Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Tom Cotton's pants-on-fire claim about congressional exemption from Obamacare

Posted By on Tue, Sep 10, 2013 at 3:30 PM

click to enlarge DISHONEST DEMAGOGUERY: Tom Cotton does it again.
  • DISHONEST DEMAGOGUERY: Tom Cotton does it again.
Club for Growth U.S. Rep. Tom Cotton is flogging a popular topic of the rabid right today — touting his legislation (which will go nowhere in any case) that purports to prevent the Office of Personnel Management from "unlawfully" providing health care subsidies for members of Congress and their staffs.

Did Obama really do such a thing?

* No. Says factcheck.org.

* No. Says Rachel Maddow. 

* No. Says The New Republic, which calls it the "latest Obamacare lie that won't die."

* No. Says Media Matters.

* No. Says Jonathan Chait.

* No. Says Ezra Klein. 

It's all about fixing a problem created by political gamesmanship that could have prevented the federal government from paying its normal contribution to employees' health insurance. But it's become a beloved right-wing talking point and Cotton, Obama's soulmate on missiles, needs to get some cred back with that group.

The best I can find in support of Cotton's dishonest representation is PolitiFact, often willing to give lying Republicans the benefit of the doubt (it's scored Cotton before, however.) It called a claim by a Republican critic like Cotton on the supposed sweetheart treatment for Congress  "half true."

Handel said Congress negotiated itself a special rule to prevent its health care benefits from rising. She’s used the words "exception" and "exemption" to describe what happened.

Congress, according to several news accounts and a GOP senator, was pushing to get this done, although it came from an order by the Obama administration. Most conservatives describe the decision as an exemption. The OPM says the rule is a continuation of past policies for funding health care coverage for congressional workers and their bosses.

Handel’s basic claim seems to be in the ballpark. But it needs a lot of context to be fully understood.

It’s true that members of Congress and some of their staffs will continue to have an employer contribution toward their health insurance premiums. But they will also still have to go through the health care exchanges like other people.

Republicans like Cotton have never met a complicated situation they couldn't reduce to a dishonest whopper  so appealing in form that it's too good to check out. Look at this one. Why wouldn't you think a member of Congress would go along with a sweetheart deal? Easy to believe. Sorry. Tom Cotton's pants are on fire.

UPDATE: Cotton insists that he believes the law doesn't allow the Office of Personnel Management to make payments toward employee insurance.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Speaking of...

  • The Max Despairs Edition

    September 12, 2014
    The latest on statewide political races, Leslie Rutledge’s past, top secret divorces in Faulkner County, a victory for Little Rock private clubs and something rotten happening in Crittenden County — all covered on this week's podcast. /more/
  • Democrats holding their own in TV spending in Arkansas

    September 12, 2014
    U.S. Sen. Mark Pryor is holding his own against Republican Tom Cotton in terms of money spent on TV advertising in their race for U.S. Senate, a new analysis shows. /more/
  • UAMS reports improved outlook thanks to Obamacare; UALR talks about neighborhood improvements

    September 11, 2014
    UAMS Chancellor Dan Rahn reported an improving financial situation at the medical center thanks in part to help from the Affordable Care Act. /more/
  • Pryor and Cotton to debate on Oct. 14

    September 11, 2014
    Rep. Tom Cotton has finally gotten on board a televised debate with Sen. Mark Pryor sponsored by the Fayetteville Chamber of Commerce. It will be broadcast from 7 to 8 p.m. Oct. 14 (a Tuesday) by KATV, KAIT and KHBS/KHOG. Roby Brock of Talk Business and Politics will moderate, joined by three TV reporters. /more/
  • GOP rule No. 1: Win

    September 11, 2014
    The Republican Party's devotion to principle was on display last week. After months of opposition to a proposed initiated act to raise the Arkansas minimum wage, Republican gubernatorial candidate Asa Hutchinson flip-flopped to say he'd vote for the measure. /more/
  • The turnout game and alcohol

    September 11, 2014
    Recent polls showing the divergence of "likely" and "registered" Arkansas voters clarifies that the outcome of the major 2014 races on the Arkansas ballot will be determined by turnout. /more/
  • Obama vs. GOP philosophy

    September 11, 2014
    If you have followed the Arkansas election ads you know that each party faces a single challenge. Republicans must overcome a philosophy problem, Democrats an Obama problem. /more/
  • The Kochs, Tom Cotton and their dislike of helping farmers

    September 10, 2014
    The Koch political lobby is trying mightily to pretend it supports American farmers and that Tom Cotton's vote against the farm bill isn't a measure of farm support. A new report from a Democratic organization blows that dishonest messaging out of the water. /more/
  • Another Arkansas benefit Tom Cotton would chop

    September 9, 2014
    Hot Springs will get $200,000 from the Economic Development Administration to develop an economic strategy. The Democratic Party notes that Rep. Tom Cotton, who represents Hot Springs, wanted to abolish the Economic Development Administration as wasteful. /more/
  • The Pryors hit the campaign trail

    September 9, 2014
    With Sen. Mark Pryor in Washington, his family surrogates — parents David and Barbara Pryor — are hitting the campaign trail hard with a round of scheduled visits to college campuses meant to underscore Republican opponent Tom Cotton's vote against the federal student loan program. /more/
  • More »

Comments (5)

Showing 1-5 of 5

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-5 of 5

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Readers also liked…

  • How extreme is Tom Cotton? Part IV

    A Washington Monthly reporter joins the ranks of people marveling at the extremist rhetoric that flows from the mouth of Tom Cotton, the Beltway consultant who rented a place in Arkansas to be elected with Club for Growth money to 4th District Congress.
    • Jan 10, 2013
  • Mike Huckabee rips the Club for Growth

    It's not the shortest book in the world, but I'm still happy to add a chapter to the fairly slender volume: "When Mike Huckabee is Right He's Right" Here it's for a subject he's worked out on before: A denunciation of the Club for Growth, a tiny group of zillionaires financed over the years heavily by Jackson T. Stephens Jr. of Little Rock.
    • Jul 24, 2013
  • Huckabee backer indicted

    Jay Odom, a developer of property in Destin, Fla., where former Gov. Mike Huckabee now lives, surrendered to federal authorities this morning after his indictment on charges that he illegally channeled $23,000 to Huckabee's 2008 campaign for the Republican presidential nomination.
    • Jan 23, 2013

Most Shared

  • Not giving up on Fred

    We ended up adopting Fred due to his incorrigible stubbornness. Originally bred to track game, basset hounds can be amazingly persistent. It sometimes appears that when their noses are working, their hearing shuts down.
  • Private clubs win early closing battle

    Private clubs apparently have won their battle against earlier closing hours, based on a "compromise" revealed at the City Board meeting last night.
  • Prosecutors have all the power

    But little oversight. Is a violation not a violation if a prosecutor says, 'I didn't mean to'?
  • The Kochs, Tom Cotton and their dislike of helping farmers

    The Koch political lobby is trying mightily to pretend it supports American farmers and that Tom Cotton's vote against the farm bill isn't a measure of farm support. A new report from a Democratic organization blows that dishonest messaging out of the water.
  • Lawsuit says Crittenden Regional Hospital charged employees for health insurance premiums but never paid claims

    A lawsuit filed on Friday in the Circuit Court of Crittenden County alleges that at least beginning in 2014, Crittenden Regional Hospital (CRH) withheld money from employees' paychecks for health insurance premiums, but never actually paid the claims. That would potentially leave their employees on the hook for tens of thousands of dollars in medical care they were told was covered by their health insurance. The practice may have dated back even further, said Denny Sumpter, the attorney for the plaintiffs.

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Blogroll

 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation