A survey of the best pie in Central Arkansas 

As nominated by Times readers and staff.

With the exception of the Pie Shop at Terry's, these folks need a couple days' notice if you want to buy a whole pie. We figured volume because we wanted to include pi in our pie. Volume figures are a tiny bit fudged, given that none of the pies were cylinders.

cover_story6-1.jpg

Lemon icebox pie
Big Orange, 379-8715
$32 per pie, $6 per slice

A top vote-getter by the Times' taste-testers, nicely lemony with a whipped cream topping instead of meringue (a plus with one of the testers) and a graham cracker crust, which gives any pie an advantage. Don't drink with sauvignon blanc, however, or you'll have a hard time tasting the lemon.

Aesthetics: The orange zest on the top added a nice touch.

Volume: A bit less than 113.5 cubic inches.

cover_story6-2.jpg

Coconut meringue
Charlotte's Eats & Sweets, 842-2123
$26 per pie, $4.25 per slice

Winner of the highest meringue category at two and a half inches, this pie would have been better served before the rest, so delicate is its flavor. In fact, we're sure of it. Don't have a piece of lemon pie first. And here's a hint: When you go to Charlotte's, don't wait until you've eaten your hamburger to order your pie, or you might be out of luck.

Aesthetics: Thanks to the meringue, described by one tester as "wicked," this prize wins for looks.

Volume: A bit less than 270.4 cubic inches.

cover_story6-3.jpg

Peanut butter pie
Three Sam's BBQ Joint, 407-0345
$20 per pie, $4 per slice

Testers liked the combo of chocolate and peanut butter in this creamy pie, heaped high and blanketed with peanuts. It got an "OMG" from one taster; another compared it favorably to a giant Reese's Peanut Butter Cup.

Aesthetics: A little over the top nut-wise.

Volume: A bit less than 238.6 cubic inches (biggest pie tasted).

German chocolate pie

cover_story6-4.jpg
The Pie Shop at Terry's Finer Foods, 663-4152
$32 per pie, $4 per slice

Is this a German chocolate pie with pecans? Or a pecan pie with German chocolate? One naysayer, the type who doesn't color outside the lines, was bothered by the cross-cultural identity of this pie. Naysayer was shot down in a hail of derision, however. The pecans were praised.

Aesthetics: We could look chocolate in the face for a long time.

Volume: A bit less than 80.1 cubic inches.

cover_story6-5.jpg

Pecan pie
Franke's Cafeteria, 225-4487 (Marketplace), 372-1919 (downtown)
$14.94 per pie, $2.69 per slice

This was the bargain pie, from the venerable Franke's. It should be served hot, and if you are home, put a scoop of ice cream on it. Drawback: an undistinguished crust.

Aesthetics: Ice cream makes everything beautiful.

Volume: A bit less than 85.1 cubic inches.

cover_story6-6.jpg

Raspberry cream pie
Trio's Restaurant, 221-3330
$26 per pie, $6 per slice

Excellent cream filling and graham cracker crust, rather than the raspberries, made this pie a standout. (But if strawberries are in season, get the strawberry shortcake instead at Trio's. Outstanding.)

Aesthetics: Wayne Thiebaud.

Volume: A bit less than 75.39 cubic inches (smallest pie tasted).

cover_story6-7.jpg

Caramel apple cinnamon crumb
Pie Hole food truck, 712-6366
$27 per pie, $4.50 per slice

Pockets of crunchy caramelized sugar cinnamon plus apple plus pie crust ... such cries of pleasure one never heard in a newsroom. This pie was so delicious that its appearance — the color of dog food — was completely forgiven.

Aesthetics: Ol' Roy, but smelling great.

Volume: A bit less than 143.1 cubic inches.

Comments (6)

Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

Latest in Cover Stories

  • Prosecutors have all the power

    But little oversight. Is a violation not a violation if a prosecutor says, 'I didn't mean to'?
    • Sep 11, 2014
  • The long shadow of Carnell Russ' death

    In 1971, a white Arkansas police officer shot an unarmed black man over a $23 speeding ticket.
    • Sep 4, 2014
  • Visionary Arkansans 2014

    They make an impact in science, arts, social justice.
    • Aug 28, 2014
  • More »

Most Shared

  • Not giving up on Fred

    We ended up adopting Fred due to his incorrigible stubbornness. Originally bred to track game, basset hounds can be amazingly persistent. It sometimes appears that when their noses are working, their hearing shuts down.
  • Private clubs win early closing battle

    Private clubs apparently have won their battle against earlier closing hours, based on a "compromise" revealed at the City Board meeting last night.
  • Prosecutors have all the power

    But little oversight. Is a violation not a violation if a prosecutor says, 'I didn't mean to'?
  • The Kochs, Tom Cotton and their dislike of helping farmers

    The Koch political lobby is trying mightily to pretend it supports American farmers and that Tom Cotton's vote against the farm bill isn't a measure of farm support. A new report from a Democratic organization blows that dishonest messaging out of the water.
  • In Hot Springs, pizza means Deluca's

    In Hot Springs, one pizzeria is taking fresh flavors to the next level.

Most Recent Comments

 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation