Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Friday, July 19, 2013

Securities Department responds to GOP pressure for more investigation of Shoffner case; evidence insufficient so far

Posted By on Fri, Jul 19, 2013 at 12:21 PM

click to enlarge HEATH ABSHURE: Investigation of Shoffner case continues, but insufficient evidence for new charges so far.
  • HEATH ABSHURE: Investigation of Shoffner case continues, but insufficient evidence for new charges so far.

HEATH ABSHURE: Investigation of Shoffner case continues, but insufficient evidence for new charges so far.
  • HEATH ABSHURE: Investigation of Shoffner case continues, but insufficient evidence for new charges so far.
Arkansas Republicans aren't through milking the opportunity given by federal charges against former Treasurer Martha Shoffner, a Democrat, for taking cash payments from a securities dealer who did a huge amount of business with Shoffner's office.

Earlier this month, Sen. Bryan King and Rep. Kim Hammer, co-chairs of the Legislative Joint Auditing Committee, sent letters to Securities Commissioner Heath Abshure, Attorney General Dustin McDaniel and Pulaski Prosecutor Larry Jegley. They essentially demanded more investigation of Shoffner and others for more potential charges, based on legislative audit review of the offices practices.

The audit review — though flawed in its understanding of the securities business (it, for example, compared investment yields on the treasurer's highly liquid investments with those on the riskier, longer-term investment portfolio of Teacher Retirement) — noted the concentration of business Shoffner had done with Steele Stephens of St. Bernard Financial Services. It also noted that the state had realized far less in expected earnings on some bond purchases because of their liquidation for alternative investments. The broker has defended the trading for its profit on the sale of the bonds and for the fact that prevailing interest rates hadn't performed as expected.

The Republicans and allies on the auditing staff have focused like a laser on trading losses. Please note: If a securities trade loss is a crime, the prisons would be filled with stockbrokers. I say this as a son and brother of securities dealers, who sometimes invested my own money in securities that declined in value.

Though the audits themselves alleged no law violations, they did recommend a number of needed changes in treasurer's office investment practices. Shoffner's arrest had nothing to do with the audit, however. It occurred because she apparently continued to take money from a salesman despite every indication that a whistleblower had complained to authorities about her favoritism in trading months before. When the salesman went wearing a wire to see Shoffner with a pie box stuffed with $100 bills, FBI agents recorded the visit. Arrest followed swiftly and she awaits trial.

Hammer and King wrote to Abshure July 5 (and also McDaniel and Jegley in similar vein) saying:

As you can see from the enclosures, there is some concern that improper trades or investments may have occurred in transactions involving the Office of the Treasurer, resulting in violations of applicable securities laws. Please review the enclosures and ascertain whether any of the individuals or firms licensed by your office, or any other parties, should be held to account for such violations. If you are not the appropriate authority to take action on such violations, please explain why and identify who you believe to be the appropriate authority.

One problem. None of the documents provided by Hammer and King present evidence of securities law violations. Suspicion — as when Shoffner started shoving huge amounts of business to a single broker (a fact this blog first reported almost two years ago) — can smell to high heaven but not constitute probable cause for investigation or charge. But Republicans are prone to order up investigations of people they'd like to find something to pin on. Remember Kenneth Starr?

In any case, Abshure has replied extensively to the request. He says that an investigation of the people over whom he has jurisdiction in this case — securities dealers and brokers — is underway. He noted he issued a letter of caution to involved securities dealers last August. Indeed, Abshure has worked closely with legislative audit and provided it a great deal of the information on which it based reports discussed at legislative hearings,.

Abshure's letter to King and Hammer explains what it takes to prove that a sale was actually RECOMMENDED by a broker and whether it was SUITABLE for the client. These are important in determining a law violation. They are terms with legal meanings beyond opinion and suspicion.

Abshure said, for example, unsuitability cannot be proved by simply saying, in hindsight, that a better result could have been obtained with a different purchase. He indicated, also, that evidence so far has fallen short of proving that treasurer's office purchases were made on "recommendation" of the dealer.

He said the ongoing criminal investigation has hampered his own continuing look into the matter, as well as a lack of a complaint from the customer (the state treasurer's office). He wrote in the letter:

The information contained in the enclosures to your July 5 letter does not, standing alone, constitute sufficient evidence of securities law violations. The Department has been and will continue to actively investigate this matter. Once the Department is satisfied that it has sufficient evidence of securities law violations, the Department will bring all appropriate enforcement actions in a manner tht poses the least interruption of parallel actions such as the pending criminal case.

Hammer and King's letters raised, in addition to securities law questions, the question of whether anyone had given perjured testimony before the auditing committee. And it noted, "Certain individuals were charged with federal...some were not charged with anything...and we feel that we need to do a good thorough job making sure that everybody that is responsible for any action in this situation is held accountable..."

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,


Speaking of...

  • Details on the $87 million for Lockheed Martin

    May 21, 2015
    J.R. Davis, the governor's press spokesman, provided me with some additional information on the $87 million state bond issue Gov. Asa Hutchinson wants to help Lockheed Martin expand a Camden facility to produce military vehicles, if it wins the federal contract. /more/
  • Hutchinson says bond issue for Lockheed Martin would be $87 million

    May 21, 2015
    Gov. Asa Hutchinson talked with reporters this morning about the items on his call for a special session to begin next Tuesday including $87 million in corporate welfare for a major defense contractor with a budget bigger than the state of Arkansas. Plus, a non-answer about that racist email from Hutchinson's appointee for state drug director, former legislator Denny Altes. /more/
  • KATV: Bill Walker's state agency approves grants to sister UPDATE

    May 19, 2015
    KATV has dug up on questionable public dealings by a familiar figure — former state Sen. Bill Walker, who headed the state Career Education Department during the administration of Gov. Mike Beebe. /more/
  • Marching to overturn Citizens United

    May 19, 2015
    Arkansas and national groups participated in a march this morning to demonstrate support for a constitutional amendment to overturn the Citizens United ruling by which the U.S. Supreme Court gave corporattions freedom to spend unlimited amounts on elections. /more/
  • Making the people’s voices louder than big money in Arkansas

    May 18, 2015
    People in Arkansas may have gotten fed up with the influx of cash and the endless barrage of attack ads, but now they are turning that anger into action. In recent months organizers have been working to get a question on the 2016 ballot requiring increased disclosure of political spending and calling for a constitutional amendment to overturn Supreme Court decisions like Citizens United that paved the way for unlimited outside spending in our elections. /more/
  • The bigoted past of new state drug director Denny Altes

    May 15, 2015
    We mentioned yesterday some of the lowlights of newly appointed state drug director Denny Altes' long career as a lawmaker, but I forgot perhaps Altes' lowest moment: In 2005, then state Sen. Altes and Sen. Jim Holt introduced a bill that would have required officials to verify that anyone voting or taking advantage of any sort of public assistance was a U.S. citizen. /more/
  • Denny Altes appointed state drug director

    May 14, 2015
    Former legislator Denny Altes, of Fort Smith, has been appointed by Gov. Asa Hutchinson to be the state's drug director. Longtime legislative watchers will remember Altes for introducing a lot of nutty legislation that never went anywhere. /more/
  • Early vote favors keeping Eureka Springs ordinance

    May 11, 2015
    Late this afternoon, Shannon Hix of Keep Eureka Fair reports that approximately 425 early votes were cast in the election. (418 have been cast at the Eureka Springs early voting site and a handful of eligible Eureka Springs voters showed up at a Berryville early voting site.) In a town where just 792 votes were cast in the November midterm elections, this is fairly remarkable early voting activity. /more/
  • Broker who bribed Treasurer Martha Shoffner ordered to pay $20,000 fine in final order

    May 8, 2015
    Yesterday, a hearing officer assigned to hear two financial securities cases related to former Arkansas Treasurer Marsha Shoffner issued a final order on the matter of Steele Stephens, the broker at St. Bernard Financial Services of Russellville who bribed Shoffner to obtain a higher volume of the state's bond business. /more/
  • Dennis Milligan refuses to answer questions about email scandal

    May 8, 2015
    Treasurer Dennis Milligan bobs and weaves...well, scratch that, he really doesn't even bother trying. He just refuses to answer questions about the activities of his office. /more/
  • More »

Comments (12)

Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Most Shared

  • Womack gets plucked by 'Last Week Tonight with John Oliver'

    HBO's "Last Week Tonight with John Oliver, which premiered last April, has consistently shown itself to be a Daily Show-level contender for the humor-news crown. Up for discussion on the show last night: the myriad ways major poultry producers exploit chicken farmers. Also featured in the video: Arkansas Republican Rep. Steve Womack, who gets plucked and roasted for placing a rider on the agriculture appropriations bill that forbids the USDA from enforcing already-written protections for the nation's poultry farmers.
  • Magazine obtains police report over Josh Duggar sexual molestation investigation; he admits past 'mistakes,' resigns Family Council job

    In Touch magazine reports that it has obtained a Springdale police report containing allegations of sexual misconduct against an unnamed teen that it says it has confirmed was Josh Duggar, a minor at the time and now a prominent lobbyist for the Family Research Council and a leading voice for legal discrimination against gay people.
  • State budget administrator Brandon Sharp fired; no reason given

    KATV reports that Brandon Sharp was fired Monday afternoon after four years as state budget administrator, a $101,000-a-year job in the Department of Finance and Administration.
  • KATV: Bill Walker's state agency approves grants to sister UPDATE

    KATV has dug up on questionable public dealings by a familiar figure — former state Sen. Bill Walker, who headed the state Career Education Department during the administration of Gov. Mike Beebe.
  • What's not to love about the Bentonville Film Festival? Walmart.

    The Bentonville Film Festival, launched this year by actress Geena Davis and held earlier this month from May 5-9, earned a number of largely positive notices from major outlets like the Huffington Post ("At the Bentonville Film Festival, Women Are Playing in the Major Leagues"), the L.A. Times ("Bentonville Film Festival pushes diversity message from year one") and the New York Times ("Bentonville, Ark., Hosts a Film Festival Without a Movie Theater"), most of them centering on its unique and vital agenda — promoting diversity and gender equality in filmmaking — and its celebrity cache (e.g. an acting workshop taught by Robert De Niro, a softball game led by Rosie O'Donnell, etc.).

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments



© 2015 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation