Wednesday, December 30, 2015

Tennessee sees increasing pushback on state-run Achievement School District

Posted By on Wed, Dec 30, 2015 at 3:35 PM


Education Week has an important story
 (access to the full article requires registration, which is free) about dissatisfaction with Tennessee's Achievement School District, the state-run entity that administers school districts taken over by the state because of low academic achievement. The ASD often awards administration of those schools to charter management organizations.

Arkansas should watch this debate closely. In 2015, an Arkansas bill that would have created a similar entity in Arkansas was pulled down by its legislative sponsor in the face of opposition from traditional public school groups and House Democrats on the Education Committee. But it won't be a surprise if HB 1733 reemerges in a future session.

The ASD has itself struggled,  says Ed Week writer Daarel Burnette, especially in Memphis (where 27 of the ASD's 29 schools are located):

Within the ASD, enrollment at several of the 27 schools has lagged, and YES Prep Public Schools, a nationally ranked charter operator based in Houston, abruptly abandoned its efforts to expand in Memphis after its leaders said they wouldn't be able to meet enrollment projections.

Academically, the district's charter operators in Memphis have struggled to cope with the city's entrenched poverty and the abnormally high mobility rate of its student body. Leaders have also struggled to hire and retain quality and experienced teachers. Its superintendent, Chris Barbic, resigned this month. 

Here's something that should be of special interest to the Little Rock School District: The traditional school district in Memphis,Shelby County Schools, has created a school turnaround model of its own that a new study from Vanderbilt University says is more effective than the state's turnaround model.

Shelby County's "Innovation Zone" (also called the "iZone") is not charter-based, but it does entail drastic measures: "replacing entire school staffs, frequent intervention for students who fall behind, and hours added onto the school day. Teachers get bonuses to work at the schools.Shelby County Schools' staff has been more successful in coping with neighborhood poverty by deploying an expensive and time-intensive wraparound model that partly addresses psychological trauma and other needs." The district is paying for these efforts with a combination of general funds, federal grants and private philanthropy.

(I've got to inject one question here, though: Without the pressure created by the ASD, would Shelby County Schools have been motivated to create such an aggressive turnaround model in the first place?)

Here's more from the Memphis Commercial Appeal on the political push to slow down the ASD among Tennesee Democrats:

Tennessee's Achievement School District shouldn't be allowed to expand because it isn't making significant progress with the schools it oversees, Rep. Brenda Gilmore, chairwoman of the Black Caucus of State Legislators, said Monday.

"The Tennessee Black Caucus stands in unity today, with the Democratic Caucus, asking that the ASD delay any further expansions until better results can be shown and substantiated," Gilmore said. "The ASD should go back to its original goal and refocus on intense intervention at a small number of schools."
The ASD, a state district authorized to take over the bottom 5 percent of low-performing schools, has recently seen backlash in Memphis after it announced a takeover Dec. 11 of four more schools in the city. The ASD oversees 29 schools, with 27 in Memphis and two in Nashville.

The community backlash caused Shelby County Schools to pass a resolution that includes a moratorium on the ASD's takeover of any more schools "until they show consistent progress in improving student academic achievement."

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Speaking of...

Comments (2)

Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

More by Benjamin Hardy

Readers also liked…

Most Shared

Visit Arkansas

1.73-carat diamond found at Crater of Diamonds State Park

1.73-carat diamond found at Crater of Diamonds State Park

Jack Pearadin and Doug Nelsen found a 1.73-carat diamond after nearly a year of searching the park's field.

Most Viewed

  • LRPD: Robbery suspect dead after victim wrestles away gun

    Little Rock Police say a robbery suspect died early this morning after one of the victims he allegedly tried to rob during a bank deposit wrestled away his handgun and shot him with it.
  • Earned-income tax credit plan fails in House

    Rep. Warwick Sabin's bill to enact an earned-income tax aimed at low-income workers in the state was rejected today in the House. The measure failed 66-28 on a mostly party-line vote, although a scattering of Republicans backed it.
  • What's next for Hillary Clinton?

    Politico's Gabriel Debenedetti, filing from Little Rock, reports on the future plans of Hillary Clinton in the wake of her loss in the presidential election
  • Collins files campus carry bill

    As expected, Rep. Charlie Collins yesterday filed a bill to force public universities and colleges to allow staff members to carry concealed handguns.
  • Committee passes bill to redefine "stillbirth" and require reporting miscarriages at 12 weeks

    The House Public Health committee today passed a bill sponsored by Rep. David Meeks, which would redefine "stillbirth" as the unintended death of a fetus any time after 12 weeks (current state law uses the medical definition, 20 weeks).  The bill would require that miscarriages that happened at 12 weeks gestation or more be reported to the division of Vital Records within five days after the event. Under current law, such fetal deaths must be reported when the fetus weighs more than 350 grams, or at 20 weeks if the weight is unknown. (The reporting requirement falls on medical providers, not on women who miscarry.)

Most Recent Comments



© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation