Monday, July 11, 2016

Maggio asks appeals court to withdraw guilty plea in bribery case

Posted By on Mon, Jul 11, 2016 at 3:33 PM

APPEALING: Mike Maggio, shown here with his wife after federal district court sentencing on a bribery charge, is trying to overturn that sentence.
  • APPEALING: Mike Maggio, shown here with his wife after federal district court sentencing on a bribery charge, is trying to overturn that sentence.

Former Circuit Judge Mike Maggio of Conway today filed his argument to withdraw his guilty plea to a bribery charge for reducing a $5.2 million verdict in a nursing home negligence case to $1 million in return for campaign contributions.

Maggio entered a plea bargain in the case, but later tried to withdraw his guilty plea. The request was denied by Judge Brian Miller, who handed down a 10-year sentence in March.

In a brief today to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Maggio’s court-appointed attorney, John Wesley Hall of Little Rock, argued that there was no factual basis for Maggio’s plea. He said the judge abused his discretion in refusing the withdrawal of the guilty plea because the government had failed to prove a “nexus” between bribe and action by Maggio. He also said the judge’s decision to enhance Maggio’s sentence was “unreasonable.” 

Only Maggio has been charged in the case. He’s accused – though the others were not named – of taking campaign contributions arranged by former Republican Sen. Gilbert Baker of Conway for his race for Court of Appeals. The money came from Michael Morton of Fort Smith, a nursing home owner whose properties include the Greenbrier nursing home sued for failing to send an ailing elderly woman to the hospital. She died in pain and a unanimous jury verdict awarded her family $5.2 million. Maggio considered and ultimately reduced the claim as efforts were  underway to move Morton money to Baker and then to PACs supporting Maggio. Neither Baker nor Morton has been charged with a crime and both have denied wrongdoing. Maggio remains free pending appeal.

Hall argued that Maggio was not an agent of the state as a judge and the government couldn't establish that a campaign contribution was a bribe, thus he had standing to appeal the refusal to grant his motion to withdraw the plea. The judge’s decision to reduce the nursing home verdict was not, he also wrote, "in connection with any business, transaction or series of transactions" of a government agency. Hall cited the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in the case of former Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell that held financial benefits the governor received from a company hoping to do business weren't criminal.

The government made a bribery charge in part resting on the fact that state courts in Arkansas receive federal money. But Hall asked: “What does a legally proper remittitur after a civil jury trial, between a personal representative of a deceased person and the nursing home where she died, have to do with federal funds received by the circuit court for drug or juvenile court?”  Without that connection, Maggio has a “fair and just” reason to ask to withdraw his guilty plea.

Under the statute by which Maggio was charged, Hall said, the government had to prove he
was an agent of government, solicited something of value intending to be influenced in connection with transactions of government and the agency of government received more than $10,000 in federal money. Some court precedent has held there need not be a connection between a bribe and federal funds. But Hall contended the statute is unconstitutional without that connection. “Otherwise, we have overcriminalization and free ranging prosecution with no proof whatsoever of a federal interest.”

Any ambiguity about the federal statute should be decided in favor of the defendant, Hall argued. If bribery occurred, there’s ample state law to prosecute the charge. Without a rule limiting overbroad laws, “couldn’t anything potentially be a federal crime, federal nexus or not? Any judge who rules in favor of a campaign contributor during the period of the campaign is at risk of a prosecution like Maggio’s, even if the judicial act was completely justified by fact and law and within precedent. And that’s just what this case boils down to.” (In defending a civil suit over Maggio’s verdict reduction, an expert witness for lawyers for Morton and Baker, former federal Judge Jim Moody, has said that the verdict reduction he entered could be justified by law.)

Hall quoted a text message from Baker to Maggio shortly before the verdict reduction, part of the indictment against Maggio.

The message about “Win, lose or draw, you have Individual A’s support” underscores that there simply was no bribe. Yes, it looks bad because of the timing and who it came from like McDonnell looked bad, but it just cannot be a crime based on these facts without nexus. 

In arguing for withdrawal of the plea, Hall contended Maggio was innocent and had admitted guilt only under pressure by previous counsel.

Although Maggio admitted to having a conflict of interest and allowing improper considerations to creep into the exercise of his judicial discretion, he never admitted to meeting the specific elements of bribery under § 666(a)(1)(B.

Maggio’s delay in seeking to withdraw the plea came because it was only after he had new trial counsel that “he fully understood and appreciated the legal issues in his case. “

On the sentencing issue, Hall argued the judge had improperly given Maggio a sentence enhancement, from 63 to 120 months. He said guideline already took into account that he was an elected official.

Yes, the District Court undeniably makes a valid point: “What is worse: A dope dealer on the phone talking about a dope deal, or a dirty judge? There’s no question. In society a dirty judge is by far more harmful to society than any dope dealer.” But, that’s already factored into the guidelines, and it is substantively unreasonable to double up and enhance Maggio yet again for that.”

The prosecution will have time to respond to Maggio's arguments. Hall asked for oral arguments on the appeal. Should he succeed on either withdrawal of the guilty plea or sentencing, he asked that the case be returned to district court for reconsideration.

Here's the full brief.

Tags: , , , , , , ,


Speaking of...

Comments (14)

Showing 1-14 of 14

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-14 of 14

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • A foggy open line and preparation for King-Lee Day

    The line is open. Perhaps you're reading in preparation for the King-Lee holiday tomorrow. One book is currently sold out, thanks to Donald Trump.
    • Jan 15, 2017
  • An angle on collecting sales tax from Amazon, other online sales

    The president of the Arkansas Restaurant Association says there is a way to make sure a sales tax is collected from on-line retailers, most recently adopted in Louisiaa. He's working on the idea in Arkansas.
    • Jan 15, 2017
  • LR City Hall agenda: Sales taxes

    The Little Rock City Board of Directors has  scheduled a vote on a resolution asking for a meeting with the Arkansas congressional delegation about federal legislation to allow cities to recapture sales tax revenue lost to Internet sales.
    • Jan 15, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

Most Shared

  • UPDATE: Retired Arkansas Arts Center director Townsend Wolfe dies at 81

    Townsend Durant Wolfe, III, retired director and chief curator of the Arkansas Arts Center, has died at 81.
  • Subpoenas identify names of federal interest in kickback probe

    The Northwest Arkansas Economic Development District today provided me with the subpoena it received from federal investigators in a probe that led to former Republican Rep. Micah Neal's guilty plea to taking kickbacks from money he guided to a nonprofit agency and a private college in Springdale, apparently Ecclesia College.
  • Human Services says it's eliminated Medicaid application backlog

    The state Human Services Department has informed Gov. Asa Hutchinson that it has all but eliminated a backlog in applications for Medicaid coverage.
  • Praising Asa

    Let us now praise the governor for a starkly moderate record, at least in comparison with other red-state executives.
  • Glass houses

    Having gotten a deep security briefing and probably a confidential glimpse of our own vast cyberspying operation, Donald Trump is no longer pretty sure that the Kremlin didn't hack Democratic computers or employ other tactics to help his election.

Visit Arkansas

Indian Rock House at Fairfield Bay

Indian Rock House at Fairfield Bay

Winter is the perfect time to explore the natural stone shelters where native Arkansans once lived

Most Recent Comments



© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation