Favorite

The TV effect 

As yet another make-believe Washington "crisis" looms, it's tempting to suspect that the most fraught interludes in American politics derive from turning government into a TV show. Artificial deadlines, imaginary cliffs, villains and heroes; a state of permanent emergency. These well-worn dramatic devices have been the stuff of serial melodrama from the "Perils of Pauline" through "24."

No sooner was the 2012 presidential election blessedly ended than journalists started handicapping the 2016 presidential election overnight.

Next, new crisis was declared. OMG! The Fiscal Cliff! OMG!

Without a conflict, see, there's no story.

So must we therefore govern the country according to the narrative conventions of spy thrillers to boost cable news network ratings and to insure pundits and politicians plenty of TV face time?

Apparently so. However, is it really good for our democracy that many otherwise normal Americans recognize figures like Rep. Eric Cantor (R-Va.) or Sen. Claire McKaskill (D-Mo.) on sight? To put it another way, if I weren't a subscriber to the NBA League Pass, would I too stand in danger of turning into a "fiscal cliff" junkie between now and January 2 — feverishly flipping from MSNBC to Fox seeking fresh excitement and outrage?

In his 1997 book "Breaking the News: How the Media Undermine American Democracy," James Fallows explained a lot about what drives such coverage. "Why do [journalists] want to appear [on TV], when so many reporters make fun of the shows?" he asked. "The most immediate payoff is the simple thrill of being noticed and known. Political-journalistic Washington functions much like a big high school, with cliques of the popular kids, the nerds, the rebels, the left-outs, and so on. To be on TV is to become very quickly a cool kid. Friends call to say they've seen you. People recognize you in stores. Whether people agree or disagree with what you said (or whether they even remember), they treat you as 'realer' and bigger than you were before."

And that was back when 24/7 cable TV political programming barely existed. Since then, print reporters have quit dismissing TV. (Most were only pretending to be snobs about it anyway.) Now they ponder how to become the next Ezra Klein.

The rewards, Fallows made clear, can be heady. Celebrity journalists "have that extra, sizzling experience of seeing strangers' heads flip back, for a second look ('Is it really him?') as they walk into restaurants or through airport corridors... [T]he recognition is almost entirely judgment-free...TV's effect is mainly to make you bigger than life. For each hundred acquaintances who will say, 'I saw you on the show,' only one will say, 'I agree [or disagree] with what you said.' "

And why is the pundit walking through airports? Most likely on his or her way to collect hefty speaking fees in the American outback, or to sign books likely never to have been written or published but for the author's TV appearances. You started out covering municipal sewer and water commission meetings, and now you're a star!

Having done just enough of this kind of thing to understand how it works, I'd add a secondary but very real danger. Going on TV can be very time-consuming and energy-absorbing. Between the time spent in limos and makeup rooms, not to mention dealing with the secondary effects of newfound celebrity, there's not much time left to do much real work.

So pundits start coasting, gradually drawing down their stock of genuine expertise — such as it is. Next comes faking. On camera, some talking head asks the journalist to opine about a topic that, strictly speaking, he knows bugger-all about. Instead of saying so, our hero cleverly paraphrases something he heard some other savant say on a different channel.

Remember during the campaign when Mitt Romney made a fool of himself explaining how Syria was Iran's route to the sea? (Iran has its own seacoast and no border with Syria.) I'd bet he'd heard that from some other big bluffer pretending to be worldly wise on cable TV.

Almost needless to say, if the potentially corrupting effects of TV celebrity can be bad for journalists, they're even worse for politicians. Under the best of circumstances, there's hardly enough available attention and acclaim from sea to shining sea to satisfy the average United States congressman. Add the ego-inflating thrill of being on a first-name basis with Bill O'Reilly or Erin Burnett, and what dramatic poses wouldn't a previously obscure pol from Utah or South Carolina strike to get on TV?

So heighten the contradictions. Ramp up the conflict. The Fiscal Cliff! OMG! It's not a budget debate, it's good vs. evil! Civilization hangs in the balance!

Except, no it doesn't. It's a budget fight that President Obama wins.

He's holding all the high cards; Republicans are playing a weak hand badly, and people are getting really fed up with the fake hysteria.

Favorite

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

More by Gene Lyons

  • New York Times fails again

    If one were of a low and suspicious nature regarding the New York Times' historically inept Washington Bureau, one might suspect yet another example of the "Clinton Rules" — that is, a shaky allegation unsupported by facts.
    • Aug 27, 2015
  • Same old song with Hillary

    Same as it ever was. Once again, according to pundits on the influential Washington, D.C., cocktail party circuit, Hillary Clinton is in deep trouble. The National Bitch Hunt is definitely on.
    • Aug 20, 2015
  • More »

Most Shared

  • Hutchinson's dilemma same as Beebe's and his GOP affiliation doesn't help

    Ernest Dumas writes about the difficulties faced by Gov. Asa Hutchinson in matching the achievements of Democratic Gov. Mike Beebe, even though he, like the majority of the legislature is a Republican. In short, Hutchinson needs Obamacare money, though his party rests on a foundation that hates Obamacare.
  • Visionary Arkansans 2015

    They make an impact.
  • Brantley: South toward home

    A two-week cruise from Vancouver to Alaska was nicely timed for the August heat wave. It dipped into the 40s during my visit to the Hubbard Glacier, loudly "calving" with mighty booms of cracking ice. Here's a brief politically tinged travelogue.
  • New York Times fails again

    If one were of a low and suspicious nature regarding the New York Times' historically inept Washington Bureau, one might suspect yet another example of the "Clinton Rules" — that is, a shaky allegation unsupported by facts.

Latest in Gene Lyons

  • New York Times fails again

    If one were of a low and suspicious nature regarding the New York Times' historically inept Washington Bureau, one might suspect yet another example of the "Clinton Rules" — that is, a shaky allegation unsupported by facts.
    • Aug 27, 2015
  • Same old song with Hillary

    Same as it ever was. Once again, according to pundits on the influential Washington, D.C., cocktail party circuit, Hillary Clinton is in deep trouble. The National Bitch Hunt is definitely on.
    • Aug 20, 2015
  • Cursing each other

    To establish my credentials, here's something that happened to my wife and me a bit before last year's tragedy in Ferguson, Mo. We'd taken our daily three-mile walk with the dogs along our gravel road, where encountering three vehicles is a busy day. Often we see nobody.
    • Aug 13, 2015
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

August

S M T W T F S
  1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31  

Most Viewed

  • Fayetteville ordinance: the good vs. the perfect

    A few weeks back a fundraising invitation arrived from "For Fayetteville," the ballot group supporting an antidiscrimination ordinance to be considered by the city's voters on Sept. 8. After several days of pondering, I ultimately decided to drop by the back room of Doe's in Little Rock with a small check. The reason for the hesitation: The ordinance has real flaws in terms of the breadth of its religious exemptions.
  • Brantley: South toward home

    A two-week cruise from Vancouver to Alaska was nicely timed for the August heat wave. It dipped into the 40s during my visit to the Hubbard Glacier, loudly "calving" with mighty booms of cracking ice. Here's a brief politically tinged travelogue.
  • New York Times fails again

    If one were of a low and suspicious nature regarding the New York Times' historically inept Washington Bureau, one might suspect yet another example of the "Clinton Rules" — that is, a shaky allegation unsupported by facts.
  • Asa Hutchinson: trying to please

    Mike Beebe is celebrated for the finesse with which he governed Arkansas with a legislature that for two years was effectively controlled by the other party and for his last two years with Republican numerical control as well. So what will they say about Asa Hutchinson, who must govern with his party owning lopsided majorities in both legislative houses?

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: New York Times fails again

    • Somehow I have the feeling it's not going to stop due to fact that bad…

    • on August 27, 2015
  • Re: Treat, don't jail, the mentally ill

    • Here is part of our state's (Missouri) solution, in combination with CIT training: http://www.mocoalition.org/#!community-mental-health-liasion/cvzg I…

    • on August 27, 2015
  • Re: Treat, don't jail, the mentally ill

    • Here is part of our state's (Missouri's) solution to this issue, in combination with CIT…

    • on August 27, 2015
 

© 2015 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation