Favorite

Bush’s bad math 

It must be hard for most people to believe the two international reports that show a big gap between the math concepts and skills of young Americans and those of much of the rest of the developed world, which continues for a third generation and is growing. But how can you avoid the evidence at President Bush’s press conference Monday, when he tried to explain how his “reforms” were going to save Social Security and not aggravate its long-term financial problem? That has perplexed people since he first said he was going to rescue Social Security by having workers direct part of their payroll taxes into the stock and bond markets. Now and for the next 15 years, Social Security will add to its vast surplus, and it will support full benefits to everyone until at least 2042 or 2052, depending on whether you believe the Social Security trustees or the Congressional Budget Office. If something isn’t done, like lifting the earnings cap on the payroll tax, benefits would be lowered then. Reporters asked Bush to explain how reducing the amount of payroll taxes that are invested in government bonds for Social Security at every pay period and transferring the money instead into private investment accounts that workers would manage themselves would keep Social Security flush far beyond 2042 or 2052. “Yeah, I will try to explain how without negotiating with myself,” Bush said with a chuckle. But he couldn’t do it. “I think what you all — people ought to do is to go look at the Moynihan commission report,” he suggested, referring to the President’s Commission to Strengthen Social Security. That helps us a little, that is if the president is going to choose Model 2 of the Moynihan report, which seems most like what he is proposing. Bush hints that benefits will be cut under his plan but not for people who are already retired or are approaching retirement. Every worker would see his or her benefits cut but Bush says those who put payroll taxes aside in a private account would earn so much from it that it would more than offset the reduction in regular Social Security. It would be voluntary but if you didn’t choose to play with the stocks your benefits would be cut anyway to make the system solvent. Not many current workers would be excited about it. Under the commission’s plan —and presumably Bush’s — a worker who is 37 today and retires in 2032 would receive 17 percent less in regular benefits. For young workers the reduction would grow to a third. Today’s babies would see cuts of more than 40 percent from currently expected benefits. A study of the commission’s plans at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2002 concluded that the role of Social Security in allowing the elderly to maintain their standard of living after retirement would decline “rather sharply” over time if the private investment option becomes law. But Bush says he’s sure that younger workers who invested in the markets would see such big gains that it would offset the reductions in pensions and that those retirees could enjoy perhaps an even better life than they would under the present Social Security system. That calls for some wildly rosy assumptions, starting with the notion that the stock market will perform the next 30 years as it has the past 30. The most bullish analyst, even Bush’s Treasury Department, will have trouble showing an array of stock returns and dividend yields that will add up. It also assumes low administrative costs, although obviously not as low as Social Security’s 1 percent, which is one reason that it is the most efficiently run government program in world history. The Moynihan commission — Bush wanted us to check it out, remember — figured that it would cost about 10 times as much to administer if a government office managed the investments. But Bush says every worker would manage his own investments, subject to some limits so he doesn’t squander money on lottery tickets or some wild scheme, because otherwise he would not have real ownership, which to the president is the real reason to do it. If Wall Street or local banks and brokerages get their hands on the money, which is why the investment industry has been cheerleading for the “reform,” all bets are off. But that seems to be the key to the Bush plan. Chile and England do it that way now, and the government is having to come to the rescue. But none of that answers the basic math question. How will the private accounts and the diminished payroll taxes solve the cash problems of Social Security when they do finally come to roost? The commission’s answer was to divert trillions of dollars from general revenues. But that was when we thought we would always have a surplus. Bush’s loyal treasury secretary said it was easy. Just pick a figure in the trillions and we’ll borrow it. If that’s the answer, who needs math at all?
Favorite

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Ernest Dumas

  • Fake economics

    Fake news is a new phenomenon in the world of politics and policy, but hokey economic scholarship has been around as long as Form 1040 and is about as reliable as the news hoaxes that enlivened the presidential campaign.
    • Dec 1, 2016
  • China in charge

    Let's turn to foreign affairs to see how we might calm the flood of anxieties over the coming Donald Trump presidency.
    • Nov 24, 2016
  • A little hope

    It may not be nearly as bad as you expect.
    • Nov 17, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Religion as excuse upends Constitution

    Tirades over religious liberty since the U.S. Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriages nationwide have awakened the ghost of James Madison, the author of the constitutional doctrine on the matter, and it isn't happy that his effort to protect religious inquiry in America is being corrupted.
    • Jul 9, 2015
  • Guns, God and gays

    Many more mass shootings like the one last week in Roseburg, Ore., will stain the future and no law will pass that might reduce the carnage. That is not a prediction but a fact of life that is immune even to Hillary Clinton.
    • Oct 8, 2015
  • AEC dumps ALEC

    No matter which side of the battle over global warming you're on, that was blockbuster news last week. No, not the signing of the climate-change treaty that commits all of Earth's 195 nations to lowering their greenhouse-gas emissions and slowing the heating of the planet, but American Electric Power's announcement that it would no longer underwrite efforts to block renewable energy or federal smokestack controls in the United States.
    • Dec 17, 2015

Most Shared

  • Department of Arkansas Heritage archeologist resigns

    Bob Scoggin, 50, the Department of Arkansas Heritage archeologist whose job it was to review the work of agencies, including DAH and the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department, for possible impacts on historic properties, resigned from the agency on Monday. Multiple sources say Scoggin, whom they describe as an "exemplary" employee who the week before had completed an archeological project on DAH property, was told he would be fired if he did not resign.
  • Labor department director inappropriately expensed out-of-state trips, audit finds

    Jones was "Minority Outreach Coordinator" for Hutchinson's 2014 gubernatorial campaign. The governor first named him as policy director before placing him over the labor department instead in Jan. 2015, soon after taking office.
  • Lawsuit filed against ADC officials, prison chaplain convicted of sexual assault at McPherson

    A former inmate who claims she was sexually assaulted over 70 times by former McPherson Womens' Unit chaplain Kenneth Dewitt has filed a federal lawsuit against Dewitt, several staff members at the prison, and officials with the Arkansas Department of Corrections, including former director Ray Hobbs.
  • Rapert compares Bill Clinton to Orval Faubus

    Sen. Jason Rapert (R-Conway)  was on "Capitol View" on KARK, Channel 4, this morning, and among other things that will likely inspire you to yell at your computer screen, he said he expects someone in the legislature to file a bill to do ... something about changing the name of the Bill and Hillary Clinton National Airport.

Latest in Ernest Dumas

  • Fake economics

    Fake news is a new phenomenon in the world of politics and policy, but hokey economic scholarship has been around as long as Form 1040 and is about as reliable as the news hoaxes that enlivened the presidential campaign.
    • Dec 1, 2016
  • China in charge

    Let's turn to foreign affairs to see how we might calm the flood of anxieties over the coming Donald Trump presidency.
    • Nov 24, 2016
  • A little hope

    It may not be nearly as bad as you expect.
    • Nov 17, 2016
  • More »

Visit Arkansas

Arkansas remembers Pearl Harbor

Arkansas remembers Pearl Harbor

Central Arkansas venues have a full week of commemorative events planned

Event Calendar

« »

December

S M T W T F S
  1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Worth it

    • Alas, Gene's memory ain't what it used to be. He wrote a column some time…

    • on December 5, 2016
  • Re: Forget identity politics

    • Hillarys 'Stronger Together' nonsense failed because she failed to make it a reality. As Gene…

    • on December 5, 2016
  • Re: Fake economics

    • Trump economic proposals: Rates for Married-Joint filers: Less than $75,000: 12% More than $75,000 but…

    • on December 5, 2016
 

© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation