How much is too much? 

The Beebe administration's triumphant landing of a windmill blade plant at the Little Rock Port called to mind former Gov. Jim Guy Tucker's triumphant announcement of a Southwest Airlines call center at the Little Rock Airport, long gone.

It reminds me again of the absence of sober and believable cost-benefit analyses when corporate welfare gets thrown around.

The Arkansas Democrat-Gazette has been doing some dogged reporting on the enticements to land the $150 million installation of LM Glasfiber, a Danish company. It could eventually employ 1,000 people.

What did it cost to create these jobs? A bunch.

• $6.9 million from the governor's “quick action closing fund.”

• Free land valued at $5.4 million from the city of Little Rock and the port.

• $8 million from the Economic Development Department.

• $3,500 per worker (as much as $3.5 million, in other words) for job training.

• $63,000 from the Highway and Transportation Department to improve freeway access.

• An untold amount from a 27-year state income tax exemption.

This is a significant sum for jobs that will mostly pay from $11.50 to $14.90 per hour and it includes no cost for the 27-year income tax exemption. (Of course, most big corporations have figured out accounting dodges around the corporate income tax.)

There are other not-so-evident contributions to the new company. Local taxpayers have paid millions to build the Little Rock Port and its railroad. U.S. taxpayers have paid hundreds of millions to build the Arkansas River navigation system that was critical to the plant. We don't know yet if the plant will seek low-cost Act 9 financing to build the plant itself, but this has been discussed. If it happens, the facility might or might not be made to make payments in lieu of property taxes on the tax-exempt structure. Based on the record so far, I wouldn't hold out much hope for contributions to the school property tax base.

At a minimum, taxpayers will plunk down nearly $24 million for a $30 million annual payroll, not counting substantial unknown costs. Is that a good deal?

Rollover effect of this plant will be slight. Products won't be sold here. Goods used in the manufacturing process won't be taxed. The corporation won't be taxed. No related industries are in the works. At this pay level, workers will pay modest income taxes, probably at a level that will take 20 years or more to recoup the direct government investment. Workers will buy groceries, clothes and other taxable goods. As for Little Rock's contribution, perhaps the workers will live in Little Rock. Perhaps they will commute from Cabot.

Developers are confident this is a winner any way you compute it. But I'd love to see a rigorous cost-benefit analysis for public inspection. I'd also like an analysis of whether Arkansas HAD to give up everything that was demanded. We had much to negotiate with.

Gov. Mike Beebe suggested that this plant was a strike back by the U.S. at the movement of manufacturing overseas. That's nonsense. This plant was built here for our low wages; our proximity to locations where the blades will be sold (Texas, for one), and for the important rail, river and highway (also taxpayer-subsidized) links to ship in raw material and ship out finished product. This plant was never going to be built in China.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Working Families group buys ads hitting French Hill on vote for bank protection

    Republican U.S. Rep. French Hill of Little Rock seems likely to cruise to re-election against largely unfunded opponents, including Libertarian Chris Hayes and Democrat Dianne Curry, but an independent group has entered the fray against Hill with ads  attacking the former banker's votes helpful to big banks.
    • Oct 26, 2016
  • Hester says state can afford $105 million income tax cut

    Sen. Bart Hester, a Republican from Cave Springs who's been endeavoring lately to end state support for the state-owned War Memorial Stadium among other attacks on government spending, distributed a news release today saying he was working on a proposed $105 million income tax cut.
    • Oct 26, 2016
  • Vote suppression efforts continue in U.S.

    This is one to watch in Arkansas. The New York Times reports on incidents nationwide in which Republican-controlled states where voter ID laws have been invalidated in courts have found other ways to make it hard for new voters to get access to the polls.
    • Oct 26, 2016
  • More »

More by Fritz Brantley

  • Words, Dec. 20

    Introducing an old movie on the old movie channel the other night, the host told an old story. The story is untrue, although I suppose the host, semi-old, believed it.
    • Dec 20, 2007
  • He talks, and talks, the talk

    A fellow posted an old newspaper article on his blog about a Mike Huckabee speech to a religious group in 1998. A friend faxed the article to me, then called to ask if I’d yet read it, which I had.
    • Dec 20, 2007
  • Going whole hog

    A Q&A with irreverent Arkansas-raised comedian Matt Besser
    • Dec 20, 2007
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • The education legislature

    Republican political control in Arkansas means many things: lots of gun bills, lots of anti-abortion bills, lots of efforts to make religious belief law, such as discrimination against gay people.
    • Mar 10, 2015
  • Supremely discredited

    Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Rhonda Wood and her allies continue to discredit the state's highest court.
    • Jul 30, 2015
  • Hutchinson pulls Faubus move

    I don't know what if anything might arise or be planned in the future relative to Gov. Asa Hutchinson's order to end Medicaid reimbursement for medical services (not abortion) provided by Planned Parenthood in Arkansas.
    • Aug 20, 2015

Most Shared

  • Welfare for the wealthy: More reasons to VOTE NO on ISSUE 3

    Voices on the left and right are lifted against Issue 3, the corporate welfare amendment to send tax money to private business and corporate lobbyists.
  • Little Rock police kill man downtown

    Little Rock police responding to a disturbance call near Eighth and Sherman Streets about 12:40 a.m. killed a man with a long gun, Police Chief Kenton Buckner said in an early morning meeting with reporters.
  • From the mind of Sol LeWitt: Crystal Bridges 'Loopy Doopy': A correction

    Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art is installing Sol Lewitt's 70-foot eye-crosser "Wall Drawing 880: Loopy Doopy," waves of complementary orange and green, on the outside of the Twentieth Century Gallery bridge. You can glimpse painters working on it from Eleven, the museum's restaurant, museum spokeswoman Beth Bobbitt said

Latest in Max Brantley

  • Trumped in Arkansas

    After two solid debates and the release of a video and corroborating testimony that further confirmed the misogyny of Donald Trump, Hillary Clinton is favored to win the presidential election Nov. 8
    • Oct 20, 2016
  • So many provocations...

    Another bad week demands a Worst Of listing.
    • Oct 6, 2016
  • State university secrets

    Today's subject: lack of accountability at state universities.
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • More »

Visit Arkansas

Searching for diamonds at Crater of Diamonds State Park

Searching for diamonds at Crater of Diamonds State Park

A venture to this state park is on the must-do list for many, the park being the only spot in North America where you can dig for diamonds and other gemstones and keep your finds.

Event Calendar

« »


2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31  

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: The big loser

    • Investigator, you are none of those things, but simply a serial ranter. At this you…

    • on October 26, 2016
  • Re: The big loser

    • If they really wanted to knockout the Clinton's, they would have done so with guilty…

    • on October 26, 2016
  • Re: Trumped in Arkansas

    • What a funny article, I hope sarcasm was your intent! First, since this was written…

    • on October 23, 2016

© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation