Arkansas Republicans still fighting Obamacare 

Why federal-government-hating state Republicans, with direction from national conservatives, oppose the state-run exchange.

Page 2 of 3

"It's a legal challenge to the IRS's attempt to re-write Obamacare," Cannon told the Times. "The statute says that if a state does not create its own exchange then major provisions of the law don't apply."

Cutting off tax credits and subsidies to help people buy insurance on the exchange would be a major whack at the law, but there's more. The penalties on employers that don't offer sufficient insurance to their employees (the "employer mandate") are triggered by those very same credits and subsidies once their employees go shopping on the exchange. The requirement that people buy health insurance (the "individual mandate") exempts people if the cost of coverage, minus credits and subsidies, exceeds 8 percent of household income. Without credits and subsidies, many more would be exempted, weakening the mandate. In other words, in Cannon's reading of the law, in states that don't run their own exchanges, the exchange will fall apart.

On its face, the argument seems odd — why would Congress establish federally run exchanges as a backup to states but then strip them of everything they'd need to actually run an exchange?

"There are a couple of subsections of a particular section of the statue that if read in complete isolation from the entire rest of the statute and in complete ignorance of the history of the statute, you could read to say that," health-law expert Timothy Jost, a Washington and Lee law professor, told the Times. "It's unfortunate that he has had so much impact on states that are just trying to find some way to gum this up." Jost believes that lawsuits pursuing Cannon's arguments now will run into problems with legal standing to raise the case, but even if a party has standing, he expects "that the court will take a look at the entire statute ... and will throw this case out."

Cannon and Jost are engaged in an ongoing public debate about these questions. Who's right? That will be up to lawyers and judges to haggle over in the coming months and years, but Cannon's ideas aren't going away. In September, Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt filed a lawsuit along the same lines in federal court.

Arkansas Sen. Cecile Bledsoe (R-Rogers) explicitly referenced Cannon and his claims last month as legislators considered whether to revisit the exchange issue after the feds gave states an extension on their decision. Citing Cannon as a source, she was hopeful that employers wouldn't be subject to the law's penalties if the state said no to running its own exchange, an idea echoed by Sen. Michael Lamoureux (R-Russellville), the incoming Senate president, all of which baffled Arkansas Health Exchange director Cynthia Crone.

"That's just not true," Crone said. She said that she has since thoroughly researched the issue, checking with the Treasury Department, the IRS and numerous other relevant federal agencies and has received "full authority that there is equal implementation" of the law regardless of who runs the exchange.

Bledsoe was upset that Crone did not know about the libertarian legal theory at the time. "Here's the thing," she said, "we're on a fact-finding mission on all of this and I think you need to look at all the different think tanks. And I'm just reading, I'm not involved like the Insurance Department should be. Why did they not know some of these things? That was a problem, I thought."

Speaking of...

Comments (2)

Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

More by David Ramsey

  • Kim Kardashian, a Christmas playlist, local poetry and more

    Tonight, is the Arkansas Times annual holiday party. As usual, I've been asked to DJ. That means putting together a playlist on iTunes and Spotify that starts with not-lame Christmas music, gradually transitions into mid-tempo party music, moves to Stax and Motown so the boomers on staff will dance and then, maybe after Beyonce and Justin Timberlake, is just "Back That Azz Up" played on a loop.
    • Dec 12, 2014
  • Ann Patchett, Robert Wyatt, graphic design, poetry and more

    My wife Grace recommended Ann Patchett's "State of Wonder" to me. Here is what Grace said on her blog: "This book has everything I like a book to have: an original and complex female character, intrigue, and weird science. Don’t want to give away the plot, so I’ll just say this: Amazon rainforest, hallucinogenic mushrooms, pregnant women."
    • Nov 21, 2014
  • More »

Most Shared

  • Photos from March for TC

    Last night, dozens of friends of TC Edwards, the Little Rock musician and man on the scene who was found murdered Dec. 7, marched in his memory, chanting "Justice for TC" and "TC is metal" as they walked from Pizza D' Action up Kavanaugh.
  • Psych of the South: The Mercenaries' 'Things Found Here'

    Recently, a trove of band business cards from the golden era of Arkansas garage bands was discovered and put on eBay. I was able to purchase some of them, including one by a little known 1960s garage band from Little Rock named The Mercenaries. Their record, on the cult favorite MY records label based in Little Rock, was released in early 1967. Their songs, including the atmospheric and heavy “Things Found Here” along with the psychedelic tinged “Take It All” are obscure even by garage rock standards. They were not featured on the 1999 Butler Center MY records compilation and their story has not been told before
  • Good policies, bad politics

    Democrats are like Republicans in one way. One party or the other suffers devastating losses at least every eight years and then engages in a noisy search for blame and atonement.
  • Women's work in the House

    The new Republican majority in Arkansas came with the support of female majorities in some key races.
  • The Duggar clan provides big boost, unintentionally, for gay kids

    Still more good news for Lucie's Place, the small Little Rock nonprofit that works to help homeless LGBT youths. It's added a $10,000 grant to $30,000 raised in a symbolic response to the Duggar family's support for discrimination against gay people in Fayetteville.

Latest in Arkansas Reporter

Event Calendar

« »


  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31  

Most Viewed

  • Big Ideas for Arkansas 2014

    Readers and experts suggest ways to change Arkansas for the better.
  • Unrestricted high explosives, available at a sporting goods store near you

    It's 'dangerous stuff,' according to a Little Rock bomb squad member.
  • Packing in Walmart

    Also, Attorney General Dustin McDaniel's inglorious exit, a bumpy ride, friends in high places and Eugene Ellison, by the numbers.
  • Three days of Garth

    The veteran country star Garth Brooks played his favorites, and sang with wife Trisha Yearwood, in an unprecedented-for-Arkansas three-day run of concerts at Verizon Arena.
  • Raping with impunity

    In Gene Lyons' Dec. 11 column "Rolling Stone Now Publishing Fiction," he asked a rhetorical question: "Had American culture really coarsened to where college boys could rape with impunity?" I'm writing this letter because I thought he might like to know that question has been empirically answered by social scientists.

Most Recent Comments


© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation