit on productivity based pay (i.e. the number of signatures gathered), based on such exhaustive evidence from experts across the country, provides a complete road-map to challenging the outright ban on such pay found in Sen. Ingram’s SB 821.

If Arkansas SB 821 passes, I’m confident all that evidence will be brought to a federal court in Arkansas. Moreover, those behind SB 821 will have to admit (a) they don't have a single verified case of fraud, i.e. no conviction of anyone for anything (because, inexplicably, no one has been charged and prosecuted), and more importantly, (b) they have no evidence whatsoever that per signature pay increases the incidence of fraud or that banning per signature pay reduces fraud.

Citizens in Charge Foundation did an open records study in all 26 initiative and referendum states, which found that, between 1998 and 2008, states which banned pay based on the number of signatures gathered had more verified fraud cases than states like Arkansas that allowed pay to petition circulators based on the number of signatures.

Care to guess the state with the most verified cases of actually prosecuted and convicted fraud? North Dakota! The state with restrictions on out-of-state circulators and pay per signature

Courts have admittedly been mixed on pay per signature. The Sixth Circuit has struck it down. The Ninth has joined the Eighth in upholding it, though again citing clearly in the written decision that had there been more evidence of any burden on the plaintiffs, the court would have used strict scrutiny and perhaps ruled differently. A ban on productively pay for petitioners was struck down in neighboring Mississippi a decade or so ago. It was upheld in Nebraska in, again, a badly evidenced and argued case.

As I mentioned above, that same North Dakota case upholding a productivity pay ban also found residency requirements for petitioners constitutional. Not only have three federal circuits found unanimously against residency in the last five years, but so did a federal judge in Nebraska recently.

Last year, the State of Nebraska paid our attorneys $250,000 to cover our legal fees when we won the case, Citizens in Charge v. Gale, overturning the state's residency requirement. Nebraska is in the 8th Circuit, too. Nonetheless, the federal judge ignored that North Dakota case, striking down Nebraska’s law. Then, the Nebraska AG thought so much of the North Dakota case’s precedent that he declined to appeal our victory to the 8th Circuit.

That speaks volumes about the legal precedent being relied upon for SB 821.

If SB 821 passes, in addition to effectively undermining our most fundamental political rights for a time, it will also undoubtedly cost the state money to defend. Including, before all is said and done, the cost of legal fees for the First Amendment attorney who takes the lawsuit to challenge and overturn SB 821 in federal court.

Arkansas has one of the best initiative and referendum systems in the country. I’d hate to see it undercut. And if it is, I’ll sure want to see it restored.

Sorry to be long-winded.



Attached is the fiscal impact statement that was passed out at the committee hearing on Wednesday. As you can see it totally misses the mark. The only thing that they looked at was possible costs associated with imprisonment of people who may be convicted for violating the law. The big hidden costs in these bills are not addressed. This bill would require that the Board of Election Commissioners establish and provide a training program for paid canvassers which I assume would have to be statewide because I sincerely doubt that it would be fair to have someone from Lake Village or Bentonville come to Little Rock for training. This program is just not going to magically appear and operate and there will have to be materials associated with it and someone to administer it. It would also require that the secretary of state provide some type of “proof of registration” which would include a photo. The secretary of state is going to have to provide registration forms, keep a registration database and provide photo ID’s to these people at no charge because the constitution prohibits the state from charging someone to be a canvasser. If voter ID cards were going to cost the state $300,000 then here is another $300,000 arguably. SB821 is on the agenda today at 11. I don’t see where any amendments have been filed yet but I’m going and taking Paul Spencer with me just to keep an eye on these scoundrels. I agree with everything that Paul Jacob said in his email to you. I had the North Dakota case with me Wednesday in case the Friday Firm lawyers decided to tout the constitutionality of this obviously unconstitutional proposal.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Speaking of...

  • The debate over Pryor-Cotton debates

    September 29, 2014
    The tedious debate over debates continues, with the Cotton campaign slamming Mark Pryor for not agreeing to the KARK debate and the Pryor campaign slamming Tom Cotton for not agreeing to the AETN debate. /more/
  • World Trade Center Arkansas receives grant from Economic Development Administration, which Tom Cotton voted to abolish

    September 29, 2014
    Sen. Mark Pryor, along with Republicans Sen. John Boozman, Rep. Steve Womack and Rep. Tim Griffin, were on hand today in Rogers to announce a $600,000 federal grant for the World Trade Center Arkansas, an affiliate of the University of Arkansas. The federal money will be used "to expand its outreach services to diversify and strengthen the state’s economy," according to the university. The funds were available via the Economic Development Administration, which Tom Cotton voted to abolish. /more/
  • Monkey business from Americans for Prosperity

    September 29, 2014
    Stay classy, Americans for Prosperity. /more/
  • State of the Cotton-Pryor race

    September 29, 2014
    All of the polling aggregation and forecast models currently give Tom Cotton the advantage over Mark Pryor, in some cases a substantial one. The race is by no means over and is indeed close — even the most pessimistic models still give Pryor a one in five chance of prevailing. But if these forecasts are to be believed, Cotton is a clear favorite at this point. /more/
  • The minimum wage issue in Senate races, and why Tom Cotton and Asa Hutchinson choose not to take a principled stand

    September 29, 2014
    Joni Ernst, the GOP candidate in a tough battle for a U.S. Senate seat in Iowa, is taking a big risk with her opposition to a hike of the state minimum wage. Here in Arkansas, Tom Cotton and Asa Hutchinson are taking no such risk, with their transparent election-year ploy — as soon as the wage hike initiative made the ballot, they suddenly said they were for it. And we applaud them for their support! Just don't call it principled. /more/
  • Bill Clinton coming to Arkansas to campaign for Democrats

    September 29, 2014
    The Arkansas Democratic Party announced this morning that former President Bill Clinton will take some time off from grandparenting to headline rallies and campaign for Arkansas Democrats in Conway, Jonesboro, Fayetteville and Rogers on October 6 and 7. Clinton will speak at University of Central Arkansas, Arkansas State University, the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville, and the John Q. Hammons Convention Center in Rogers. /more/
  • The not-so-principled stand of Tom Cotton on the minimum wage

    September 28, 2014
    Finger-in-the-wind political maneuvering doesn't get much more stark than Republican Senate candidate Tom Cotton announcing earlier this month that he would support the ballot initiative to raise the state minimum wage. Cotton's endorsement of the minimum wage hike was presumably meant to neutralize the minimum wage issue in this campaign, which Sen. Mark Pryor might have used as a political cudgel. But Cotton's brand — and his defense on controversial votes — is that he always takes the principled stand, even if it's difficult or unpopular. /more/
  • Chuck Todd proposes KARK debate; Tom Cotton accepts, no response yet from Mark Pryor

    September 28, 2014
    During a taped segment Friday with local KARK-4 reporter David Goins, NBC's Meet the Press host Chuck Todd suggested that the two co-host a debate between Senate candidates Tom Cotton and Mark Pryor, with Todd suggesting that he would come down to Little Rock for the event. /more/
  • Mike Ross goes after Asa Hutchinson for flip-flops

    September 27, 2014
    Asa Hutchinson's flip flop on the minimum wage was as egregious as it gets. Mike Ross is noting another Asa flip flop, on pre-k (expanding pre-k was the wrong direction, Hutchinson said this summer; now "we need to expand pre-k," he said to the Northwest Arkansas Political Animals on Thursday). See the video above, from the Ross campaign. Hutchinson is triangulating away. A bemused Ross said, "Wow, I knew Congressman Hutchinson had changed his position on the minimum wage, I didn't know he'd changed it on pre-k too," to hoots and laughter from the audience. /more/
  • Tom Cotton's 2000 law review article on the Arkansas ballot initiative

    September 27, 2014
    Tom Cotton's 2000 article in the Arkansas Law Review displays young Cotton's distrust of populism and his exaltation of the wise and virtuous few selected to represent the people. /more/
  • More »

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Beverly Carter's body found in shallow grave on Highway 5 in northern Pulaski County

    The Pulaski sheriff's office reported early this morning that the body of Beverly Carter, the real estate agent apparently abducted while showing a home near Scott Thursday evening, had been found in a shallow grad near Cabot. The charges against Arron Lewis, her suspected abuctor, have been upgraded to capital murder.
    • Sep 30, 2014
  • Mark Pryor is a consensus builder; attorney general talk proves it

    The fact that Sen. Mark Pryor is even mentioned as a potential nominee for attorney general is solid proof — as evidenced by right-wing news sources — that he's the candidate in the race this year who offers some promise of being a bipartisan consensus builder.
    • Sep 25, 2014
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Nate Bell finds an acorn

    I get lots of opportunities to make cracks about right-wing Republican legislator Nate Bell of Mena.
    • Jan 11, 2013
  • Gov. Mike Beebe slams Darr, will decide on abortion bill this afternoon

    Gov. Mike Beebe had harsh words for Lt. Gov. Mark Darr, who signed legislation exempting the concealed-carry permit list from the state Freedom of Information Act as acting governor while Beebe was out of town.
    • Feb 26, 2013
  • Voter ID may be stalled

    Because it would require amending the constitution, which requires a supermajority in both chambers.
    • Mar 8, 2013

People who saved…

Most Shared

  • How the South became dead red

    Good piece in Politico from Stanford sociology professor Doug McAdam on the roots of our modern partisan divide. McAdam tells the familiar story of how the South flipped, as yellow dog Democrats in the old Confederacy abandoned the party in the wake of the Civil Rights movement.
  • Fact-checkers unaninmous: Tom Cotton is a liar

    Tom Cotton has hit the fact-checking trifecta: All three major fact-checking operations says his ad blaming his vote against the farm bill on President Obama is dishonest.
  • Bill Clinton sounds caution on charter schools

    A singular voice, former president Bill Clinton, sounded a note of caution about charter schools in a speech in New York yesterday and thank goodness.
  • Fayetteville City Clerk's office certifies signatures — civil rights ordinance will go to a public vote

    The Fayetteville City Clerk's office has certified that enough signatures were gathered to trigger a special election on Fayetteville's new civil rights ordinance, the Fayetteville Flyer reports. The effort to force a popular vote on the ordinance, led by a Repeal 119, a church-led group, gathered 5,714 signatures. Petitioners needed 4,905; the City Clerk's office began certifying the signatures last week and stopped at the end of the day Friday once enough signatures had been validated. The ordinance to discourage discrimination in housing and employment passed in the City Council 6-2 last month. The vote came after 10 hours of discussion, with many conservatives furious because the classes of people protected included gay and transgender people.
  • Tom Cotton's evasive maneuvering on the Farm Bill

    Rep. Tom Cotton continues to take a ribbing for his recent ad attempting cover on his vote against the Farm Bill (Cotton, you'll remember, claimed that Obama "hijacked" it and turned it into a food stamp bill; factcheckers pounced). Cotton is trying to have his row crops and eat them too, claiming he supports farm subsidies while voting against them.

Most Viewed

  • Hot Springs firing range declared a "Muslim free zone" by its owner

    The owner of The Gun Cave Indoor Shooting Range in Hot Springs, Jan Morgan, announced yesterday that she is banning the presence of Muslims in her business. Her reasoning: "Why would I hand guns and ammunition to people whose religion commands them to kill me and my non-muslim patrons?" OK, let's get that lawsuit rolling.
  • Bench warrant issued in disappearance of Beverly Carter — UPDATE

    A bench warrant has been issued for a man named Aaron M. Lewis on one count of kidnapping in the disappearance of Beverly Carter, 51, a Crye-Leike real estate agent who disappeared after going to show a house on Thursday afternoon. With updated information as of 10:30 p.m..
  • Beverly Carter's body found in shallow grave on Highway 5 in northern Pulaski County

    The Pulaski sheriff's office reported early this morning that the body of Beverly Carter, the real estate agent apparently abducted while showing a home near Scott Thursday evening, had been found in a shallow grad near Cabot. The charges against Arron Lewis, her suspected abuctor, have been upgraded to capital murder.

Most Recent Comments



© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation