Wednesday, February 25, 2015

Senate committee defeats Ballinger's anti-gay bill, also a Sharia law attack

Posted By on Wed, Feb 25, 2015 at 1:34 PM

click to enlarge DANGEROUS DUO: Bart Hester (lefrt) and Bob Ballinger have led the way on legislation intended to ensure protection for legal discrimination against gay people. In the name of religious freedom. - BRIAN CHILSON
  • Brian Chilson
  • DANGEROUS DUO: Bart Hester (lefrt) and Bob Ballinger have led the way on legislation intended to ensure protection for legal discrimination against gay people. In the name of religious freedom.

The Senate Judiciary Committee, after extended debate, today refused to endorse HB 1228, Rep. Bob Ballinger's "conscience protection" bill that is intended to allow people to claim religion as a pretext for discriminating against gay people.

The measure failed  on a 4-3 vote, with five needed for recommendation. The four Republicans on the committee — Jeremy Hutchinson, Linda Collins-Smith, Terry Rice and Jon Woods voted aye. Sens. Joyce Elliott, David Johnson and Linda Chesterfield voted no. David Burnett voted present, the same as a no. Hutchinson invited them to return. His uncle, Gov. Asa Hutchinson, had expressed some reservations about unintended consequences and said amendments might be possible.

Sen. Bart Hester, who sponsored another gay-discrimination bill this session, added an amendment that exempted private employers from being sued by a "religious" person over offense to their beliefs. Only an offensive state action could prompt a lawsuit against a state actor. It's not much of a solution. Any number of state actors could do things that offended the "religious." The amendment does nothing, of course, to help a gay person who's been denied a hamburger, an apartment or a job because of his or her sexuality.

The bill could be pulled from committee to the Senate floor, a maneuver that requires only a simple majority of the overwhelmingly Republican chamber. Republicans as a party here and nationally are opposed to equal treatment of gay people. Hester's SB 202, which just became law, prevents local protections for gay people. It and Ballinger's bill arose from opposition to the Fayetteville civil rights ordinance aimed at protecting LGBT people.

Ballinger claimed again, that it was almost innocuous, a bill to require strict scrutiny (a high standard) to do something for which someone claims religious protection.

"All we're trying to say is that a person has a right to believe what they want to believe." Nobody challenged Ballinger. But the point of the bill is to prevent equal treatment of gay people, even if it has no effect on anyone's beliefs.

"It would strike a balance between religion and the law," Ballinger said. It would be a balance, however, that heavily favored an imposition of religion on actions of others.

Sen. David Johnson said, "this launches us into uncharted and worrisome territory." Sen. Joyce Elliott offered the example of a prison warden who refused to carry out an execution on religious grounds. Ballinger said another employee could be found.

John Wilkerson, an attorney for the Arkansas Municipal League, opposed the bill. He said Texas passed such a bill and there's been a three-fold increase in religious claims that have cost cities money to defend. If the bill passes there could be dozens of lawsuits in cities where they've passed ordinances protecting LGBT people. In other states, he said a Buddhist temple had sued claiming exemption from parking regulations and he said the Texas law has produced different rules for religious and non-religious halfway houses. He offered the example of two book clubs — one studying an Ayn Rand book and the other a Christian group studying the Bible. He said the Bible group could claim exemption from parking regulations, the Ayn Rand group could not.

"We know it's going to cost us something," Wilkerson said. "We're worried it's going to cost us a lot."

Paul Byrd, a Little Rock lawyer, spoke for the bill. He said citizens should have a fundamental right to have religious beliefs protected by strict scrutiny.

Bill Kopsky of the Arkansas Public Policy Panel said the bill would return Arkansas "to some of our darkest days of discrimination."

Mark Whitmore, with the Association of Arkansas Counties, said while state agencies cannot be sued, individual people can. "This bill, this verbiage, is not consistent with federal law." He said it will add complexity and expense.

Judge Wendell Griffen, speaking for the church he pastors and the Arkansas Interfaith Alliance, said he was born in 1952 and lived first-hand under Jim Crow. "Jim Crow relied on religious grounds. I can quote you chapter and verse." He said a neighboring church has a substance abuse program. If the bill passes, he said the churches would have to hire a lawyer to fight if someone who lived in the neighborhood said they had a religious right not to be around people with substance abuse problems.

An Army veteran, Griffen said the law would allow a pacifist Quaker to refuse him service because he's a veteran.

Ballinger said the law was nothing new and rooted in the Civil Rights Act of 1963. Griffen agreed. "This is nothing new .... this is 1896 old, Plessy versus Ferguson, and it is wicked." The system guarantees not only freedom of religion but freedom from religion, he said. "Please do not take us back down this dark path."

For a time at least, the path is closed. I doubt it's over.

The Stonewall Democrats commented:

HB1228 is a thinly veiled effort to use religion to advance animus intent toward the LGBT
community through the legislative process.

We are encouraged that the Judicial Committee voted against HB1228 but our efforts to expose the true animus intent of both SB202 and HB1228 continues.

We ask a legislator to bravely step forward and present a bill to amend the Arkansas Civil Rights Act. The true intent behind SB202 and HB1228 will be evident if a bill is introduced to add five simple words to the Arkansas Civil Rights Act: sexual orientation and gender identity.

If legislators vote no to add those five simple words, the tattered veil hiding the animus intent of

SB202 and HB1228 will flutter away and the discriminatory intent will be in the open for all to see. 

ALSO: Some colorful debate preceded a committee decision not to endorse Sen. John Cooper's bill to prevent consideration of foreign laws in Arkansas courts. This appears to be one of those anti-Sharia law bills that have become popular among right-wingers around the country.

— Reporting by David Koon

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Speaking of...

Comments (17)

Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Courting trouble

    The Arkansas Bar Association voted recently to recommend that the Arkansas Constitution be amended to provide for appointment of members of the Arkansas Supreme Court rather than by election.
    • Jun 30, 2016
  • Advocates sound the alarm about more income tax cuts

    Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families has begun a four-part series on the dangers of another income tax cut, a plan Gov. Asa Hutchinson and the Republican majority legislature seems bound to follow.
    • Jun 29, 2016
  • Wednesday's open line and news roundup

    Wednesday: An open line and a video roundup of news and comment.
    • Jun 29, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

Most Shared

  • Defense for Suhl asks judge to dismiss bribery indictment, citing Supreme Court decision in McDonnell case

    Attorneys for the businessman argue that his cash payments to a former deputy director of DHS, Steven Jones, did not constitute corruption. They say prosecutors cannot prove the money was given in exchange for any particular "official act" from Jones.
  • A modest proposal: Turn Bentonville over to charter schools

    Paul Hewitt, the recently retired Fayetteville school superintendent, has an innovative idea: Turn all schools in a school district over to charter school management companies. No, he's not talking about Little Rock. He thinks the experiment should start on the home turf of the country's biggest backers of charter schools.
  • Another voice rises against school duplication in Pulaski County

    Add Jerry Guess, superintendent of the Pulaski County Special School District, to the voice of Baker Kurrus, outgoing Little Rock superintendent, in questioning the wisdom of creating duplicate school systems in Pulaski County in the form of ever-expanding charter schools.
  • Kenneth Starr: Today's schadenfreude edition

    Mimi Swartz has an op-ed in the New York Times, "Ken Starr's Squalid Second Act," which blisters the self-righteous and pious former Whitewater persecutor for his dereliction as Baylor president during the unfolding scandal of placing athletic success ahead of rape victims.
  • Resistance grows nationally to freeway expansions

    The U.S. Public Interest Research Group has issued a news release about freeway expansion with relevance in Little Rock. It's about wasting money to widen freeways that only create more congestion. Sound familiar?

Most Viewed

  • Nursing home bribery case details suspect judicial fund-raising

    Plaintiffs' lawyers made their case today to continue to trial with the civil suit over then-Judge Mike Maggio's reduction of a $5.2 million jury verdict in a nursing home negligence case to $1 million, a reduction he said he made in return for campaign contributions from the nursing home's owner.
  • Texarkana repeals nondiscrimination ordinance

    Texarkana voters repealed a city non-discrimination ordinance Tuesday by a vote of 3,409 to 881.
  • The long and winding road: No exception yet for 30 Crossing

    The Arkansas highway department's representative on the Metroplan board of directors told the board today that the department is requesting an exception to the planning agency's cap on six lanes for its 30 Crossing project to widen Interstate 30 from six to 10 (and more) lanes.
  • Deadspin disses Donald Trump GOP convention lineup

    Deadspin pulls no punches in describing Donald Trump lineup for Republican National Convention. Trump is, however, denying a report that convicted rapist Mike Tyson will be among his sports greats on hand.

Most Recent Comments



© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation