Taking on the little guys 

There is one issue being overlooked in all of the comment surrounding the anti-immigration legislation recently introduced in the Arkansas legislature. The most controversial bill, Senate Bill 206, is sponsored by Sen. Jim Holt and is intended to prevent illegal immigrants from claiming state benefits or registering to vote. It proved an easy target for critics, including Gov. Mike Huckabee, who pointed out that the federal government requires states to make many aid programs available to anyone in need, regardless of citizenship status. Furthermore, they point out, it is heartless and shortsighted to deny something like prenatal care to a pregnant immigrant whose child will be a U.S. citizen at birth. That said, this episode is yet another example of how the immigration debate in Arkansas and nationwide never touches the fundamental issues: Do we want to limit immigration at all? If so, how do we enforce the laws? If not, how will that affect our economy, and how do we provide for our national security in an age of terrorism? After all, if Holt and his allies have a point (and I’m being generous here), it is where they argue that our laws are not being enforced. But they overlook the fact that the illegal immigrants they condemn wouldn’t be here in the first place if businesses were not illegally employing them. Anyone who hires an illegal immigrant cannot claim ignorance of the matter. A fake Social Security number will bring a letter from the IRS, assuming the employer files the tax information in the first place. Businesses that exploit illegal immigrant labor reap many benefits. Of course, they can pay the workers less than minimum wage, often off the books. They can hire and fire at will, knowing that the immigrants are desperate for jobs. Illegal immigrants cannot organize or bring lawsuits if they are injured or otherwise treated unfairly. By taking advantage of these benefits, businesses that use illegal workers have an edge over any competition that actually abides by the law. And for every illegal immigrant they pay at a reduced rate, there is a citizen who is denied a job that would garner at least minimum wage, which contributes to a higher unemployment rate and less money overall circulating in the retail economy. Needless to say, many business owners like this arrangement, and that is why they favor loose enforcement of immigration laws. They want to maintain a cheap labor pool, which explains why President Bush — not usually the champion of the underdog — is advocating for guest worker visas and other measures to ease the passage of people across our borders. It is foolish to believe that he has the interests of immigrants in mind. As always, he is listening to corporate interests, but he can claim that he is motivated by compassion. With this in mind, Holt should be denounced as a hypocrite. At one point, he said, “I just want to uphold the law,” and explained, “I would be doing a disservice to my children as a father to continue to let them do things illegal or wrongly without correcting them.” His partner in this effort, an anti-immigration activist named Joe McCutchen, also said, “Doggone it, the rule of law is not being upheld, and that’s wrong.” If enforcing the law is their interest, Holt and McCutchen could target the well-educated business owners who know the law and are willfully violating it for profit. Instead they are going after the basic social benefits enjoyed by a defenseless group of underprivileged people. Perhaps they thought it would be easier to demagogue against individuals with a different skin hue than to challenge some of the most powerful interests in the state. It is certainly easier than dealing with the complexities of the issue, which can be distilled to this: There is a demand for cheap labor that illegal immigration satisfies, and the efficiencies that result translate to cheaper consumer products, which benefit the entire economy. If we acknowledge this, then we realize that it doesn’t make sense to strictly enforce immigration laws. Then why have them in the first place? Because, ironically, if we didn’t have the laws to break, then you couldn’t have the cheaper labor, because the immigrants would be legal, and you would have to pay them at least the minimum wage. So when it comes to immigration, big business and liberal social activists agree: “Don’t ask, don’t tell.”


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Thursday's open line and the daily video

    Here's the open line and the daily video.
    • Oct 27, 2016
  • UPDATE: Ted Suhl gets seven years, $200,000 fine for bribery

    Ted Suhl was sentenced this morning by federal Judge Billy Roy Wilson on four counts of attempting to bribe a state official to help his mental health business supported by Medicaid money. He received 84 months and a $200,000 fine and is to report to prison in early January. He will appeal.
    • Oct 27, 2016
  • Question raised on Dallas Cowboy gift to NLR cops

    Blogger Russ Racop raises an interesting question, as he sometimes does, about Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones' gift of free tickets for North Little Rock cops to attend a Dallas Cowboy football game.
    • Oct 27, 2016
  • More »

More by Warwick Sabin

  • Helena's disappearing buildings

    Preservationists hope to slow demolitions.
    • Mar 22, 2007
  • Trailers headed to Dumas

    Gov. Mike Beebe issued the following statement earlier today: Although this decision by FEMA to deny emergency funds to Desha County defies common sense, Arkansas will take care of its own people.
    • Mar 9, 2007
  • Youth Ranch robbed, vandalized

    According to a press release we just received: The Donald W. Reynolds Campus of the Arkansas Sheriff’s Youth Ranches (The Ranch) located near Fort Smith was vandalized overnight Thursday.  Items stolen during the break-in included all of the children’s saddles, food, tools and supplies from The Ranch’s carpentry shop and all equipment from its auto shop.  An investigation is underway with the Crawford County Sheriff’s Office.
    • Mar 9, 2007
  • More »

Most Shared

  • Issue 3: blank check

    Who could object to a constitutional amendment "concerning job creation, job expansion and economic development," which is the condensed title for Issue 3 for Arkansas voters on Nov. 8?
  • Little Rock police kill man downtown

    Little Rock police responding to a disturbance call near Eighth and Sherman Streets about 12:40 a.m. killed a man with a long gun, Police Chief Kenton Buckner said in an early morning meeting with reporters.
  • From the mind of Sol LeWitt: Crystal Bridges 'Loopy Doopy': A correction

    Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art is installing Sol Lewitt's 70-foot eye-crosser "Wall Drawing 880: Loopy Doopy," waves of complementary orange and green, on the outside of the Twentieth Century Gallery bridge. You can glimpse painters working on it from Eleven, the museum's restaurant, museum spokeswoman Beth Bobbitt said
  • Ted Suhl loses another bid for new trial; faces stiff sentencing recommendation

    Ted Suhl, the former operator of residential and out-patient mental health services, has lost a second bid to get a new trial on his conviction for paying bribes to influence state Human Services Department policies. Set for sentencing Thursday, Suhl faces a government request for a sentence up to almost 20 years. He argues for no more than 33 months.
  • Football and foster kids

    It took a football stadium to lay bare Republican budget hypocrisy in Arkansas.

Latest in Warwick Sabin

  • Trickle-up theory

    Through thick and thin, there has always been one group of dedicated Americans whose support for President George W. Bush has been unwavering: The wealthy.
    • Mar 8, 2007
  • Time to go

    Tough questions face us in Iraq and it's time to confront them directly.
    • Mar 1, 2007
  • Plugged in

    One reason why the South remained solidly Democratic during the mid-20th century was the enduring gratitude to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who brought electricity to the poor, rural parts of the region. According to one historical account, “Althou
    • Feb 22, 2007
  • More »

Visit Arkansas

Jodi Morris's lifelong ties to the National Park Service

Jodi Morris's lifelong ties to the National Park Service

"History is always happening" at Little Rock Central High School National Historic Site

Event Calendar

« »


2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31  

Most Viewed

  • The politics of opportunity

    Are you sick of the election yet? One thing that seems certain is that our politics remain as hyperpartisan and dysfunctional as ever. I may be naive, but I think Arkansas has an opportunity to help lead the country back toward pragmatic progress on the issues that will make our families and communities stronger.
  • The end is near

    Practically speaking, it doesn't really matter if Donald Trump accepts the results of the November election.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Football and foster kids

    • I think Bart Hester just hates tax dollars being spent anywhere for anything.

    • on October 27, 2016
  • Re: The politics of opportunity

    • Maybe we need to revive a grassroots movement to have (1) nonpartisan redistricting (2)Top two…

    • on October 27, 2016
  • Re: The politics of opportunity

    • I don't see the collective will to accomplish these things, either within or out of…

    • on October 27, 2016

© 2016 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation