Arkansas Times

Arkansas Blog

« Vote suppression update | Main | Murder suspect arrested »

Again: Ledge v. Game and Fish

OK. I KNOW this a.g. opinion request stems from Game and Fish protectiveness of its gas riches. Here, Sen. Steve Farris asks a pointed question: What is it about the messy business of oil and gas drilling that is in harmony with the agency's fiercely defended constitutional autonomy to protect wildlife? And does a gas company lease of public land for private use make it taxable?

Answer: Good questions. More development of the issues will be required. I think we can expect some development come January.

QUESTION: Is the use of Arkansas Game and Fish Commission land for the drilling of gas wells on that  land consistent with its mandate under Amendment 35 to manage, restore, conserve, and regulate the birds, fish, game and wildlife resources of the State?  Q2) Does public property  retain its tax exemption under art. 16, sec. 5(b) of the Arkansas Constitution if the state agency or commission that owns the land uses the property for a state purpose as well as to generate a profit for itself by leasing the land to a non-public entity?  Q3) Is land that is leased from a state agency to a commercial enterprise subject to property tax under art. 16, sec. 5(a) of the Arkansas Constitution?  Q4) Is the language of A.C.A. 26-3-301(4) that exempts all state property, whether real or personal, consistent with art. 16, sec. 5(b) that exempts public property only if it is used exclusively for public purposes?  Q5) While the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission holds title to various parcels of real property, do the people of the State of Arkansas retain the beneficial interest in the real property with the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission holding the property in trust for the people? 

 RESPONSE:  Q1)  It is impossible to answer this question definitively without full development of the facts and circumstances surrounding this particular use of Commission land.  See Opinion for general discussion.  Q2 &3)  These questions require factual determinations by the assessor. See  A.C.A. 26-27-317 and 26-27-318.  Generally, the assessor will not consider any individual parcel of land leased to a private entity to be tax-exempt.   The question of whether an entire larger tract, containing some parcels which are leased and others which are devoted to public use, will lose its tax emption under Ark. Const. article 16, section 5 due to the presence of the leased parcels will depend upon the predominant or primary use of that larger tract.  Q4)  A court would read this statute in light of the constitution, as also requiring an exclusive public use. Q5)  The court has identified the Commission as "trustee for the people."  Farris v. Ark. State Game & Fish Comm'n, 228 Ark. 776, 782, 310 S.W.2d 231 (1958).  But the term "beneficial interest" would not appear to applyin the context of Amendment 35.

 

Comments

If a parent has a responsibility to raise and nurture a child... but later decides to profit from selling out that child's body.. the state would need to step in for a whole lot of reasons... especially since the land and water/child are all of ours.

If AGFC is going to act like this.. then their status/ability to foster public lands should be seriously reconsidered.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Life and death
Date: 11/19/2009
By: David Koon

Not many were shocked when Curtis Lavelle Vance was found guilty last week of capital murder, rape, residential burglary and theft of property in the October 2008 beating death of KATV anchor Anne Pressly. /more/

Xmas access nixed
Date: 11/19/2009
By: Arkansas Times Staff

Two weeks ago we reported on the efforts of the Arkansas Society of Freethinkers to put up a winter solstice display on the grounds of the state Capitol. /more/


Charter school wisdom
Date: 11/19/2009
By: Arkansas Times Staff

The state Board of Education last week demonstrated a more searching approach to charter school applications than it has sometimes shown. /more/

Home / Blogs / This Week / Entertainment / Real Estate / Classifieds / Subscribe / Contact