Favorite

Barth: By the Numbers: 40 + 5 

[image-1]

Numbers are at the heart of electoral politics. From vote totals to money raised to doors knocked on by canvassers, numbers tell us much about what happens in the political world. "By the Numbers" is a new regular web-only feature with a goal of illuminating some of the key numbers in Arkansas politics. Have a comment or have a request for a future piece? Email Jay Barth at jay@jaybarth.org.

Runoff elections have been around for over a century and are regular features in politics in the South. Most southern states adopted the runoff once one-party Democratic reign was established with the disenfranchisement of African Americans and the demolition of Populist threats to Democrats. Ensuring that the ultimate winners of Democratic primaries (then the only elections that mattered) would have a majority of the vote, Democratic parties in the South created the runoff as a bow to "majority rule" at the same time the majorities of southerners were denied the right to participate in those primaries.

Because runoff elections have now been around for decades, we now have a lot of data on them. Scholars who have studied runoffs find that the leader of the first primary ends up winning the runoff about two-thirds of the time. Moreover, if a candidate gains 40 percent of the first primary vote and has a 5 point lead in the first primary over the candidate they are to face in the runoff, the candidate rarely loses. That is, unless all of their first round opponents coalesce behind the second place finisher or the second place finisher has a decidedly better turnout operation, that "40 + 5" lead is enough to hold off the challenger.

Going into yesterday's runoff elections for the First and Fourth Congressional District's Democratic nominations, the first primary leaders — Prosecuting Attorney Scott Ellington in the First and State Senator Gene Jeffress in the Fourth — each were in strong shape according to the "40 + 5" rule of thumb. Yet, Ellington limped across the finish line yesterday barely defeating State Representative Clark Hall despite the fact he'd nearly avoided a runoff altogether three weeks previous. Jeffress, on the other hand, blew by his runoff opponent Q. Byrum Hurst on the way to an easy victory. Why the disparities in outcomes?

In the First District, analysis of the vote returns across the counties of the district, shows that very little changed in terms of the candidates' support across the runoff campaign except that Ellington nicely coalesced the support of third place finisher Gary Latanich across the district.   To be more specific, a simple regression analysis shows that nearly 70 percent of the variance in Ellington's vote across the counties of the district  yesterday is explained by only two factors: his share of the vote in a county in the May primary and the percentage of the vote received in a county by Latanich.  This means that not much happened in terms of electoral dynamics over the past three weeks in that these results were a reiteration of what happened before.

The story of the First District runoff vote that made things close in the end was turnout. Ellington showed an extraordinary inability to get his voters back to the polls for the runoff. This was particularly true in the two large counties — Craighead and Greene — where he ran up huge majorities in the first primary (and large percentages in both elections). In his home county of Craighead, voter turnout dropped by over 70 percent, causing a reduction in Ellington's vote total of 2,944 votes from the first primary. The numbers were even worse in Greene County, where turnout went down by just under 80 percent and Ellington's vote total went down by 2,173. In contrast, while participation dropped in Hall's best counties, it was by much lower amounts. Most importantly, in his home county of Phillips, turnout decreased by only 30 percent costing him 703 votes. This basic pattern held across the district.

While I was bullish on Ellington's general election chances following his surprising showing in the first primary, his inability to put the race away should give Democrats pause. In addition to raising the resources (and getting help from the national party in DC) to present his message against incumbent Rep. Rick Crawford, Ellington has to also build a campaign infrastructure that can get his voters to the polls, particularly in the southern part of the district where he did poorly, in way that didn't happen in the runoff. The clock is ticking on both fundraising and building campaign apparatus.

In the Fourth District, on the other hand, Jeffress strolled to an easy victory. Again, the pattern in terms of county-level returns between the first primary and the runoff were markedly stable showing that very little shook up the race over the last three weeks. Moreover, somewhat surprisingly, Jeffress nicely coalesced the vote gained by third-place finisher DC Morrison who endorsed Jeffress after the primary. A regression analysis shows that the two variables — Jeffress's percentage of the county level vote in the first primary and Morrison's vote by county — explains quite extraordinarily nearly 90 percent in the county variance in yesterday's results. Moreover, while the pattern was not nearly as stark as in the First District, Jeffress had a turnout advantage. Specifically, voters showing up to vote in the competitive state Senate primary between Eddie Cheatham and Gregg Reep covering much of the southeastern part of the district, also voted overwhelmingly for Jeffress; Jeffress gained over 75% in most of those counties.

Jeffress did it the old fashioned way, gaining votes person-by-person. It was enough to pull off a strong showing in a low turnout election. The odds are not good that it will be repeated in the fall. The Fourth District contest will be a great experiment in the comparative power of old-style Arkansas politics (a personal campaign where money matters very little, practiced by Jeffress) and a new-style media driven politics practiced by newcomer Tom Cotton. The money is on the future, but it will be fun to watch.

Favorite

Comments (4)

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

More by Jay Barth

  • 'Proactive' policing

    On Monday, after six months of study, President Obama's Task Force on 21st Century Policing released its 100-plus page final report.
    • May 21, 2015
  • Early vote favors keeping Eureka Springs ordinance

    Late this afternoon, Shannon Hix of Keep Eureka Fair reports that approximately 425 early votes were cast in the election. (418 have been cast at the Eureka Springs early voting site and a handful of eligible Eureka Springs voters showed up at a Berryville early voting site.) In a town where just 792 votes were cast in the November midterm elections, this is fairly remarkable early voting activity.
    • May 11, 2015
  • More »

Most Shared

  • Womack gets plucked by 'Last Week Tonight with John Oliver'

    HBO's "Last Week Tonight with John Oliver, which premiered last April, has consistently shown itself to be a Daily Show-level contender for the humor-news crown. Up for discussion on the show last night: the myriad ways major poultry producers exploit chicken farmers. Also featured in the video: Arkansas Republican Rep. Steve Womack, who gets plucked and roasted for placing a rider on the agriculture appropriations bill that forbids the USDA from enforcing already-written protections for the nation's poultry farmers.
  • Magazine obtains police report over Josh Duggar sexual molestation investigation; he admits past 'mistakes,' resigns Family Council job

    In Touch magazine reports that it has obtained a Springdale police report containing allegations of sexual misconduct against an unnamed teen that it says it has confirmed was Josh Duggar, a minor at the time and now a prominent lobbyist for the Family Research Council and a leading voice for legal discrimination against gay people.
  • State budget administrator Brandon Sharp fired; no reason given

    KATV reports that Brandon Sharp was fired Monday afternoon after four years as state budget administrator, a $101,000-a-year job in the Department of Finance and Administration.
  • KATV: Bill Walker's state agency approves grants to sister UPDATE

    KATV has dug up on questionable public dealings by a familiar figure — former state Sen. Bill Walker, who headed the state Career Education Department during the administration of Gov. Mike Beebe.
  • What's not to love about the Bentonville Film Festival? Walmart.

    The Bentonville Film Festival, launched this year by actress Geena Davis and held earlier this month from May 5-9, earned a number of largely positive notices from major outlets like the Huffington Post ("At the Bentonville Film Festival, Women Are Playing in the Major Leagues"), the L.A. Times ("Bentonville Film Festival pushes diversity message from year one") and the New York Times ("Bentonville, Ark., Hosts a Film Festival Without a Movie Theater"), most of them centering on its unique and vital agenda — promoting diversity and gender equality in filmmaking — and its celebrity cache (e.g. an acting workshop taught by Robert De Niro, a softball game led by Rosie O'Donnell, etc.).

Latest in Jay Barth

  • 'Proactive' policing

    On Monday, after six months of study, President Obama's Task Force on 21st Century Policing released its 100-plus page final report.
    • May 21, 2015
  • Some politics is still local

    As early voting begins this week in Eureka Springs, a campaign that has been consciously localized seems well positioned to pull off an important victory for LGBT rights progress in an emphatically red state.
    • May 7, 2015
  • Hillary Clinton's well-played gender card

    Hillary Clinton's 2008 campaign for president is the most thoroughly critiqued primary candidacy of all time. The early signs from her second race for president indicate that this will be a very different Clinton campaign in terms of gender.
    • Apr 23, 2015
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

May

S M T W T F S
  1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31  

Most Viewed

  • Truth on Iraq

    Jeb Bush's still prospective race for president took a little nosedive when he bungled questions from friendly agents at Fox television about his brother's invasion of Iraq. If Fox News can foil a Republican so easily, people asked, could he be seriously considered for the party's nomination?
  • While I was away...

    I'm just back from two weeks out of the country. A couple of catchups.
  • NFL blows it

    The bombast and grandiosity of NFL football have always put me off. Fans too often treat ballgames as if they were wars between rival tribes or nation states; symbolic struggles between good and evil. As somebody who watches probably 150 major league baseball games a year, I find the hype alternately exhausting and ridiculous.
  • 'Proactive' policing

    On Monday, after six months of study, President Obama's Task Force on 21st Century Policing released its 100-plus page final report.

Most Recent Comments

 

© 2015 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation