Favorite

Independent judiciary: Rapert doesn't get it 

click to enlarge Sen. Jason Rapert image
  • Brian Chilson
  • Sen. Jason Rapert

What do Alexander Hamilton, state Sen. Jason Rapert of Bigelow and the opinion editors at the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette have in common? Not much.

For two weeks, the statewide newspaper had given Pulaski Circuit Judge Chris Piazza as thorough a verbal whipping as you can lay on a judge for doing what the law requires him to do, decide lawsuits, after he held that state laws prohibiting legal recognition of same-sex partnerships violated their constitutional protections.

Then Sunday the paper gave nearly two full pages of its opinion section to Rapert for an amazing screed against Piazza, the homosexual "lobby" and assorted critics of the senator. The giant piece — it ran to nearly 3,000 words and was decorated with patriotic art and headline ("We the People") — began with Abraham Lincoln, closed with George Washington and along the way liberally invoked Thomas Jefferson, "the founding fathers" and Ronald Reagan. None of them ever had a word to say that bore on whether same-sex couples deserved to have legal protections or whether judges could or ought to rule that they did.

Notably missing was the one sainted historical figure who was relevant to the whole controversy. That is Hamilton, the greatest constitutionalist. He directed the writing of the Federalist Papers on the proposed constitution and wrote all the essays explaining the need for a coequal judicial branch with the power and will to review decisions of the other branches and to protect the rights of minorities.

That is what the outsized controversy over Piazza's decision is all about — whether courts have the power to annul laws passed by legislatures or by a majority of voters if they violate the Constitution. Rapert says courts don't have that power and claims a good part of the legislature is in his corner. Hamilton established the power of judicial review in the most famous Federalist tract, the Supreme Court affirmed it in 1803 and thousands of courts have exercised the power for two centuries.

The newspaper's position is not so clear on anything about Piazza's decision except that he is incompetent and out of control. Uniformly, judges all across America for the past nine months have rendered the same decision, but it is safe to say none has gotten such a savaging as Piazza, a judge who has been elected to the bench for 23 years without a whiff of scandal and who enjoys a record of approval by superior courts that is about as unsullied as a trial judge can have.

So what did Hamilton, who is honored above all the founders for his bravery, political principle and intellectual acuity, have to say about this mess? This, in Federalist 78: "The independence of the judges may be an essential safeguard against the effects of occasional ill humors in the society. These sometimes extend no farther than to the injury of the private rights of particular classes of citizens, by unjust and partial laws."

Does that describe the situation with same-sex partnerships just about perfectly?

Piazza is not really the object of the screeds. The Arkansas Supreme Court is. The seven justices will decide the issue, perhaps as early as this winter but whenever it can no longer prolong the ordeal. The justices are all elected or else serving interim appointments. The founders gave federal judges lifetime appointments, contingent on good behavior, to assure them of independence from the political branches and from the electorate. Some of the states, like Arkansas, disagreed with the founders on an independent judiciary and elect their judges.

Will the Arkansas supremes get the message from the editorials and columns from the only statewide medium and from legislative screeds? You bet. Except those approaching 70, they are looking at re-election or, in the case of Justice Courtney Goodson, running for chief justice. Another new justice in January, Rhonda Wood, has bigger political ambitions. Can they afford to throw their careers on the rocks by legalizing same-sex marriages or civil unions?

Twice in the last dozen years, the state Supreme Court has upheld the principle in Piazza's decision, that the government cannot deny couples rights that others enjoy simply because they are of the same sex. Not one of the 10 justices who participated in those decisions said the government could punish couples for homosexual conduct or deny them adoption and foster-parenting privileges.

The court has not always been so independent or, shall we say, courageous.

After one of Piazza's predecessors held in 1967 that Arkansas's voter-approved law banning mention of evolution in schools violated the First Amendment, the case went up to a mostly terrified Supreme Court.

The chief justice, fearing popular loathing of his beloved court, begged his colleagues to be united. But it split 4 to 3 for upholding the law. The issue seethed in chambers for more than a year until on the last day of the term two of the dissenters agreed to switch their votes as long as their names were not appended to an opinion defending the law. The ruling came down without a word of explanation. Justice Lyle Brown is reported to have flung his ringing dissent at the others the last day and announced that he would be recorded as voting no even if he was not allowed to say why.

The U.S. Supreme Court reversed them and ridiculed the Arkansas justices for their cowardice. It took some time for the court to recoup its honor.

Favorite

Speaking of...

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

More by Ernest Dumas

  • Truth on Iraq

    Jeb Bush's still prospective race for president took a little nosedive when he bungled questions from friendly agents at Fox television about his brother's invasion of Iraq. If Fox News can foil a Republican so easily, people asked, could he be seriously considered for the party's nomination?
    • May 21, 2015
  • God won't win it for Bro.-Gov. Huck

    Mike Huckabee may have hit upon the right strategy for the early presidential sweepstakes by blending religious fanaticism and a weird (for a Republican) progovernment populism, but the old preacher's calculations may look a little too, well, calculating.
    • May 14, 2015
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Brantley: Gay equality now

    Thanks to court rulings and changing public sentiment, gradualism has disappeared from the vocabulary of advocates for gay equality. That has certain adverse consequences in the darker corners of the world. Places like Arkansas.
    • Oct 31, 2013
  • Billionaires' dirty laundering

    The state of California, often the pacesetter for governmental reform, struck a small blow for democracy and openness last week when it forced two dark-money groups to admit they had illegally laundered $15 million from secret businessmen to influence voters on two ballot issues, one that would raise their taxes and the other that would trim the political clout of California unions.
    • Oct 31, 2013
  • Obamacare will help people, not politicians

    It was predictable that the rollout of the new insurance markets under Obamacare would be troubled, maybe even nightmarish. In fact, that was exactly what was predicted when Republicans first proposed mandatory market-oriented insurance — 40 years ago in the case of employer-sponsored insurance and 25 years ago in the case of an individual mandate.
    • Nov 21, 2013

Most Shared

  • Womack gets plucked by 'Last Week Tonight with John Oliver'

    HBO's "Last Week Tonight with John Oliver, which premiered last April, has consistently shown itself to be a Daily Show-level contender for the humor-news crown. Up for discussion on the show last night: the myriad ways major poultry producers exploit chicken farmers. Also featured in the video: Arkansas Republican Rep. Steve Womack, who gets plucked and roasted for placing a rider on the agriculture appropriations bill that forbids the USDA from enforcing already-written protections for the nation's poultry farmers.
  • Magazine obtains police report over Josh Duggar sexual molestation investigation; he admits past 'mistakes,' resigns Family Council job

    In Touch magazine reports that it has obtained a Springdale police report containing allegations of sexual misconduct against an unnamed teen that it says it has confirmed was Josh Duggar, a minor at the time and now a prominent lobbyist for the Family Research Council and a leading voice for legal discrimination against gay people.
  • State budget administrator Brandon Sharp fired; no reason given

    KATV reports that Brandon Sharp was fired Monday afternoon after four years as state budget administrator, a $101,000-a-year job in the Department of Finance and Administration.
  • KATV: Bill Walker's state agency approves grants to sister UPDATE

    KATV has dug up on questionable public dealings by a familiar figure — former state Sen. Bill Walker, who headed the state Career Education Department during the administration of Gov. Mike Beebe.
  • What's not to love about the Bentonville Film Festival? Walmart.

    The Bentonville Film Festival, launched this year by actress Geena Davis and held earlier this month from May 5-9, earned a number of largely positive notices from major outlets like the Huffington Post ("At the Bentonville Film Festival, Women Are Playing in the Major Leagues"), the L.A. Times ("Bentonville Film Festival pushes diversity message from year one") and the New York Times ("Bentonville, Ark., Hosts a Film Festival Without a Movie Theater"), most of them centering on its unique and vital agenda — promoting diversity and gender equality in filmmaking — and its celebrity cache (e.g. an acting workshop taught by Robert De Niro, a softball game led by Rosie O'Donnell, etc.).

Latest in Ernest Dumas

  • Truth on Iraq

    Jeb Bush's still prospective race for president took a little nosedive when he bungled questions from friendly agents at Fox television about his brother's invasion of Iraq. If Fox News can foil a Republican so easily, people asked, could he be seriously considered for the party's nomination?
    • May 21, 2015
  • God won't win it for Bro.-Gov. Huck

    Mike Huckabee may have hit upon the right strategy for the early presidential sweepstakes by blending religious fanaticism and a weird (for a Republican) progovernment populism, but the old preacher's calculations may look a little too, well, calculating.
    • May 14, 2015
  • Lose Obamacare, lose tax cuts

    team of 40 health experts, a task force of 14 Arkansas legislators and a company of corporate consultants backed by millions of taxpayer dollars are assembling to attempt the hardest political gambit of our time: how to make Obamacare look like it's not Obamacare.
    • May 7, 2015
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

May

S M T W T F S
  1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31  

Most Viewed

  • While I was away...

    I'm just back from two weeks out of the country. A couple of catchups.
  • Truth on Iraq

    Jeb Bush's still prospective race for president took a little nosedive when he bungled questions from friendly agents at Fox television about his brother's invasion of Iraq. If Fox News can foil a Republican so easily, people asked, could he be seriously considered for the party's nomination?
  • 'Proactive' policing

    On Monday, after six months of study, President Obama's Task Force on 21st Century Policing released its 100-plus page final report.
  • NFL blows it

    The bombast and grandiosity of NFL football have always put me off. Fans too often treat ballgames as if they were wars between rival tribes or nation states; symbolic struggles between good and evil. As somebody who watches probably 150 major league baseball games a year, I find the hype alternately exhausting and ridiculous.

Most Recent Comments

 

© 2015 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation