Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Thursday, April 17, 2014

Tom Cotton continues to avoid taking stance on private option

Posted By on Thu, Apr 17, 2014 at 1:21 PM

click to enlarge cotton_3.jpg
We've noted before that while Rep. Tom Cotton wants to repeal Obamacare (which would have the effect of ending the private option), he refuses to take a position on whether the state made the right decision in pursuing the private option policy, which uses Medicaid funds to purchase health insurance for low-income Arkansans. 

Cotton was asked about the private option by a constituent at a townhall event focused on health care in Waldron last Monday (no media was present; someone in attendance sent the Arkansas Blog an audio recording of the meeting). 

A constituent named Leonard asked about the "part of [Medicaid] that our legislature was so nice give the government the opportunity to come in here for three years and establish Medicare [he actually means Medicaid] the way they want it and put all the bells and whistles on it and at the end of three years, after three years is up we're stuck with the bill and we have to pay the whole amount — but the legislature wasn't smart enough to figure out how we're going to pay for this after it gets here."

Rep. Terry Rice, a state representative opposed to the private option who is now running for state Senate interjected to clarify that Leonard was talking about Medicaid. 

"Medicaid, sorry, not Medicare," Leonard said. "[Rice] is one of the ones that didn’t vote for it, so I’m not talking about him."

Cotton: "Yeah, I was going to let him answer it."

Leonard asks Cotton, "What I want to know is, is there anything that's going to help us out on that? If it comes to that — if we can’t get rid of this Obamacare?"

Cotton responds: "Well, Terry, correct me if I’m wrong because I’m not well versed in the details of the law, but y’all do have some kind of circuit breaker so that if we do repeal or change the reimbursement rates for the state, the program is reduced or even eliminated, right?

"There are triggers in there," Rice responded and then switched to talking about the decision by Insurance Commissioner Jay Bradford to take advantage of a decision by the Obama administration and allow Arkansans to keep non-compliant health insurance plans through the fall of 2017. 

Cotton eventually circled back to Leonard's question about the private option: 

My understanding is that Kathleen Sebelius and Beebe might have had a good working relationship from their time as Governors together, and you know, at the time when they were striking that deal Sebelius and the President were desperate for any state to join into the Medicaid expansion, so they were willing to give away lots of things. I think surprised a lot of your colleagues, right Terry? But, the history of these programs is not the history of Washington upholding its end of the bargain or giving states more flexibility. The history of these programs — and that’s not just in the health care realm — of any program that is joint federal and state, is Washington continuing to impose more requirements and red tape no matter what amount of money they give. Education is a good example. Washington provides seven percent of our education dollars in this country and usually tries to dictate 100 percent of the control. So, I’m worried about that for Arkansas. I’m also worried about it for our country and the consequences for our deficit as well. I think in the long run what we need to do is get Washington out of the role of micromanaging the states and let the states address the needs of their population.

Now, Arkansas did expand Medicaid in a way that — has any other state followed suit?  It was only done because that part of Obamacare was ruled unconstitutional. I mean, initially, I think, this is what an affront, it goes to show you, it gets back to the gist of  your question, Terry, what Washington thinks about the states. Obamacare initially said we will give you this pot of money to expand your Medicaid population, and if you don’t take it you will not only lose this pot of money that’s new, you’ll lose all your old Medicaid money for the elderly and the blind and disabled and for poor children. And the Supreme Court said that is such an affront to the sovereignty of states and our constitutional system that it’s unconstitutional. They struck down that part of Obamacare. But, I worry that if we don’t let states craft solutions for their own populations that Medicaid is going to continue to grow and grow and grow; and that’s not just in Arkansas, that’s in other states as well, but we pay for it.

If you can divine what Cotton's position is on the private option from all that, more power to you. It sounds to me like Leonard wanted to know Cotton's take on the private option specifically and Cotton dodged. 

(Worth noting that Cotton highlights "circuit breakers" — triggers in the law that would end the private option if the feds stop providing the matching rates promised in the Affordable Care Act — a feature often cited by the law's proponents and dismissed or disparaged by the law's opponents.)

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Speaking of...

  • Manic Monday open line

    September 29, 2014
    Our video roundup covers today's news. /more/
  • The debate over Pryor-Cotton debates

    September 29, 2014
    The tedious debate over debates continues, with the Cotton campaign slamming Mark Pryor for not agreeing to the KARK debate and the Pryor campaign slamming Tom Cotton for not agreeing to the AETN debate. /more/
  • World Trade Center Arkansas receives grant from Economic Development Administration, which Tom Cotton voted to abolish

    September 29, 2014
    Sen. Mark Pryor, along with Republicans Sen. John Boozman, Rep. Steve Womack and Rep. Tim Griffin, were on hand today in Rogers to announce a $600,000 federal grant for the World Trade Center Arkansas, an affiliate of the University of Arkansas. The federal money will be used "to expand its outreach services to diversify and strengthen the state’s economy," according to the university. The funds were available via the Economic Development Administration, which Tom Cotton voted to abolish. /more/
  • State of the Cotton-Pryor race

    September 29, 2014
    All of the polling aggregation and forecast models currently give Tom Cotton the advantage over Mark Pryor, in some cases a substantial one. The race is by no means over and is indeed close — even the most pessimistic models still give Pryor a one in five chance of prevailing. But if these forecasts are to be believed, Cotton is a clear favorite at this point. /more/
  • The minimum wage issue in Senate races, and why Tom Cotton and Asa Hutchinson choose not to take a principled stand

    September 29, 2014
    Joni Ernst, the GOP candidate in a tough battle for a U.S. Senate seat in Iowa, is taking a big risk with her opposition to a hike of the state minimum wage. Here in Arkansas, Tom Cotton and Asa Hutchinson are taking no such risk, with their transparent election-year ploy — as soon as the wage hike initiative made the ballot, they suddenly said they were for it. And we applaud them for their support! Just don't call it principled. /more/
  • The not-so-principled stand of Tom Cotton on the minimum wage

    September 28, 2014
    Finger-in-the-wind political maneuvering doesn't get much more stark than Republican Senate candidate Tom Cotton announcing earlier this month that he would support the ballot initiative to raise the state minimum wage. Cotton's endorsement of the minimum wage hike was presumably meant to neutralize the minimum wage issue in this campaign, which Sen. Mark Pryor might have used as a political cudgel. But Cotton's brand — and his defense on controversial votes — is that he always takes the principled stand, even if it's difficult or unpopular. /more/
  • Chuck Todd proposes KARK debate; Tom Cotton accepts, no response yet from Mark Pryor

    September 28, 2014
    During a taped segment Friday with local KARK-4 reporter David Goins, NBC's Meet the Press host Chuck Todd suggested that the two co-host a debate between Senate candidates Tom Cotton and Mark Pryor, with Todd suggesting that he would come down to Little Rock for the event. /more/
  • Tom Cotton's 2000 law review article on the Arkansas ballot initiative

    September 27, 2014
    Tom Cotton's 2000 article in the Arkansas Law Review displays young Cotton's distrust of populism and his exaltation of the wise and virtuous few selected to represent the people. /more/
  • Tennessee continues to look for Medicaid expansion deal; expansion states see big reduction in uncompensated care

    September 27, 2014
    Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam is continuing intensive discussions with the feds over a deal for the state to expand Medicaid. Haslam has reportedly been interested in some elements of the Arkansas-style private option, but has had trouble finding an agreement palatable with the federal Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Meanwhile, earlier this week HHS released a report finding that hospitals are facing $5.7 billion less in uncompensated care costs because of Obamacare, with states that expanded Medicaid getting the bulk of that benefit (about three quarters of the reduction took place in the expansion states). /more/
  • The Tom Cotton 99 Pinocchios Edition

    September 26, 2014
    Tom Cotton and the farm bill flap that won’t die, a blow to disability rights in Arkansas and a vote to extend Little Rock School District Superintendent Dexter Suggs — all covered on this week's podcast. /more/
  • More »

Comments (8)

Showing 1-8 of 8

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-8 of 8

Add a comment

More by David Ramsey

Most Shared

  • How the South became dead red

    Good piece in Politico from Stanford sociology professor Doug McAdam on the roots of our modern partisan divide. McAdam tells the familiar story of how the South flipped, as yellow dog Democrats in the old Confederacy abandoned the party in the wake of the Civil Rights movement.
  • Fact-checkers unaninmous: Tom Cotton is a liar

    Tom Cotton has hit the fact-checking trifecta: All three major fact-checking operations says his ad blaming his vote against the farm bill on President Obama is dishonest.
  • Bill Clinton sounds caution on charter schools

    A singular voice, former president Bill Clinton, sounded a note of caution about charter schools in a speech in New York yesterday and thank goodness.
  • Fayetteville City Clerk's office certifies signatures — civil rights ordinance will go to a public vote

    The Fayetteville City Clerk's office has certified that enough signatures were gathered to trigger a special election on Fayetteville's new civil rights ordinance, the Fayetteville Flyer reports. The effort to force a popular vote on the ordinance, led by a Repeal 119, a church-led group, gathered 5,714 signatures. Petitioners needed 4,905; the City Clerk's office began certifying the signatures last week and stopped at the end of the day Friday once enough signatures had been validated. The ordinance to discourage discrimination in housing and employment passed in the City Council 6-2 last month. The vote came after 10 hours of discussion, with many conservatives furious because the classes of people protected included gay and transgender people.
  • Tom Cotton's evasive maneuvering on the Farm Bill

    Rep. Tom Cotton continues to take a ribbing for his recent ad attempting cover on his vote against the Farm Bill (Cotton, you'll remember, claimed that Obama "hijacked" it and turned it into a food stamp bill; factcheckers pounced). Cotton is trying to have his row crops and eat them too, claiming he supports farm subsidies while voting against them.

Most Viewed

  • Hot Springs firing range declared a "Muslim free zone" by its owner

    The owner of The Gun Cave Indoor Shooting Range in Hot Springs, Jan Morgan, announced yesterday that she is banning the presence of Muslims in her business. Her reasoning: "Why would I hand guns and ammunition to people whose religion commands them to kill me and my non-muslim patrons?" OK, let's get that lawsuit rolling.
  • Bench warrant issued in disappearance of Beverly Carter — UPDATE

    A bench warrant has been issued for a man named Aaron M. Lewis on one count of kidnapping in the disappearance of Beverly Carter, 51, a Crye-Leike real estate agent who disappeared after going to show a house on Thursday afternoon. With updated information as of 10:30 p.m..
  • Beverly Carter's body found in shallow grave on Highway 5 in northern Pulaski County

    The Pulaski sheriff's office reported early this morning that the body of Beverly Carter, the real estate agent apparently abducted while showing a home near Scott Thursday evening, had been found in a shallow grad near Cabot. The charges against Arron Lewis, her suspected abuctor, have been upgraded to capital murder.

Most Recent Comments



© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation