Find out more →

Get unlimited access. Become a digital member!

Monday, July 13, 2015

State sued over refusal to put same-sex spouses on birth certificates

Posted By Max Brantley on Mon, Jul 13, 2015 at 2:09 PM

click to enlarge

• A YOUNG PLAINTIFF: The newborn at right, son of Leigh and Jana Jacobs, is one of the plaintiffs in a lawsuit seeking to make the state put both his mothers' names on his birth certificate.

As promised last week, a lawsuit was filed in Pulaski Circuit Court today on behalf of three couples — all married women — who have been unable to get both parents' names on birth certificates.

They include Leigh and Jana Jacobs, who related their problems to me Friday. In each case, the birth mother was allowed to have her name on the birth certificate, but hospital and state officials have said they wouldn't add the other parent without a court order. This complicates obtaining health insurance for the newborn under the coverage of the unrecognized parent.

The suit was filed by Cheryl Maples, who brought the first suit challenging the state's same-sex marriage ban, on behalf of the Jacobses, Marisa and Terrah Pavan and Courtney Kassel and Kelly Scott. Though these couples are married and all had children through a sperm donor, the suit said it believes the state is applying this restriction to unmarried same-sex couples as well.

The suit alleges equal protection and due process violations of the Arkansas and U.S. Constitutions because the state doesn't impose the same restrictions on heterosexual couples. Said the suit:

The Bureau of Vital Statistics routinely provides two–parent birth certificates to all children born to heterosexual couples, even those that are not married, without regard to how the children are conceived or whether a child shares a genetic connection to both parents.

In the case of a child born during a marriage, Ark. Code Anno. § 20-18-401 provides for mandatory inclusion of the spouse on the birth certificate unless there has been a finding that he spouse is NOT the parent or unless there is a sworn statement from the birth mother that her spouse is not the parent of her child. There is a strong
presumption that a spouse of a birth mother is also the child’s parent. Defendant’s policy is to unconstitutionally apply this to heterosexual married couples only.

Ark. Code Anno. § 20-18-401 also provides for the birth mother, if unmarried, to provide the name of the child’s other parent by way of a sworn affidavit. With such a sworn affidavit, the other parent is listed on the birth certificate without any other  showing of proof. Defendant’s policy is to unconstitutionally apply this to heterosexual
unmarried couples only.

The effect of this policy, the suit says, is to deprive the same-sex couples and their children of the "dignity, legitimacy, security, support and protections provided to children of heterosexual couples,"

The state Health Department Friday confirmed it was following this policy, but indicated it was mandated by rule to do so until the state Board of Health could change its regulations and the birth certificate form to a gender-free version. Any board rule would require legislative review, which wouldn't necessarily be an easy process.

The suit notes that the enforcement of the rule harms same-sex couples by making it difficult to obtain Social Security numbers and passports; prevents a non-birth mother from making medical and school decisions for her child; restricts the ability to apply for benefits through the non-birth mother; harms inheritance rights; doesn't protect the parent-child relationship in case of a divorce or child support dispute.

The suit asks that Health Department officials be enjoined from continuing to discriminate against same-sex couples. The defendant is Nathaniel Smith, director of the department.

I have sent questions to the attorney general, who'll have to respond for the state, and the state Health Department.

UPDATE: Beyond confirming the attorney general will defend the state, Leslie Rutledge's office declined further comment at this time.

A Health Department spokesman said its comments now had to be limited because of pending litigation. But the agency continues to move ahead, as it said Friday, on resolving the issue through Board of Health action.

Tags: birth certificates, Arkansas Health Department, Cheryl Maples, Leigh Jacobs, Jana Jacobs, Marisa and Terrah Pavan, Courtney Kassel and Kelly Scott, same-sex marriage, marriage equality, Image

Speaking of...

• Judge orders listing of both same-sex parents on birth certificates

  June 30, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  A federal judge in Indiana has ordered that state to list both parents in a married female couple on birth certificates, not just the birth mother. A similar case is on appeal in Arkansas. /more/

• Evening news brief: Fashion, gay discrimination, crime and punishment

  June 27, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  An evening news roundup includes presidential fashion, a ruling for gay rights in Mississippi and lots of crime and punishment. /more/

• A belated happy anniversary to marriage equality

  May 20, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  A belated note on the second anniversary of a judicial ruling striking down Arkansas's ban on same-sex marriage. Opponents said then it would be the ruination of the institution of marriage. What you think? /more/

• State continues fight against equal rights at every opportunity

  April 16, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  Attorney General Leslie Rutledge, naturally, is appealing Circuit Judge Tim Fox's ruling that allowed the names of three married same-sex couple to appear on their child's birth certificate. /more/

• Lawyers in Tennessee marriage case get $2 million

  March 30, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  I'm about to decide that the lawyers who fought for marriage equality in state and federal courts in Arkansas got screwed. Get a load of what a Tennessee judge just gave winners of the lawsuit there challenging a same-sex marriage ban. /more/

• Closeted no more: A story from Eureka Springs

  March 4, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  StoryCorps, the website devoted to using human stories to inspire a more compassionate world, has posted a story today about a couple in Eureka Springs — Dick Titus and Zeek Taylor. /more/

• Justice Courtney Goodson ad hits airwaves in race for Chief Justice of state Supreme Court

  February 3, 2016
  by David Ramsey

  Here come the ads. /more/

• Opposition to same-sex marriage costs Kentucky $1.1 million

  January 14, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  Arkansas got off light, with tiny attorney fee awards in lawsuits successfully challenging the state ban on same-sex marriage. Kentucky must pay more than $1 million. /more/

• Alabama chief justice orders halt to same-sex marriages in state

  January 6, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore today issued an order that said probate clerks in Alabama are not to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. /more/

• Robert Loyd, a leader in the fight for equality, dies in Conway

  January 2, 2016
  by Max Brantley

  As readers noted yesterday, Facebook has news — and an outpouring of sadness — of the death Wednesday of Robert Loyd, a pivotal figure in Central Arkansas in the struggle for equal rights for LGBT people. /more/

• More »