Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

The metallurgical report on the Mayflower pipeline break just went public

Posted By on Wed, Jul 31, 2013 at 8:53 PM

  • Hurst Metallurgical report

So, that forensic metallurgical report ExxonMobil ordered after its Pegasus Pipeline split. You want it. We got it.

You can read the full report, by Hurst Metallurgical Research Laboratory Inc., at this link. Unless you work for that firm, Exxon, or the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), or you happen to be a bellicose elected official in Arkansas, this is probably the first chance you’ve had to eyeball these 200-plus pages of verbal Ambien. It contains Hurst's take on why the old pipeline burst and dumped hundreds of thousands of gallons of oil into the streets and yards and waterways of Mayflower.

A few noteworthy passages:

The subject section of the 20" Patoka to Corsicana #1-20" North Pipeline, the segment from Conway to Corsicana, consisted of approximately 50' long sections of 20" O.D. x 0.312" thick wall DC Electric Resistance Welded (ERW) pipe that was manufactured in 1947 and 1948 by Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company in Youngstown, Ohio. — pg. 2

Prior to failure, the pipeline was reported to typically operate between 47°F and 78° at pressures ranging between 240 psig and 820 psig. — pg. 3

The basic pipe bio. The split measured 22 feet long on one 50-foot section of pipe.

No trees, roads, or buildings were located directly above the pipeline where the fracture occurred. As shown in Photograph No. 1, two (2) homes were built in close proximity to the pipeline, with driveways crossing over the pipeline at two (2) points downstream of the fractured segment. During construction of the homes, the pipeline may have experienced vehicle loadings caused by construction equipment and/or vehicles crossing the pipeline at multiple locations, including over the fractured segment. There was no indication of construction, digging, localized flooding, or other ground movements in the area of the fractured segment occurring during or immediately prior to the pipeline rupture. —pg. 3

If you look at an aerial map of Mayflower, you’ll see the pipe's path cuts mostly through rural stretches like a scar. For the break to occur beneath a neighborhood seems unlikely, if the site were randomly picked along the 850-mile pipeline. The report at least gives a nod to possible causation there.

The hook cracks initiated and followed the brittle upturned grain flow lines or bands that were created during the manufacturing of the pipe due to effects of the stresses induced by hydrostatic testing, thermal stresses, residual stresses, and/or pressure cycles. The hook cracks may not have all occurred simultaneously … and potential microcracks in the upset/heat-affected zones may have then merged due to stresses during service. — pg. 31

  • Hurst Metallurgical report

This passage appears to give some lie to any reading that says the break owed only to “manufacturing defects” (also pg. 31). After Exxon reviewed the report, it stated publicly that “the independent laboratory concluded that the root cause of the failure can be attributed to original manufacturing defects — namely hook cracks near the seam.” While that may be so, the report also doesn’t ignore the actual use of the pipe as a contributing factor. That may seem patently obvious, but as we’ve seen for the past four months, there are no apparent breaks in the old pipe when no one is pushing 95,000 gallons of oil through it daily.

This report hasn’t been made publicly available until now. Exxon spokesman Aaron Stryk emailed an InsideClimate News reporter July 11 to explain that “It is up to PHMSA when they decide to make the report publically available.” We’ve emailed Stryk to see whether he has any response to this post and will update it if he responds.

Without having seen the report, Richard Kuprewicz, president of the pipeline consulting firm Accufacts Inc., commented to InsideClimate News that “not disclosing the forensic metallurgical report is nuts” and “that’s stuff that’s eventually going to be made public.” (Kuprewicz is now consulting for Central Arkansas Water.)

This still leaves a couple of documents pertaining to the oil spill investigation lurking in the weeds. The most interesting one is the inline inspection report that Exxon made of the Pegasus in the month before it broke. Stryk has previously gone on record saying those data are still being analyzed.

Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel, whose office filed suit against Exxon in June, said Wednesday that he’s pushing for all the germane reports to be released. “The sooner they are made public, the sooner scrutiny from independent experts and journalists can begin,” he said. “But I'm not being critical in saying who's holding up the process. I'm just calling for those who can expedite release to expedite release.”

Asked whether Exxon could be slow-pedaling that process, he said that hasn’t been Exxon's M.O. to date.

“He who controls the information has the upper hand in such a technical situation as this,” McDaniel said. “I have, however, not seen [Exxon] withholding information from me or from PHMSA that I know of. I think they've had some pretty cold-hearted policy positions and they've had some pretty unpleasant public relations stumbles. But I cannot at this point say that they have not been cooperative with our requests for them to produce information.”

Elizabeth Douglass of InsideClimate News contributed to this report, which is part of a joint investigative project by Arkansas Times and InsideClimate News. Funding for the report comes from people like you who donated to an crowdfunding campaign and for the Fund for Investigative Journalism.

Tags: , ,

Speaking of Mayflower Oil Spill, exxonmobil

Comments (6)

Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

More by Sam Eifling

Readers also liked…

  • McDaniel announces air test results in Mayflower oil spill homes

    Attorney General Dustin McDaniel today announced results of air tests in 14 homes in Mayflower in the area of spill of Canadian tar sands crude from the ruptured ExxonMobil Pegasus pipeline.
    • May 9, 2013
  • Health impact of oil spills — a medical dilemma

    Inside Climate News has new reporting today on potential health risks from exposure to chemicals put into the environment in oil spills such as the Canadian tar sands that exploded from the burst ExxonMobil pipeline in Mayflower.
    • Jul 3, 2013
  • ExxonMobil ending housing assistance for Mayflower spill victims

    Sam Eifling, newly at work for us on our Mayflower oil spill project with Inside Climate News, is at work on a news story about ExxonMobil's notice to owners of property in the Mayflower subdivision soiled by the pipeline burst that the oil giant is cutting off temporary housing assistance Sept. 1 to displaced residents.
    • Jul 25, 2013

People who saved…

Most Shared

  • Photos from March for TC

    Last night, dozens of friends of TC Edwards, the Little Rock musician and man on the scene who was found murdered Dec. 7, marched in his memory, chanting "Justice for TC" and "TC is metal" as they walked from Pizza D' Action up Kavanaugh.
  • Psych of the South: The Mercenaries' 'Things Found Here'

    Recently, a trove of band business cards from the golden era of Arkansas garage bands was discovered and put on eBay. I was able to purchase some of them, including one by a little known 1960s garage band from Little Rock named The Mercenaries. Their record, on the cult favorite MY records label based in Little Rock, was released in early 1967. Their songs, including the atmospheric and heavy “Things Found Here” along with the psychedelic tinged “Take It All” are obscure even by garage rock standards. They were not featured on the 1999 Butler Center MY records compilation and their story has not been told before
  • Good policies, bad politics

    Democrats are like Republicans in one way. One party or the other suffers devastating losses at least every eight years and then engages in a noisy search for blame and atonement.
  • Women's work in the House

    The new Republican majority in Arkansas came with the support of female majorities in some key races.
  • The Duggar clan provides big boost, unintentionally, for gay kids

    Still more good news for Lucie's Place, the small Little Rock nonprofit that works to help homeless LGBT youths. It's added a $10,000 grant to $30,000 raised in a symbolic response to the Duggar family's support for discrimination against gay people in Fayetteville.

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments



© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation