Thursday, September 4, 2014

Arkansas Supreme Court refuses recusal motion in same-sex marriage case

Posted By on Thu, Sep 4, 2014 at 9:37 AM

The Arkansas Supreme Court, back from recess today, issued an order that pdenied without comment plaintiffs' request that judges facing future elections disqualify from hearing the case.

Pulaski Circuit Judge Chris Piazza struck down the state's statutory and constitutional bans on same-sex marriage as unconstitutional denial of equal protection and due process. The state appealed.

Early in August, attorneys for the plaintiffs asked that judges facing future elections to recuse from the case. The request cited legislative action that could raise questions about impartiality of judges hearing the case. This referred to passage of a Legislative Council resolution by Sen. Jason Rapert, a foe of same-sex marriage. The resolution, which was hand-delivered to the Supreme Court, said the legislature would pursue legislative remedies to prevent the popular will from being thwarted by "judicial activism." Legislators have said this could include proposing for the ballot a judicial recall mechanism in 2016. Some legislators have also talked of impeachment of judges who ruled in favor of same-sex marriage.

Two of the court's seven justices — Donald Corbin and Cliff Hoofman — are not seeking election and will leave the court at the end of the year. Three judges, Chief Justice Jim Hannah and Justices Paul Danielson and Jo Hart, are considered unlikely to seek office again because of a state law that requires judges to forfeit retirement benefits if they seek election again after age 70. But they could run. That leaves two justices with likely future races — Courtney Goodson and Karen Baker. Goodson has reportedly been making the rounds of lawyers to line up support for a race for chief justice in 2016. Baker was unopposed for re-election this year.

The attorneys — Jack Wagoner and Cheryl Maples — had said they didn't think the justices would fail to be impartial, but said the appearance would exist because of the legislative action. Wagoner said today:

"We assume that the Justices have looked at the issue and made the right decision and that’s all we asked them to do."

CORRECTION: I wrote incorrectly initially that the order also approved friend-of-the-court briefs in the case. That actually was a decision pertaining to the pending Voter ID law appeal. No amicus brief requests are pending in the marriage case.



Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Arkansas Times Recommends: A Literary Edition

    Arkansas Times Recommends is a series in which Times staff members (or whoever happens to be around at the time) highlight things we've been enjoying this week.
    • Jul 1, 2016
  • Little Rock camera catches package removal

    Thanks to KARK for a report on a home owner's surveillance camera that caught a piece of film of a young man picking up a package delivered minutes before by UPS and leaving.
    • Jul 1, 2016
  • The long weekend open line

    Here's the open line and the daily news video.
    • Jul 1, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Mountain Home church leader cursed for inclusiveness

    Arkansas gets some unwanted (if deserved) web attention on Crooks and Liars: From Alice Hurley, Minister,
    • Nov 12, 2014
  • The Lemon Cakery is pure bliss

    In the eternal and often epic battle between "cake" and "pie," I normally come down on the pie side of things. The Lemon Cakery puts that rule to the test—deliciously.
    • Oct 1, 2015
  • The French Hill 'tis better to receive-than-give open line

    An open line that features new Congressman French HIll's antipathy in the Catholic newspaper to Obamacare as a "giveaway" to drug companies and hospitals. A Catholic nurse points out that children and other people in need are the real beneficiaries of this giveaway, along with Catholic hospitals.
    • Nov 15, 2014

Most Shared

  • Defense for Suhl asks judge to dismiss bribery indictment, citing Supreme Court decision in McDonnell case

    Attorneys for the businessman argue that his cash payments to a former deputy director of DHS, Steven Jones, did not constitute corruption. They say prosecutors cannot prove the money was given in exchange for any particular "official act" from Jones.
  • Nursing home bribery case details suspect judicial fund-raising

    Plaintiffs' lawyers made their case today to continue to trial with the civil suit over then-Judge Mike Maggio's reduction of a $5.2 million jury verdict in a nursing home negligence case to $1 million, a reduction he said he made in return for campaign contributions from the nursing home's owner.
  • Arkansas Heirloom Tomatoes at Edwards Food Giant for the Fourth of July weekend

    We are receiving 200-pounds of large heirloom tomatoes Friday morning from Times publisher and farmer Alan Leveritt. We have dark, brick red Carbons, Goldies (large, high acid golden tomatoes) and Annis Noire, a delicious French heirloom that is green with red marbling when ripe.
  • When America was great

    Donald Trump is right. There was a time when America was great and it didn't pussyfoot around to avoid offending people who thought they were victimized by discrimination. It was, let's see, the period after World War II, when everyone prospered and America was kicking butts, at home and abroad, and Arkansas's leaders were at the center of it.
  • Resistance grows nationally to freeway expansions

    The U.S. Public Interest Research Group has issued a news release about freeway expansion with relevance in Little Rock. It's about wasting money to widen freeways that only create more congestion. Sound familiar?

Most Recent Comments



© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation