Snyder, Lincoln push benefits for Guard, Reservists
U.S. Rep. Vic Snyder gets attention from a prominent military affairs columnist for urging defense officials during a contentious congressional hearing to increase benefits for National Guard and Reserve soldiers under the Montgomery G.I. Bill (MGIB). U.S. Sen. Blanche Lincoln also is cited for her role in sponsoring an amendment to enhance MGIB benefits for reservists that the Bush administration is opposing.
When active duty members leave service, they take along MGIB benefits. Reserve benefits can only be used while they remain in drill status.
“How is it fair when two members serve side by side in combat, they return home together, both leave the service, but one will have education benefits [and] the other will not have any?" asked Snyder. “This seems to me to be unconscionable.” ...
It’s also true, Snyder said, that the Bush administration has not asked for money to adjust Reserve MGIB. On Oct. 1, when active duty benefits go up once again, Reserve MGIB benefits will stay frozen and their value, relative to active duty MGIB, will fall to 27 percent.
“Shouldn’t we at least bring that benefit up to where it was at the time the program was [established],” Snyder asked Michael L. Dominguez, principal deputy under secretary of defense for personnel and readiness. ...
“If we look at our recruiting and retention numbers, we’re achieving the purposes for which the program was intended,” said Dominguez, a 1975 West Point graduate. For five years, until last July, he served as assistant secretary of the Air Force for manpower and reserve affairs.
Following that logic, an angry Snyder told Dominguez, if the Reserve MGIB “deteriorates to three percent of the [active duty] benefit…or one percent, you’re going to be perfectly satisfied as long as Americans are stepping forward and signing enlistment contracts for reasons for patriotism, family heritage, for love of country. You don’t care where that benefit deteriorates to…I think you stepped in it, Mr. Secretary.” ...
The Senate, in its version of the 2007 defense authorization bill, adopted an amendment from Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-Ark.) that would give Reserve MGIB benefits the same portability as active duty MGIB, a 10-year window to use benefits after separation. The House bill was silent on the issue. Odds were seen as slim the Lincoln provision would survive a House-Senate conference committee ironing out differences between the two bills.
The Bush administration, in opposing the Lincoln provision, also pointed to projected costs of $1.5 billion over 10 years and urged a delay on any changes to benefits until a joint VA-Department of Defense task force completes a comprehensive review of MGIB issues.








Comments
Something tells me the Snyder-bashers will be conspicously absent from this thread.
I'm sure Mayberry would be battling the Bush administration over vet benefits {rolls eyes}
Posted by: Roland
|
September 29, 2006 04:58 PM
I have to admit I do not know much about military vs. reservist pay or benefits. I guess I assumed that if you are serving your country in a dangerous place one would get the same benefits as everyone else.
Does someone who is in the reserve and serving in Iraq get paid the same as active duty military? Do they get housing allowances and such for thier families? Does their family get the same type of benefits if they are killed while serving?
Posted by: Any*Mouse
|
September 29, 2006 06:13 PM
Dman! They spent beau coup millions of dollars for bribes to people in Iraq and can't afford an education packet for our loyal troops......what a bunch of horse fertilizer.
What sort of message does this send our troops? Bush and company are crookeder than the Pig Trail.
Posted by: Jake da Snake
|
September 29, 2006 06:23 PM
It's a shame that one thing that popped into my mind on this topic is that increased benefits to those who serve creates more incentive for folks to join and help fill the depleted ranks. They deserve it, but I hate to see it, in any way, result in more people signing up to go over there in the first place.
Posted by: Spirit
|
September 29, 2006 06:34 PM
Any*mouse....to answer your questions:
My son was a captain in the Arkansas National Guard (I never got above the rank of E-5) and he has been in 9 foreign countries. He was the company commander of the unit when they were sent to Kuwait a few years ago to guard Patriot Missile sites from possible Iraqi attack. He got out a couple of months before his unit was called up again to be sent to Iraq, where one was killed and several wounded, some very severe.
The point is, he told me they are under the same pay, benefits, etc., as the Regular Army. If they have active duty for 180 days in a calendar year they are covered medically by the V.A. (I only had 29 federal duty days in the LR Central activation so I am not covered).
The one big difference is in retirement. Regular Army can retire after X number of years and start immediately drawing a military retirement check. The NG has to wait until they are 60. My son had his 20 years in at age 40, with two or three federal duty stints, but has to wait 20 years until he turns 60 to draw retirement benefits.
Hope that clears it up for you.
Posted by: Rasputin
|
September 29, 2006 09:01 PM
Apparently this is the part of "support our troops" the Bushists do not want to understand. More and more, we are hearing about the soldiers returning home to find their jobs gone and having to go through the long hassle of filing a complaint under the Soldiers and Sailors Act. Also, the closing of many VA medical facilities, leaves wounded vets with longer distances to travel for care.
Any veterans group he appears before should boo him out of the hall.
Posted by: Jim Lendall
|
September 29, 2006 10:14 PM
Cato,
Were you in the halls of LR Central during your activation?
Posted by: rosso
|
September 29, 2006 11:46 PM
No. I had just started my freshman year at the UofA and my unit did not send any students to LR. We had to drill every night, attached to the Fayetteville unit. We were bussed to Fort Chaffee for physicals (remember, Fort Chaffee was an active base back then).
We did this for 29 days, I almost flunked out of school but I took my pay for those 29 days and bought a tv at Montgomery Ward. B/W, since there was no color back then. Got to watch Paladin, Mr. Diamond, Matt and Chester, Jackie Gleason, The Twentieth Century and Walter Cronkite.
Posted by: Rasputin
|
September 30, 2006 08:30 AM