In review: Charter school mythbusting | Arkansas Blog

Sunday, August 21, 2011

In review: Charter school mythbusting

Posted By on Sun, Aug 21, 2011 at 7:36 AM

brillbook.jpg
Today's reading assignment for those interested in education reform and the Billionaire Boys Club drive to charterize public education (and destroy teacher unions in the few places they exist):

It's a New York Times review of Steven Brill's new book "Class Warfare," an anti-union, pro-charter school effort. The interesting thing is the review, by Sara Mosle, a Teach for America alumna and now a teacher in a reform academy. She brings a balanced view to the subject and in the process points out some of the things that Brill overlooks in singing charter school praises and condemning unions. Like:

* Even a study funded by the pro-charter Waltons found no significant general advantage to charter schools over conventional public schools.

* Successful charter schools (think KIPP) though undoubtedly worth studying and emulating, are just about impossible to replicate on a broad scale and enjoy built-in advantages of relatively better qualified students and more motivated parents. Not to mention the ability to dismiss families who don't meet standards.

* There's no objective showing of the presumed ills of teachers unions. Many good districts have them; many bad ones don't. Union evil is merely an article of faith to the billionaires, who otherwise insist on the empirical perfection of test scores and other "objective" measures of teachers (a subject on which the reviewer also has some comments).

Brill cites policy advocates who argue that students who have top quartile teachers several years in a row could (at least theoretically) make remarkable gains. Absent other proven criteria for determining the most effective teachers, these reformers conclude that schools should base hiring, firing and promotion decisions, at least in substantial part, on teachers’ ability to generate year-to-year gains on their students’ test scores.

Brill, however, glosses over an important qualifier to such research. Teacher quality may be the most important variable within schools, but mountains of data, going back decades, demonstrates that most of the variation in student performance is explained by nonschool factors: not just poverty, but also parental literacy (and whether parents read to their children), student health, frequent relocations, crime-­related stress and the like.

* The review notes that even Geoffrey Canada, featured in the charterites' cinema Bible, "Waiting for Superman," and a recent visitor to Little Rock, says KIPP alone isn't the answer.

Canada decries KIPP’s approach as a kind of reverse “quarantine, walling off the most promising kids from a sick neighborhood’s contagion,” in Tough’s paraphrase. In fact, though Brill and the filmmakers never acknowledge it, Canada’s philosophy is actually diametrically opposed to KIPP’s. Canada insists such charters can’t succeed, at least not with all inner-city children, including those who may be disaffected from school, without substantially increased investments in wraparound social services, which Canada’s Harlem Children’s Zone provides.

Check it out, Luke.

My hero Diane Ravitch (prolific Twitterer) has been busting Brill's chops for days. Her turn against "reform" sent him into a rage of ad hominem attacks on Ravitch. Best he's come up with is that she's taken some speaking fees from teacher's unions (and reform groups, too). He'd find nothing amiss at all, I'm sure, in the Waltons' underwriting of the work of the pro-charter, anti-union "reform" professors up at the UA-Walton Campus in Fayetteville. They're objective because they agree with him.

Tags: , , , , , , ,


Favorite

Comments (11)

Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Sarah Sanders' bad day on the race beat

    Sarah Huckabee Sanders was nailed again yesterday for peddling baloney in a White House press briefing. For once, she acknowledged it, grudgingly and with more spin. But that wasn't all for her on the racially fraught Trump front.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • George McGill wins Fort Smith mayor's race

    Democratic State Rep. George McGill handily won election Tuesday night as mayor of Fort Smith.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • Governor responds to Medicaid work rule lawsuit

    Gov. Asa Hutchinson has responded sharply to the lawsuit challenging the legality of the state's new work requirement for Medicaid coverage and also criticizing the online-only reporting requirement. His statement:
    • Aug 14, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Women's March planned in Arkansas to mark Trump inauguration

    Speaking of Donald Trump and in answer to a reader's question: There will be a women's march in Arkansas on Jan. 21, the day after inauguration, as well as the national march planned in Washington.
    • Dec 30, 2016
  • Trump tariffs hit farmers hard

    Well, the trade war has begun and the early returns for farmers are not good — sharp reductions in the prices for soybeans and corn. You may have heard that Arkansas, which overwhelmingly supported Donald Trump, has some agricultural interests, particularly in soybeans.
    • Jul 6, 2018
  • Campus gun bill clears committee

    The so-called compromise amendment that will allow anyone 25 or older with a training certificate carry a concealed weapon on public college campuses was approved in a Senate committee this afternoon.
    • Feb 21, 2017

Most Viewed

  • Who knew? George Soros has targeted Arkansas!

    Attorney General Leslie Rutledge regularly bends the truth to suit her narrative of the day, but she gets extra credit for dragging George Soros into her re-election campaign.
  • Sarah Sanders' bad day on the race beat

    Sarah Huckabee Sanders was nailed again yesterday for peddling baloney in a White House press briefing. For once, she acknowledged it, grudgingly and with more spin. But that wasn't all for her on the racially fraught Trump front.
  • George McGill wins Fort Smith mayor's race

    Democratic State Rep. George McGill handily won election Tuesday night as mayor of Fort Smith.
  • Governor responds to Medicaid work rule lawsuit

    Gov. Asa Hutchinson has responded sharply to the lawsuit challenging the legality of the state's new work requirement for Medicaid coverage and also criticizing the online-only reporting requirement. His statement:

Most Recent Comments

Slideshows

 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation