Duh — Rapert bill is unconstitutional | Arkansas Blog

Monday, February 4, 2013

Duh — Rapert bill is unconstitutional

Posted By on Mon, Feb 4, 2013 at 12:37 PM

Gov. Mike Beebe's preliminary assessment is that Sen. Jason Rapert's bill to ban most abortions (after first jamming a probe up an unwilling woman's vagina) is unconstitutional.

Duh.

This didn't require a room full of Learned Hands to reach such a conclusion. Rapert would make it a crime to provide an abortion to a woman after a fetal hearbeat had been detected, as early as 5.5 weeks.

In 1973, Roe V. Wade barred states from prohibiting abortion before viability of the fetus, then about 28 weeks. Then you had the 1993 ruling in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which reaffirmed Roe as to, among others,

"a recognition of a woman's right to choose to have an abortion before fetal viability and to obtain it without undue interference from the State, whose previability interests are not strong enough to support an abortion prohibition or the imposition of substantial obstacles to the woman's effective right to elect the procedure;"

This 20-year-old ruling is undisturbed, too, by subsequent court rulings, in this language:

The Roe rule's limitation on state power could not be repudiated without serious inequity to people who, for two decades of economic and social developments, have organized intimate relationships and made choices that define their views of themselves and their places in society, in reliance on the availability of abortion in the event that contraception should fail. The ability of women to participate equally in the economic and social life of the Nation has been facilitated by their ability to control their reproductive lives. The Constitution serves human values, and while the effect of reliance on Roe cannot be exactly measured, neither can the certain costs of overruling Roe for people who have ordered their thinking and living around that case be dismissed.

Get it? States may not prohibit abortions pre-viability. They also may not impose "substantial obstacles" to that right. A prohibition, as Rapert proposes, fails for sure. Arguably, he fails, too, with his requirement of an unnecessary and unwanted probe of private parts. For Arkansas to try to do otherwise than what the law requires on abortion access would produce "serious inequity."

It is beyond shameful that a mere eight senators could be mustered to vote against this bill, which tramples the clear dictates of law. It is 1957 and interposition all over again, based on a demagogue's wish that abortion could be outlawed. Pass now, pay legal fees later.

ALSO: Gene Lyons suggests, rightly I think, that passage of Rapert's bill also could trigger wrongful death investigations of miscarriages. A miscarriage of a fetus older than six weeks would require the state to find out whether it was induced without required heatbeat test, wouldn't it?

Tags: , , ,

From the ArkTimes store

Favorite

Comments (31)

Showing 1-31 of 31

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-31 of 31

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • The assault weapon open line

    The open line. And report of the arrest of a man with an AR-15 who threatened to shoot people at a Springdale business.
    • Feb 17, 2018
  • A primary challenger for Rep. Laurie Rushing

    Blue Hog Report has some news on a Republican primary challenge of an incumbent legislator, Rep. Laurie Rushing, by Ernie Hinz of Hot Springs.
    • Feb 17, 2018
  • A common-sense gun measure draws no sponsors from Arkansas

    Republicans, including at least one from Arkansas, are talking about repealing the Dickey Amendment which prohibits gun research from a public health perspective. But none of them are yet willing to DO anything about it.
    • Feb 17, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • The long and winding road: No exception yet for 30 Crossing

    The Arkansas highway department's representative on the Metroplan board of directors told the board today that the department is requesting an exception to the planning agency's cap on six lanes for its 30 Crossing project to widen Interstate 30 from six to 10 (and more) lanes.
    • Jun 29, 2016
  • Arkansas Times Recommends: A Literary Edition

    Arkansas Times Recommends is a series in which Times staff members (or whoever happens to be around at the time) highlight things we've been enjoying this week.
    • Jul 1, 2016
  • Federal judge reprimands John Goodson for misconduct in class-action case

    John Goodson  — the Texarkana attorney, D.C. lobbyist, and husband of Arkansas State Supreme Court Justice Courtney Goodson — was reprimanded today by a federal judge for his conduct in a class-action case.
    • Aug 3, 2016

Most Shared

  • A mayor stands up against freeway widening. No. Not in Little Rock.

    Another booming city, Indianapolis, fights ever wider urban freeways. Meanwhile, back in Little Rock .....
  • In the margins

    A rediscovered violin concerto brings an oft-forgotten composer into the limelight.
  • Donald Trump is historically unpopular — and not necessarily where you think

    My colleagues John Ray and Jesse Bacon and I estimate, in the first analysis of its kind for the 2018 election season, that the president's waning popularity isn't limited to coastal cities and states. The erosion of his electoral coalition has spread to The Natural State, extending far beyond the college towns and urban centers that voted for Hillary Clinton in 2016. From El Dorado to Sherwood, Fayetteville to Hot Springs, the president's approval rating is waning.
  • Arkansans join House vote to gut Americans with Disabilities Act

    Despite fierce protests from disabled people, the U.S. House voted today, mostly on party lines, to make it harder to sue businesses for violating the Americans with Disabilities Act. Of course Arkansas congressmen were on the wrong side.

Most Viewed

  • The assault weapon open line

    The open line. And report of the arrest of a man with an AR-15 who threatened to shoot people at a Springdale business.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: The assault weapon open line

    • The War on the NRA is on! mag is behind me crying while listening to…

    • on February 17, 2018
  • Re: The assault weapon open line

    • Sorry, please ignore my post above, I had the wrong page in the "paste" position…

    • on February 17, 2018
  • Re: The assault weapon open line

    • Those kids give me hope to keep fighting the idiotic laws passed by the NRA…

    • on February 17, 2018
 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation