Let the sun shine in | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Let the sun shine in

Posted By on Thu, Jul 17, 2008 at 9:59 AM

Alerted by The Iconoclast, I wrote an item recently about a civil case put under total blackout in Benton County. It involved some prominent people and a corporate dispute, I was led to understand. The circuit clerk could not even tell me the names of the parties in the case. I was particularly curious because of a sealed proceeding that concerned an allegation that sealed information in the case had been leaked to the Northwest Arkansas Business Journal. Those events apparently were at the center of a closed contempt-of-court proceeding.

I stewed about it a while and did some asking around. I was told by one attorney  that the case had been filed in the open. When I found, however, that the initial pleading was not available to the public, I drafted a motion objecting to total closure of the record.

Circuit Judge Xollie Duncan responded promptly. She said she would review the case file and talk with lawyers about whether portions of the file could be opened.

The judge entered an order in the case yesterday afternoon in response to my motion. She has modified her closure order. She said "certain matters contained within the complaints and the exhibits to the complaints are proprietary and confidential information which should be sealed herein. All other items within the file are to be open for public inspection."

The judge ordered parties to provide redacted copies of the original and subsequent complaints that will then be open to the public. Original documents will remain under seal.

I look forward to seeing the material. I now know the case number -- CV-2007-1972-5. Plaintiffs are the Laura Duke Revocable Trust, Robert B. Thornton, Bill Schwyhart, Richard M. Dunleavy, Michael Dunleavy and James Phillips. Defendants are Robert Lee Thompson Sr., Robert Lee Thompson Jr. and Vision Technologies Inc. This report is related to the dispute.

Generally, I think, many courts in Arkansas have been too quick to close judicial proceedings on motion of the parties. Why not? Generally, there's nobody from the public around to object. Courts clearly have the power to protect proprietary information, though I've seen cases where the sensitivity of certain data has been exaggerated. Fact is, people naturally like to keep their business and private lives private. But, as the Supreme Court has said any number of times, if people want to use the public's courts to decide their grievances, transparency is a necessity for accountability. For example: Who prevailed on the contempt of court motion in this case? These are the sorts of records by which the public may measure the quality of justice in a court.

Thanks to Judge Duncan for giving reasoned consideration to the motion.

From the ArkTimes store



Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Turkeys rescued in Yellville enjoy their Thanksgiving

    Farm Sanctuary, an animal protection organization, sends word that four turkeys rescued from the Yellville Turkey Trot after the annual drops from buildings and an airplane will enjoy Thanksgiving in friendlier places
    • Nov 23, 2017
  • The New Orleans charter school 'miracle'? It's a ruse

    The New Orleans Tribune has a devastating piece of editorial commentary, based on local reporting and test scores, that lays bare the depiction of the charterization of New Orleans public schools 12 years ago as a miracle of the "reform" movement.
    • Nov 23, 2017
  • More criticism of UA proposal to change tenure policy

    Reason is among the latest to offer critical commentary of a proposal from University of Arkansas System lawyers to change the tenure policy so that a lack of collegiality could be used as a justification for firing a tenured professor.
    • Nov 23, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Kenneth Starr: A comment from Betsey Wright

    Betsey Wright, former President Bill Clinton's chief of staff when he was Arkansas governor, responds bitterly to a New York Times article today quoting Whitewater Prosecutor Kenneth Starr's warm words about Clinton. She can't forget the lives Starr ruined in Arkansas.
    • May 24, 2016
  • Civil War over in Fort Smith; lawyer strikes his Rebel mascot battle tent

    KSFM reports that Joey McCutchen, the lawyer who's been trying to restart the Civil War in Fort Smith over the School Board's decision to drop the Rebel mascot and related trappingsfor Southside High School, is dropping his School Board takeover campaign.
    • May 27, 2016
  • 'Million-Dollar Thursday': A visit to Sherwood's hot check court

    We take a visit to the weekly hot check court in Sherwood District Court, the subject of a recent civil rights lawsuit filed by ACLU Arkansas and others, who say the system there results in a modern-day debtor's prison
    • Aug 25, 2016

Most Recent Comments



© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation