UAMS, St. Vincent collaboration 

Devil's in the details, bishop says.

click to enlarge BISHOP TAYLOR: No affiliation that "implicates" St. Vincent cooperates with the "immoral" practices of UAMS.
  • BISHOP TAYLOR: No affiliation that "implicates" St. Vincent cooperates with the "immoral" practices of UAMS.

Bishop Anthony Taylor of the Catholic Diocese of Arkansas, commenting on the proposed affiliation between St. Vincent Health System and the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, left the door open to the idea, saying that cooperation "that does not violate the ERDs [Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care] or otherwise undermine the Catholic identity" of St. Vincent "could be acceptable."

A draft term sheet of how the affiliation could work was released last week at the meeting of the University of Arkansas Board of Trustees. That draft, prepared by Hogan Lovells law firm, said that large hospitals such as UAMS and SVHS must "perform their special roles as part of larger networks." The model envisions a "network collaboration" that would not only consolidate some of the hospitals' services, like heart and cancer care, but would establish affiliations with hospitals across Arkansas "to achieve a level of financial alignment and clinical integration such that they will be able lawfully to jointly contract with payers for certain services." The term sheet envisions a third entity overseen by a council, half from UAMS and half from SVHS.

After the release of the term sheet, activist Jo Ann Coleman e-mailed the Diocese asking for the bishop's reaction to a "blended Little Rock institution, jointly governed, that included a public affiliate offering services to patients or employees which the church does not approve — birth control pills, abortion, in vitro fertilization, patient directives on end of life decisions, tubal ligations, vasectomies, morning after pill dispensation to rape victims in emergency rooms, abortion training at UAMS and more." The bishop responded to Coleman personally, writing that "I will not allow any affiliation that implicates St. Vincent in any jointly governed institution that would result in our material cooperation with any of the immoral medical practices you describe."

While UAMS and SVHS have repeatedly stated that their affiliation would not affect UAMS' ability to offer such services as outlined in Coleman's letter, the term sheet says the Network Collaboration "will provide world-class care to communities throughout Arkansas, and do so in a manner that is accessible, responsive, and respectful of the dignity of the individual human being." Since the church defines human being as the embryo, the language suggests that St. Vincent might require affiliated hospitals outside Little Rock to abide by its Ethical Directives.

After being provided the bishop's correspondence with Coleman, the Times asked Taylor if his response to Coleman meant that he would "disapprove of a cooperative venture with UAMS even if it offered such enumerated services independently and outside of the collaborative network proposed this week in draft form for the two institutions?"

To the Times, Taylor wrote that "I do not automatically oppose as a matter of principle every conceivable model of affiliation between Catholic and secular hospitals," but that he would oppose an affiliation that would "implicate" St. Vincent in violations of the Catholic Directives and undermine the Catholic identity of St. Vincent. Taylor added that the " 'devil' (so to speak) is always in the details.' "

Among the details to be worked out would be whether a patient seen in a clinic operated under the "network" could be referred to UAMS over SVHS' objections for a service the Catholic church considers "immoral." If so, would the referral constitute "material cooperation"? If not, would the patient be denied a legal service previously available at UAMS?

In an affiliated heart clinic, for example, what happens to the pregnant woman who, unless she terminates her pregnancy, could suffer heart damage or even death? If the cancer clinics affiliate, what would happen to the cancer patient who wishes not to be kept alive artificially?

The Times was unable to reach St. Vincent CEO Peter Banko for comment. Banko told the Times a couple of weeks ago that he believed he and the bishop had a good relationship and could "work through anything together." To not find a way to grow the hospital, Banko said, would "diminish the Catholic ministry" of St Vincent.

Margaret Preston, spokeswoman for St. Vincent, did respond, saying in an email that "Since the beginning of our discussions with UAMS in August 2012, we have been clear that we will not enter into any affiliation model that impacts our Catholic identity or UAMS' identity as a public, academic institution. That has not changed and will not change. As a Catholic ministry, we work closely with Bishop Anthony Taylor, the Catholic Diocese of Little Rock, and other Church leaders on all aspects of our strategic development. We require that at least one representative of the Church is a member of all of our governing bodies (fiduciary and advisory). We received a first draft of a proposed affiliation model from UAMS yesterday and will be actively negotiating with UAMS over the next month or two. We will be simultaneously engaging Bishop Taylor, the Diocese, and other Church leaders in our review and approval of potential models. Again, St. Vincent Health System will engage in no activities that compromise our Catholic identity."

Speaking of...

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Leslie Newell Peacock

  • The Quapaw return to Arkansas

    Casino try a good bet.
    • Nov 20, 2014
  • Thollem Electric comes to White Water

    Also, Knox Hamilton at Juanita's, John Kilzer at South on Main, Third Friday Argenta Artwalk, The Idle Class release party at Vino's, Arkansas Arts Center museum sale at Clear Channel Metroplex, Big Piph at Ron Robinson and Chase Bryant at Revolution.
    • Nov 20, 2014
  • More »

Most Shared

  • The Quapaw return to Arkansas

    Casino try a good bet.
  • Jean Gordon to receive Truth Teller award

    Jean Gordon, who's worked a half-century in just about every social justice and peace movement you can name, will receive the Arkansas Community Institute's 2014 Community Truth Teller Award at a program at 5:30 p.m. Thursday at the library's Darragh Center
  • The French Hill 'tis better to receive-than-give open line

    An open line that features new Congressman French HIll's antipathy in the Catholic newspaper to Obamacare as a "giveaway" to drug companies and hospitals. A Catholic nurse points out that children and other people in need are the real beneficiaries of this giveaway, along with Catholic hospitals.
  • Fan happiness over Hogs' win over LSU costs UA $25,000 UPDATED

    The University of Arkansas will be fined $25,000 by the SEC because Hog fans stormed the football field after Saturday's victory over LSU snapped a long SEC losing streak. It was a second offense by the UA of the conference's "access to competition area" policy.
  • GOP's new Obamacare attack

    It was inevitable. The long crusade against the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act has pivoted from a battle against socialism to a populist war against big business: The program known as Obamacare is now supposed to be merely a feed trough for the captains of industry, not a government program to force health care on the undeserving poor.

Latest in Arkansas Reporter

Event Calendar

« »

November

S M T W T F S
  1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30  

Most Viewed

  • Homicide Diary: blood and asphalt

    More voices from the streets of Little Rock. The latest in our series.
  • The Quapaw return to Arkansas

    Casino try a good bet.
  • For the least of these

    French Hill and the pope, the killing of a mountain lion, the inequality of Arkansas, preschool v. prisons, senator fighting for inequality threatens University of Arkansas funding and the return of the Huck.
  • Clinton's foreign policy legacy

    Left to right, moderator James Bennet of The Atlantic; Sandy Berger, the former national security advisor; retired Gen. Wesley Clark, the former NATO commander; Ambassador Nancy Soderberg; Mara Rudman, former chief of staff of the National Security Council, and Robert Strong, a professor at Washington and Lee University.
  • The future of Social Security

    I've heard many people lament that Social Security won't be around by the time they need it. Social Security is quite sound and is well run. It has to be tweaked from time to time to keep it that way, and that's where the voters come in.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: The Quapaw return to Arkansas

    • I'm the oldest son of the oldest son of the oldest son of the oldest…

    • on November 20, 2014
  • Re: The Quapaw return to Arkansas

    • That's what we need...another casino. Look how Tunica is tanking. I hope this doesn't happen.

    • on November 19, 2014
 

© 2014 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation