The torture debate 

'Zero Dark Thirty' presents it as dehumanizing, but necessary.

click to enlarge 'ZERO DARK THIRTY': Jessica Chastain stars image
  • 'ZERO DARK THIRTY': Jessica Chastain stars.

The early criticism of "Zero Dark Thirty," the gut-churning account of the CIA's hunt for Osama bin Laden, has focused rightly on some of its most memorable and vital scenes: Those early in the film of agents torturing informants. In the movie, the torture works. In real life, not nearly so much. Three senators who reviewed classified information while on the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence sent a letter to Sony Pictures stating that, contrary to the film, none of the tips the CIA received that led to learning the name of bin Laden's courier, Ibrahim Saeed Ahmed (a.k.a. Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti), came through "coercive interrogation techniques."

Because the film does show torture as a pragmatic if awful implement of those interrogations, people have tried to ask the filmmakers — director Kathryn Bigelow and screenwriter Mark Boal, collaborators previously on "The Hurt Locker" — why the hell they'd depict torture as being more productive than it was. When "Zero Dark Thirty" premiered in Washington, Bigelow and Boal slunk out early, behind a retaining wall of bodyguards, rather than answer reporters' questions.

The implications of tacitly praising torture are profound. Exactly what the United States is willing to do to human beings in order to meet military objectives is a serious question, and the impact of "Zero Dark Thirty," which is up for Best Picture among its five Oscar nods, stands to cast a long shadow over that popular discussion. It doesn't help that the CIA has acknowledged destroying tapes of interrogations and that America generally is happy to be kept in the dark on such matters. As a Human Rights Watch counterterrorism advisor recently wrote in Foreign Policy: "We would not even be having this debate, and this film probably would not have even been made in the way it was, had the U.S. government not gone to such great lengths over the past 11 years to cover up the tracks of its crimes and bury the facts."

What the movie gets right, at least for all appearances, is its depiction of torture as a nasty, brutish, dehumanizing slog for both the detainees and the interrogators. And once "Zero Dark Thirty" gets moving, it's just an overall ripping docudrama. Jessica Chastain has an Oscar nod for her turn as Maya, a CIA agent in Pakistan who for almost 10 years doggedly chases leads in pursuit of bin Laden, even as his influence wanes and he becomes a relative afterthought among the other intelligence brass. Jason Clarke plays a waterboarding field agent who moves up the ranks; Jennifer Ehle is another in-country CIA pal of Maya's. Among the few characters with publicly known names are Kyle Chandler as Joseph Bradley and James Gandolfini as Leon Panetta. Mostly, this is a tribute to nameless spooks.

Spoiler alert: That courier of bin Laden's, once found, inadvertently led the CIA to the gates of the infamous compound that Navy SEALS stormed on May 2, 2011. The final series of events as they appear in the film are positively gripping; the siege of the compound, complete with the shooting of bin Laden and digital photos of his corpse, is meticulously rendered, playing in real time like the world's most infamous episode of "Cops." But then, the entire movie plays as an extended infomercial on why you don't want to mess with America.

The power of "Zero Dark Thirty," despite its often dense dialogue and its tripodless nausea-cam cinematography, is that it yanks the audience through a chapter of recent history that we cannot help but find fascinating. The stakes are high, and we know them intimately. Anyone who sees "Zero Dark Thirty" will recall its depictions of events when trying to imagine what that compound raid was like, or what life in Pakistan for American operatives is like, or what life for suspected terrorists is like in the secret CIA prisons that were set up around the world after 9/11.

The risk for history is that this film, for all its authenticity, leads us to believe it's showing events as they truly were. It may be close, but "Zero Dark Thirty" is still just a movie, a work of unsettling fiction that shouldn't make us any more comfortable with the choices that were made in our names.

Film Details

Zero Dark Thirty
Rated R · 157 min. · 2013
Official Site: www.zerodarkthirty-movie.com/site
Director: Kathryn Bigelow
Writer: Mark Boal
Producer: Mark Boal, Kathryn Bigelow, Megan Ellison, Colin Wilson, Greg Shapiro and Ted Schipper
Cast: Jessica Chastain, Jason Clarke, Joel Edgerton, Jennifer Ehle, Mark Strong, Kyle Chandler and Edgar Ramirez

Trailer


Now Playing

Sorry there are no upcoming showtimes for Zero Dark Thirty

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Sam Eifling

Most Shared

  • The TC Edwards memorial roundup

    TC Edwards had hundreds of friends. If you were among them or even somewhere on the periphery, your Facebook feed has been dominated this week by tributes and photos and news of benefit concerts. Here's an attempt at a roundup of everything that's out there, with a focus on all the things you can do or attend.
  • Psych of the South: The Mercenaries' 'Things Found Here'

    Recently, a trove of band business cards from the golden era of Arkansas garage bands was discovered and put on eBay. I was able to purchase some of them, including one by a little known 1960s garage band from Little Rock named The Mercenaries. Their record, on the cult favorite MY records label based in Little Rock, was released in early 1967. Their songs, including the atmospheric and heavy “Things Found Here” along with the psychedelic tinged “Take It All” are obscure even by garage rock standards. They were not featured on the 1999 Butler Center MY records compilation and their story has not been told before
  • Photos from March for TC

    Last night, dozens of friends of TC Edwards, the Little Rock musician and man on the scene who was found murdered Dec. 7, marched in his memory, chanting "Justice for TC" and "TC is metal" as they walked from Pizza D' Action up Kavanaugh.
  • Arkansas Baptist College receives $30 million federal loan; expected to ease cash crunch

    Arkansas Baptist College officials say they have received news of approval of a federal loan that is expected to stabilize the college's finances after a period of struggle.
  • Alderman says he'll try again for Fayetteville civil rights ordinance

    Fayetteville Alderman Matt Petty says he'll try again to pass a city civil rights ordinance that extends some protections to LGBT people.

Latest in Movie Reviews

Event Calendar

« »

December

S M T W T F S
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31  
 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation