Favorite

If not Obamacare, then what? 

We are 11 months from a President Trump, Clinton, Sanders, Cruz or Rubio and a final reckoning on what to do with Obamacare.

We are 11 months from a President Trump, Clinton, Sanders, Cruz or Rubio and a final reckoning on what to do with Obamacare. In five years, the House of Representatives has voted more than 60 times to repeal it, but if one of the three Republicans sits in the Oval Office and the Senate remains Republican, this time it would mean something. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act would disappear, 15 million people would lose their health insurance and everyone else's insurance would be affected.

Ending the widely unpopular law has been the first goal of the Republican Party and all but a couple of the vast field of presidential candidates. You would expect that, so close to the goal, the remaining five would by now have the outlines of a plan to replace it.

You would be wrong.

In the last GOP debate, CNN interrogators belabored the candidates to describe their plans because all had said they would install something better. It produced the best fireworks of the debates: Marco Rubio taunting the suddenly ruffled Trump for endlessly repeating empty catchphrases. Rubio was right, but no one was much better than Trump. They offered old ideas that are already in the law but unpopular or else solutions that already are a part of Obamacare. But no one dares to say that their popular notions are already part of the law. We have some history of that in Arkansas: provider-reimbursement reforms, the "private option" and now "Arkansas Works," Gov. Hutchinson's plan for "replacing" Obamacare for the poor.

On the Democratic side, both Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders would continue Obamacare. Sanders would convert it incrementally into a single-payer system for all. Clinton would make improvements, mostly those that would have gotten into the law in 2010 when the Senate bill and the better House version went to conference, but the loss of a filibuster-proof majority with the death of Ted Kennedy forced Congress and the president to take the Senate bill. Republican majorities since 2011 have made it impossible to change even a comma of the law, and without Democratic majorities in both houses neither Sanders nor Clinton could fix a sentence.

So any change, good or bad, in Obamacare rests with a Republican president. None of the candidates had an answer that should satisfy the most rabid haters or the mildest critics of Obamacare. That is because no one has come up with a workable plan, unless it is to leave 25 million Americans who can't afford the premiums to their own devices. The basic elements of Obamacare — mandatory insurance for individuals and large employers — was the conservative solution, devised by the Heritage Foundation and pushed by Republicans in both houses in 1993-94 and earlier by Presidents Nixon and Ford. The Nixon-Ford plan required all employers to provide managed care for their employees.

His opponents went after poor Gov. John Kasich because when he was in the Republican leadership in the 1990s, he and his colleagues sponsored Obamacare's mandates and Medicaid expansion. Kasich said he now knows better.

Then he proceeded to explain how, as governor of Ohio, he had fashioned changes that expanded coverage and made huge savings in health care. He will bring those reforms to the whole country. Indeed, Kasich expanded coverage in Ohio by implementing Obamacare's Medicaid expansion for childless adults and for children. Left unsaid was that his big reforms in provider reimbursement, which vastly improved patient care, was a pilot project that Obamacare urged states to experiment with in hopes that it would spread across the insurance market. Arkansas led the way in that, too, with similar results. Former Gov. Beebe and Hutchinson never credited Obamacare either, or it would have failed.

Trump promised to replace Obamacare with a plan that insured everyone. No one would die on the sidewalk for lack of medical attention. "How?" Rubio kept demanding. Trump said he would allow insurers to sell policies across state lines, an idea that Cruz and Rubio also embrace. (Actually, Obamacare calls for that, too, in section 1333. Only a few states have enacted the interstate compacts that make it possible.)

For Cruz, Rubio and Ben Carson, the big solution to Obamacare is the individual health saving account (HSA), a version of the old medical savings account. But people have been able to set up HSAs along with cheap high-deductible plans since 2003. Unless you make a lot of money and are young and healthy, they are not very useful and have not proved popular.

I think I see the future of Obamacare under any of these politicians. Mike Beebe and Asa Hutchinson developed the model. Repeal Obamacare, re-enact nearly all of it with new language and tweaks and call it something else. The politics is dubious but it's workable government.

Favorite

Speaking of Obamacare

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Cotton ploy result: Iran gets the bomb

    Sen. Tom Cotton's big grandstanding play against President Obama may not produce the war with Iran or some other Muslim country that he seems to want, but it might give us the next worst thing, a nuclear-armed Iran.
    • Mar 10, 2015
  • Jobs added, not lost, thanks to Obamacare

    Before suspending our fascination with Arkansas's rocky love affair with Obamacare and its "private option" for the rest of 2015, may we re-examine a couple of the great propaganda frauds that were perpetuated during the long battles in Arkansas and nationally?
    • Feb 12, 2015
  • In God's name

    Because I'm not running for anything, I can give it to you straight: Christianity pretty much got out of the genocide business when church and state became separated in the United States and Europe following the American Revolution.
    • Feb 12, 2015

Most Shared

Latest in Ernest Dumas

  • EpiPen lesson

    Congressional Republicans and Democrats staged a rousing display of rage against the CEO whose company gouged a fortune from families whose kids and sometimes grownups need the lifesaving properties of the drug EpiPen.
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • New normal

    No two presidential candidates since polling began have run up negatives as massive as those of Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton, who yet won their parties' nominations easily. "What gives?" may be the biggest political mystery in history.
    • Sep 22, 2016
  • Privacy hurts

    Hillary Clinton's decision to keep her mild case of pneumonia secret from all but a few of her staff and family may be only a momentary campaign distraction, but it raises the question: Will she ever get it?
    • Sep 15, 2016
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

September

S M T W T F S
  1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30  

Most Viewed

  • EpiPen lesson

    Congressional Republicans and Democrats staged a rousing display of rage against the CEO whose company gouged a fortune from families whose kids and sometimes grownups need the lifesaving properties of the drug EpiPen.
  • State university secrets

    Today's subject: lack of accountability at state universities.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Don't blame trigger warnings

    • I have experienced 2 on the list of worst things I feel a woman could…

    • on September 27, 2016
 

© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation