Enter the loan sharks 

Last November, Arkansas voters approved a constitutional change that raised the interest limit on consumer loans to 17 percent.

Barely 100 days later, the so-called "installment loan industry" has lobbyists at work on legislation to remove the interest cap on loans of less than $5,000. Former House Speaker Robbie Wills signed up almost immediately after leaving office to lead the lobbying.

Wills and the industry paint this as almost a public service for needy people. Pay no attention to the 11 percent signature loans on offer at credit unions if you put down $25 in a savings account.

The loan sharks have proposed a 36 percent interest rate for starters — expressed less ominously as $3 monthly for every $100 borrowed. But that is not the whole story. Every loan will also carry a 10 percent origination fee, upfront. In other states where these loan sharks operate, some carrying charges are also applied. Miss a payment by a day and you'll incur a 5 percent late fee. These "charges" are all cloaks for interest.

One expert in the lending industry told me the installment lenders will take more out of the pockets of consumers than the blood-sucking payday lenders, only recently run out of the state.

Testimony offered in Oklahoma in 2006 by a lawyer who'd sued the industry describes how the lenders talk borrowers into renewing loans, with punishing new origination fees each time. The lawyer, who won a huge court verdict against the lenders, said the lenders preyed on, among others, mentally and physically handicapped with disability check income. He said the companies made enormous profits, but managed to avoid Oklahoma tax liability with a variety of accounting tricks.

There's no demonstrated need to open the door to loan sharks this soon. Nor is there evidence that 50 percent interest rates are necessary to make a profit in a day when financial institutions pay barely 1 percent on deposits.

Nonetheless, an unholy alliance comprising primarily Republicans and black Democratic legislators (the latter nominally representatives of poor people, though you couldn't tell it by many of their corporate campaign contributors) has emerged to push the loan sharks' cause.

Notable was an aggressive freshman, Sen. Jason Rapert of Bigelow. He's a preacher, financial adviser and sponsor of some of the worst legislation this session — more guns on college campuses, a big tax break for the wealthy, drug testing for unemployment recipients. Though he wants smaller government — and has a constitutional amendment to make tax increases all but impossible — he's also a hypocrite. He's filed a clutch of bills to direct state pork barrel spending to his district.

But what got me most about Rapert was his comment on Jason Tolbert's blog in which he drew a parallel between the loan shark bill and microfinance. Microfinance has been employed wondrously in the Third World to make tiny loans to encourage small businesses. It's about adding value to people, not piling ruinous interest on them.

Rapert declaimed with a straight face: "This concept is virtually the same as the concept of microfinance — which is embraced by humanitarian organizations around the world as the savior of poor people who are denied access to credit."

Humanitarian Rapert said that should he get any indication the poor were being taken advantage of, he'd work to defeat the legislation. Given the persuasive testimony of consumer advocates and experience in other states plundered by the loan sharks, it would seem to be time for Rapert to get to work.

Comments (32)

Showing 1-25 of 32

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-25 of 32

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Most Shared

  • Koch mailer: We know who you are, we know if you vote

    Still more complaints rolling in — including from Republicans — about the mail campaign of the Koch-brothers-funded Americans for Prosperity to scare people into voting.
  • Pat Hays' NRA membership riles Republicans

    Democratic 2nd District Congress candidate Pat Hays is causing conniption fits among Republicans because a new TV ad shows him with his guns and mentions his long-time membership in the National Rifle Association.
  • Talk is cheap; state government isn't: Preparing for the new GOP order

    The state looks at rising prison and school costs in a world where the theme of Republican political campaigns is reducing government and cutting taxes. Does anybody in that party know arithmetic?
  • Live Review: Nahko and Medicine for the People at Rev Room

    Thursday night, Portland, Oregon’s Nahko and Medicine for the People brought their “musical medicine” to Little Rock’s Revolution Music Room, a fitting venue for the socially-conscious music collective. Their uplifting medley of folk, urban and world music, as well as hypnotizing videos featuring their music have enchanted activist-minded music fans across the world in the relatively short time they have been creating music together.
  • What about the Arkansas ballot issues?

    To give the legislature more power, the people less, a wetter state, longer term limits and a bump in the minimum wage.

Latest in Max Brantley

  • Election decisions

    The Democratic Party candidates for top offices in Arkansas are centrists, with records of bipartisanship in public life. In each race, Republican opponents are from the extreme right end of the spectrum.
    • Oct 30, 2014
  • Clarke Tucker: a vote for the future

    If the Democratic Party of Arkansas has a future, it is in people like Clarke Tucker, the Democratic nominee to succeed term-limited John Edwards in representing House District 35 — the Heights and northwestern Little Rock.
    • Oct 22, 2014
  • So many races, so few words

    As a momentous election builds to a climax, it's hard to know where best to deploy 600 words.
    • Oct 16, 2014
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »


  1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

Most Viewed

  • Mental health system in crisis in Arkansas

    The National Alliance for the Mentally Ill (NAMI) has been sounding the alarm of a nationwide crisis in mental health services since 2011. On the other side of the Atlantic, the National Health Service in the United Kingdom is struggling to provide adequate mental health services. For us mental health professionals in Arkansas, these jeremiads ring a familiar bell.
  • Election decisions

    The Democratic Party candidates for top offices in Arkansas are centrists, with records of bipartisanship in public life. In each race, Republican opponents are from the extreme right end of the spectrum.
  • Naive cynicism

    Upon first venturing to write about politics 20 years ago, I held naive views about political journalism. Specifically, I imagined that factual accuracy mattered as it did in the kinds of books and magazine pieces I'd written on non-political topics — opinionated, yes, but grounded in careful reporting.
  • Romney's Obamacare

    Since it's too late in the election cycle for much else, can we engage in a historical what-if? Specifically, what if Mitt Romney had peaked in the spring of 2008 rather than 2012?

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Election decisions

    • Especially Mike Ross and Mark Pryor. I don't necessarily agree with them on every issue…

    • on October 29, 2014
  • Re: Election decisions

    • Vote for the centrists, my friends.

    • on October 29, 2014
  • Re: Naive cynicism

    • I tried to read the Harper's article; couldn't finish. Tyson kickback? The tortuous, time-bending explication…

    • on October 29, 2014

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation