Friday, April 5, 2013

Legislature today: The final push on tort reform proposals

Posted By on Fri, Apr 5, 2013 at 2:25 PM

click to enlarge 1365197171-spill.jpg

Constitutional amendments will be discussed by the legislature's state agencies committees today and competing proposals for changes to law governing damage lawsuits ("tort reform") are at the top of the agenda.


* ETHICS: A constitutional amendment that combines ethics reform (ban on lobbyist gifts, two-year cooling off period for becoming a lobbyist, ban on corporate contributions) with measures that would allow increased pay for legislators and an extension of term limits to 16 years of service, was recommended by the committee for a popular vote.

* TORTS: I'm told no Senate amendment proposals were heard today, so no decision yet on which, if either proposal, on tort reform will make the ballot.

Awaiting word on what other two amendments will be favored.

From earlier today:

The Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association has thrown support of plaintiffs' lawyers behind an amendment with new restrictions on damage lawsuits to stave off a far more restrictive proposal in SJR 5 by the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and allied business interests.

Today, Matthew Hass, the executive director of the Trial Lawyers group, sent a letter to lawmakers that noted a powerful Arkansas corporate citizen, Riceland Foods OPPOSED a cap on punitive damages, part of the "reform" measures favored by many businesses. Riceland won a huge damage award against Bayer Cropscience in a class action suit over genetically engineered rice. The rice tainted Arkansas crops and made it impossible to sell in foreign markets. Wrote Hass:

Some proponents of SJR 5 cite this case as being bad for Arkansans businesses, yet it was Arkansas businesses and farmers who triumphed over a foreign company. How is protecting Arkansas businesses over German ones bad for business?

Full letter on the jump.

A heavy agenda is under consideration at the Capitol on other fronts. And tomorrow. Among the developments:

* GROCERY TAX CUT: A proposal to take the remaining tiny sales tax off groceries, if revenues can support it, came out of House committee today.

* RAW MILK: The bill to allow farm sales of unpasteurized milk (cheese makers everywhere cheer) also cleared a House committee.

* DREAMS DASHED: Odds look long for Sen. Joyce Elliott's bill to allow children of undocumented immigrants to have in-state tution at Arkansas colleges along with other Arkansas high school graduates. Immigrant animosity is simply too great among Arkansas Republicans.

* PUNISHING PLANNED PARENTHOOD: David Goins of Fox 16 reports on Twitter that the Senate fell one vote short of passing the bill to deny state funding to Planned Parenthood for HIV and sexual transmitted disease education. It got the minimum 18 votes, but one vote was missing when the ballot sounded. It can be reconsidered.

Dear Senator,

I know you’ve probably heard your fill of tort reform over the past few weeks, but I respectfully ask that you consider one more piece of information before making any final decisions.

The attached document is an Amicus Brief. These are written by parties who have something to say about a case being heard. In this instance, Riceland Foods, the world’s largest rice miller and one of Arkansas’ largest employers, wrote a brief on behalf of Arkansas farmers suing Bayer Cropsciences, a German corporation. The farmers were suing Bayer for tainting Arkansas’ rice crop with genetically modified rice that caused foreign markets to shut out Arkansas rice which devastated the industry.

In the brief, Riceland explains why it believes caps on damages are harmful because it allows wrongdoers to minimize the impact of their transgressions. The brief is lengthy and I know your time is precious, so I have pulled a few of Riceland’s quotes from the brief, and I ask that you bear this case in mind. Some proponents of SJR 5 cite this case as being bad for Arkansans businesses, yet it was Arkansas businesses and farmers who triumphed over a foreign company. How is protecting Arkansas businesses over German ones bad for business?

Again, I respectfully ask that you consider these arguments before making your final decision.

Quotes from Riceland Brief:

“Riceland shares Appellees’ interest in having this Court affirm the decision of the Circuit Court of Lonoke County finding the statutory cap on punitive damages unconstitutional. In the past year, three separate Arkansas state court juries have found that Bayer’s LLRICE contamination crippled the agricultural industry in this State and justified significant awards of punitive damages…” Page 10

“…enforcing the statutory cap on punitives in this case would allow Bayer to pay a mere $1 million fine. For a multi-billion-dollar foreign conglomerate such as Bayer, a minuscule fine utterly fails to punish and deter the type of conduct that devastated this State’s rice industry.” Page 10

“… history teaches that the right to jury trial is most commonly threatened precisely where its preservation was deemed most essential — where jury outcomes are different from those preferred by those with political influence.” Page 12

“Indeed, the power to award punitive damages has always belonged to juries, and served as the populace’s most basic protection against those able and willing to violate others’ rights for their own gain. … the tort reform agenda — from which Arkansas’s statutory punitive damages cap emerged — was designed to strip juries of this traditional power.” Page 13

Matthew J. Hass

Matthew J. Hass
Executive Director

Tags: , , , , , ,


Speaking of...

Comments (11)

Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Arkansas Supreme Court denies rehearing in death penalty challenge, but delays mandate

    The Arkansas Supreme Court today refused to rehear the case denying Death Row inmates information about drugs used by the state in the lethal injection process.
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • Welspun layoffs: Another example of corporate welfare folly

    Layoffs at the Welspun pipe plant in Little Rock are a reminder of the folly of corporate welfare and the inability of Arkansas to separate itself from global economic forces. See the Fayetteville shale. And keep a watchful eye on that Sun Paper pulp mill proposed near Arkadelphia.
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • Hamburg bank manager gets 21 months for theft

    Melinda Gwin, 49, of Hamburg has been sentenced to 21 months in federal prison and ordered to repay $210,875 stolen from the First National Bank of Crossett. She was sentenced in El Dorado federal court, according to a Justice Department news release.
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Huckabee goes after Obamas on Beyonce

    Mike Huckabee continues to draw wide attention — a lot of it bad — for his criticism of Beyonce and the Obamas for being friends with the entertainer. Friendship with Ted Nugent is OK, however.
    • Jan 13, 2015
  • Kochs plan to spend $889 million in 2016 campaign

    Breathaking. The political organization backed by the Koch brothers plans to spend almost a billion dollars in the 2016 campaign cycle.
    • Jan 26, 2015
  • Arkansas lawyers file class action against Walmart, others, over herbal products: UPDATE

    Lawyers in Little Rock and Fayetteville have filed federal suit in the Western District against Walmart, Target and Walgreens stores for selling herbal products that an investigation in New York discovered contained little or n one of the ingredients advertised on the bottle.
    • Feb 5, 2015

Most Shared

  • Best of Arkansas 2016

    Readers elect their favorites.
  • These Hogs won't be thin

    This may be the strongest returning receiving corps that the Razorbacks have fielded in the post-Petrino days.
  • Trump-Putin 2016

    Among the thousand bizarre aspects of the presidential campaign has been the Donald Trump-Vladimir Putin axis.
  • Hillary hit jobs

    It's always been my conviction that if Hillary Clinton could be appointed president, she'd do a bang-up job. Getting elected, however, might prove more difficult.

Most Viewed

  • DNC: The final event

    Most reading this watched last night’s final night of the Democratic National Convention and have watched many more hours of analysis of Hillary Clinton’s acceptance speech and the other events of the evening, so I will avoid too many more words on what was a crisply delivered speech.

Most Recent Comments



© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation