Will merit pay for public school teachers lead to better academic performance by students? I don’t know. So far the results are inconclusive.

What I do know is that the merit pay advocates in Arkansas continue to try to fund pilot programs anonymously, bypassing public discussion, choosing schools that are most likely to produce the best outcomes and then also paying for evaluations conducted by sympathetic analysts.

It’s infuriating to those of us who are open-minded about the potential of merit pay and other education reforms, but who believe that people with deep pockets shouldn’t be able to unilaterally and secretly impose their will on public institutions.

However, if Gov. Mike Beebe follows up on the promise he made in his State of the State address to launch a statewide pilot program for merit pay in the public schools, he could set some much-needed ground rules for how merit pay is tested in Arkansas.

Back in 2004, an anonymous donor financed the first merit pay experiment in the Little Rock School District, which was instituted by Superintendent Roy Brooks without consultation with the elected school board. (The funder was later revealed to be the Hussman Foundation, directed by Walter Hussman, publisher of the state’s largest newspaper, the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette.)

Similar tactics were used in Rogers last week, when the deputy superintendent of the Rogers public schools, Mark Sparks, announced that anonymous donors had pledged $2 million toward a potential merit pay program. The school board president said she didn’t know the identity of the donors. (Actually, it turned out to be just one donor: the Walton Family Foundation, as disclosed under duress on Jan. 26.)

“They have purchased the right to decide whether or not they are going to be private or public,” Sparks said of the donor. “It’s their choice, and if they choose to be public, that’s their business.”

That’s an incredible statement, really. Our taxes provide the bulk of the funding for public schools, and we elect school board members to set policies and oversee administration.

But apparently all it takes is a big infusion of cash to override the democratic process and get your favorite idea implemented in the public schools. Never mind if that idea is controversial or unproven. There is no need for a discussion or a vote — and no need to reveal your identity.

And along with your charitable gift (which was tax deductible because it was funneled through the non-profit foundation you control), you also get to dictate exactly where and how your idea is carried out.

In Little Rock, for instance, the privately-funded experimental merit pay programs were instituted only at select elementary schools — arguably the ones where test-score improvement was most likely to occur.

Finally, if you want to pay for the official evaluation of your pet project, go right ahead!

That courtesy was extended to the Walton Family Foundation, which not only funded merit pay pilot programs in Little Rock last year, but which also paid for the evaluation of those programs, which was conducted by the University of Arkansas’s Department of Education Reform, which was established two years ago with a $20 million grant from the Walton Family Foundation.

Isn’t that ridiculous?

Not surprisingly, the Walton-funded report by the Walton-funded academics about the Walton-funded Little Rock merit pay program was positive and uncritical. The researchers don’t compare the merit pay and non-merit pay schools on an equal basis, they ignore important demographic factors, they extrapolate from small samples, and worst of all, they won’t disclose the evaluation formulas they used.

But the merit pay advocates will no longer be able to freely manipulate their Little Rock experiment, now that the recent school board elections have reversed the power dynamic and isolated their puppet, Superintendent Brooks. That explains their retreat to Rogers, where professors from the Education Reform department were already assisting the Rogers school district with its federal grant proposal for funds to support the new merit pay program.

Since it’s clear that Arkansas is the intended petri dish for further public merit pay experiments funded by private interests, this is a good time to set some clear parameters for how these and other proposed reforms are offered a trial in the public schools.

At the very least, state regulations should require disclosure of the funding source, public consultation with teachers and administrators, open hearings and approval by the elected school board, a comprehensive test sampling that encompasses the full range of student demographics, and a truly objective analysis of the results.

It’s unfortunate that we have been reduced to begging for a fair, democratic process in our own public schools. Isn’t it ironic that a program based on merit would bend over backwards to avoid a real test?


Comments (2)

Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-2 of 2

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • The freeway department talks fairness. No, not about making truckers pay fair share

    Noel Oman of the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette reported on plans underway at the Arkansas freeway department to raise the license fee for electric cars to what a gas-powered car pays in fuel taxes, maybe $180 a year. Fair? They say yes; I'm not so sure.
    • Jan 16, 2017
  • Goodson draws home staters for appeal in class action case

    John Goodson, the Texarkana lawyer, has a Feb. 7 date with the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to argue that he shouldn't have been disciplined by federal District Judge P.K. Holmes for switching a class action case against an insurance company out of federal court into a state court that speedily approved a settlement.
    • Jan 16, 2017
  • Free beer tomorrow: Trump's health plan

    Donald Trump has proclaimed that he has a health care plan coming that will cover everyone — yes, UNIVERSAL COVERAGE — and have lower deductible payments. More coverage for less, he suggests, with plenty of pain for Big Pharma in tough negotiating.
    • Jan 16, 2017
  • More »

More by Warwick Sabin

  • Helena's disappearing buildings

    Preservationists hope to slow demolitions.
    • Mar 22, 2007
  • Trailers headed to Dumas

    Gov. Mike Beebe issued the following statement earlier today: Although this decision by FEMA to deny emergency funds to Desha County defies common sense, Arkansas will take care of its own people.
    • Mar 9, 2007
  • Youth Ranch robbed, vandalized

    According to a press release we just received: The Donald W. Reynolds Campus of the Arkansas Sheriff’s Youth Ranches (The Ranch) located near Fort Smith was vandalized overnight Thursday.  Items stolen during the break-in included all of the children’s saddles, food, tools and supplies from The Ranch’s carpentry shop and all equipment from its auto shop.  An investigation is underway with the Crawford County Sheriff’s Office.
    • Mar 9, 2007
  • More »

Most Shared

  • UPDATE: Retired Arkansas Arts Center director Townsend Wolfe dies at 81

    Townsend Durant Wolfe, III, retired director and chief curator of the Arkansas Arts Center, has died at 81.
  • Subpoenas identify names of federal interest in kickback probe

    The Northwest Arkansas Economic Development District today provided me with the subpoena it received from federal investigators in a probe that led to former Republican Rep. Micah Neal's guilty plea to taking kickbacks from money he guided to a nonprofit agency and a private college in Springdale, apparently Ecclesia College.
  • Human Services says it's eliminated Medicaid application backlog

    The state Human Services Department has informed Gov. Asa Hutchinson that it has all but eliminated a backlog in applications for Medicaid coverage.
  • Praising Asa

    Let us now praise the governor for a starkly moderate record, at least in comparison with other red-state executives.
  • Glass houses

    Having gotten a deep security briefing and probably a confidential glimpse of our own vast cyberspying operation, Donald Trump is no longer pretty sure that the Kremlin didn't hack Democratic computers or employ other tactics to help his election.

Latest in Warwick Sabin

  • Trickle-up theory

    Through thick and thin, there has always been one group of dedicated Americans whose support for President George W. Bush has been unwavering: The wealthy.
    • Mar 8, 2007
  • Time to go

    Tough questions face us in Iraq and it's time to confront them directly.
    • Mar 1, 2007
  • Plugged in

    One reason why the South remained solidly Democratic during the mid-20th century was the enduring gratitude to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who brought electricity to the poor, rural parts of the region. According to one historical account, “Althou
    • Feb 22, 2007
  • More »

Visit Arkansas

Indian Rock House at Fairfield Bay

Indian Rock House at Fairfield Bay

Winter is the perfect time to explore the natural stone shelters where native Arkansans once lived

Event Calendar

« »


1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31  

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Hillbillies

    • One last thought - oh, Nanc, do try not to refer to your children, adorable…

    • on January 14, 2017
  • Re: Hillbillies

    • Dearest Nanc - My, my - showing a good bit of hatred yourself, Look into…

    • on January 14, 2017
  • Re: Hillbillies

    • I'm with you all the way, Nanc.

    • on January 14, 2017

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation