Slopping the hogs
Before I give you an excerpt from a Wall Street Journal article, I should probably say 1) there were undoubtedly plenty of Arkansas legislators at the conference mentioned; 2) you can bet Arkansas lobbyists were on hand; 3) Arkansas is so far NOT among the 37 states considering ethics reform; 4) neither of the major candidates for governor favor lobby reform, the Republican having recently been a lobbyist and special interest bonanza beneficiary and the Democrat having long been the corporate lobby's best friend in the legislature, 5) and, yes, you can wine and dine Arkansas lawmakers in ways that the favors don't turn up on ethics reports and the swilling DOES influence votes. Now our excerpt:
NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- In Kentucky, lobbyists can't spend more than $100 a year on any state legislator. Lawmakers must disclose the smallest courtesy, effectively killing the practice of politicians dining on a lobbyist's tab.
"No cup of coffee unless you want to read about it in the newspaper," said Senate President David Williams, who has served in the legislature for 22 years. "I could accept a meal if I were so inclined -- I'm just not so inclined."
Nearly 200 miles from home, Mr. Williams takes the stage at a resort here, looking over a crowd of Kentucky lobbyists and legislators jamming the bar and buffet tables, sponsored by some 90 companies and business groups paying $250 apiece.
The Bluegrass Social -- part of last week's National Conference of State Legislators -- doesn't violate ethics rules because it is open to every member of the legislature, and doesn't benefit one lawmaker over another. As states throughout the country tighten such rules, the annual conference for legislators from all 50 states as well as events staged by similar groups seem to have taken on importance for lobbyists as places to ply their trade.
About 1,000 state legislators, joined by 5,000 aides, lobbyists and others descended on the Gaylord Opryland resort in Nashville for five days of seminars on governing issues such as tax policy and health care, pet evacuations during natural disasters -- and ethics overhaul. In their wake was a diverse group of lobbyists, touting causes such as the benefits of asphalt pavement and the proposed storage of nuclear waste in Nevada's Yucca Mountain range.
Spurred both by Washington scandals and corruption allegations in state capitals, 37 states this year have passed or are considering ethics reform. Kentucky's rules came during the 1990s, after the "Boptrot" influence-peddling scandal led to the conviction of a dozen lawmakers and lobbyists. This year, Florida joined the list of states with "no cup of coffee" rules, which bar legislators from accepting free meals, drinks or tickets to sports events, and requiring full disclosure of any gifts from lobbyists.
"The whole relationship between lawmakers and lobbyists is much more distant now," said Tennessee State Sen. Jim Kyle, the Democratic minority leader who helped to draw up new ethics rules this year. "There's far less socializing and far more email."



Comments
No good place to put this. Just read where Joe Rosenthal died at age 94.
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/object/article?f=/c/a/2006/08/21/MNROSENTHAL.DTL&o=1
Posted by: Cato | August 21, 2006 08:52 AM
No good place to put this. Just read where Joe Rosenthal died at age 94.
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/object/article?f=/c/a/2006/08/21/MNROSENTHAL.DTL&o=1
Posted by: Cato | August 21, 2006 08:52 AM
The whole relationship between lawmakers and lobbyists is much more distant now,"
Ya, sure, take a look at the financial disclosure reports for our esteemed Ledge and those running. No glaring lack of lobbyist contributions there.
Posted by: Anonymous | August 21, 2006 09:01 AM
I noticed that you never had an item on the Dem/Gaz article a few weeks ago about Sen. Jeffress and others driving long distances rather than fly to milk the mileage per diem (and of course take their wives on the state's penny).
Posted by: Anonymous | August 21, 2006 09:15 AM
Lobbyist are killing our country, inflicting far more damage than Osama every day. The whole system is a hold-over from the Reconstruction era after the Civil War. Our country did not start with lobbyists, but it sure could end because of them. They are the cancer of politics. They service the rich at the expense of everyone else.
A few laws like those mentioned in this article is a good way to start the task of ridding the country of every last lobbyist. If our leaders are so stupid they have to have a lobbyist to tell them what to do, they're too stupid to be in office. It's a political 3 card Monte game that should be put out of business.
It is to our shame that Arkansas is not on the list of states working towards reform. Another clue Arkansas is just one big plantation and Massa is keeping us down. We can't expect those who are already enjoying the lobbyist 30 pieces of silver to reform themselves. We need a strong candidate who will pledge to start lobby reform in Arkansas now.
If elected, we'll need a longer memory to hold him or her to their promise. The foxes have been in the hen house for nearly 150 years. It's going to take some powerful medicine to run them off.
Posted by: Deathbyinches | August 21, 2006 09:20 AM
It's that darn constitution. You know the part about free association and free speech. Petitioning your representative and all that. I wish we could ban money from the political process altogether but alas it is not to be. I would hope that lobby laws are constitutional but I have my doubts.
ARK. BLOGOther states have outlawed gifts and meals for lawmakers. The inability to purchase a lawmaker a martini doesn't inhibit your ability to speak to him/her. (Or does it?)
Posted by: FortSmithBoy | August 21, 2006 10:43 AM
The truth is that Arkansas' political theater, lobbyists factor in only in the most marginal sense.
With the strictest term limits in the nation, Arkansas legislators have little incentive to playcate lobbyists to finance a future campaign that can't legally happen. I've seen more than one occasion where a legislator received a contribution from an interest group even after he voted against them on a crucial issue as they try to woo him again. An explosion of lobbyists in the past few years have likewise ensured that they are being wooed by more voices and so do not build the kind of loyalty that existed ten years ago.
Anyone that has spent time around the rotunda the past few sessions will echo the sentiment. Lobbyists don't factor in on the local level as they do nationally.
Posted by: Basil | August 21, 2006 10:48 AM
And not to advocate too much for the devil but..
"A few laws like those mentioned in this article is a good way to start the task of ridding the country of every last lobbyist. If our leaders are so stupid they have to have a lobbyist to tell them what to do, they're too stupid to be in office."
The ACLU, Common Cause, ACORN, the American Heart Association, NAACP and NOW all have lobbyists.
Also represented by lobbyists: heart disease, liver disease, kidney disease, electrical engineers, locamotive engineers, the little engine that could...
Like it or not, lobbyists play a huge role in educating legislators on issues and that will NEVER change. All legislators depend on advocates of issues to provide SOME information on the thousands of votes they cast every session. Every member of our state legislature and state delegation included.
THAT my friend is the most dangerous thing about lobbyists in AR. It's not the meals they buy at NU or Does or Faded Rose. It's the fact that our severly term limited legislature so lacks that institutional memory that they are forced to depend on lobbyists for info on everything from seat belts to schools to railroad crossings.
Posted by: Basil | August 21, 2006 11:01 AM
I can safely say at least one Arkansas lobbyist was there.
Posted by: Crash Davis | August 21, 2006 11:07 AM
OH!!! I forgot the largest lobby in the country...
"AARP says it will be hitting the road in Arkansas this election season, taking a message by van around the state on some issues important to its membership (and others.) Key issues: 1) reform of long-term care; 2) protecting people who live in nursing homes; 3) (here's one for everybody) protecting consumers from the sharks known as payday lenders."
Posted by: Yes, its Basil again | August 21, 2006 11:20 AM
Lobbyists write the laws; the foxes ate the hens long ago. Term limits just reinforce the strength of lobbyists and weaken legislative competence. A strong executive branch could become downright dictatorial if so inclined. Who would be there to watch out for those who do not wield power and money?
Posted by: bodybybush | August 21, 2006 11:57 AM
Now wait Basil....are you saying the people we elect are too stupid to do their jobs unless a lobbyist tells them what to do on a daily basis? Wouldn't we be better off electing the lobbyist and cutting out the middle man?
When I say ban lobbyist, I'm mostly talking about banning the money, the trips, the gifts. I don't know of an American way to ban adults from talking to each other. Let lobbyist knock on the doors during regular business hours like all the rest of us. Take their name and purpose and write it in the book of life for all to see.
If a legislator is out having a late dinner, it better be his wife or his mistress and not some cigar chomping lobbyist from AP & L or the West Memphis dog track.
When I had a business, at times I'd ask advice. Most of the time I got way too much unsolicited advice from winos on up. But best I can remember I didn't slip money or gifts to the people I got advice from, nor did anyone give me a gold door knocker when I helped them out of a bind. So...why must our term-limited whores in government be such magnets for gifts and money?
I think about 99.99% of us got up this morning, did our jobs and all we got was a paycheck. How are our jobs any different than Representative Sammy "Red" Butts?
All the business of governing is boring, but very little of it is rocket science. Paron school isn't hard to figure out, it's just tossing that political football around in an election year that makes it so hard.
Posted by: Deathbyinches
|
August 21, 2006 05:35 PM