Judge Griffen objects to new prison; draws criticism for "dog bite" rule requiring prison time | Arkansas Blog

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Judge Griffen objects to new prison; draws criticism for "dog bite" rule requiring prison time

Posted By on Wed, Feb 12, 2014 at 6:57 AM

click to enlarge JUDE WENDELL GRIFFEN: Prisons too full (but not of violent offenders.).
  • JUDE WENDELL GRIFFEN: Prisons too full (but not of violent offenders.).
Circuit Judge Wendell Griffen just doesn't operate in the shadows.

Today he has distributed a letter to Gov. Mike Beebe objecting to plans to spend state money on new prison facilities.

He contends the War on Drugs has stacked prisons with non-violent offenders. Wrote Griffien:

Arkansas does not have a prison overcrowding problem because of a dramatic increase in violent offenders. We have a prison overcrowding problem because of the "War on Drugs."

It is foolish to believe that cancer, AIDS, and other life-threatening diseases will be reduced and cured by building mortuaries and cemeteries and hiring funeral directors and grave diggers. The January 23 decision of the Board of Corrections represents similar folly. That is why I urge you to stop the Board's plans and impose a moratorium on new prison construction in Arkansas.

Coincidentally, I received a copy of a court filing in which Judge Griffen is more or less indirectly accused of contributing to prison crowding by virtue of what he calls a "dog bite rule." According to the pleading, the judge rejects all plea bargains, typically with lesser sentences than conviction might bring, for a violent offense on which a felony charge was brought. In the case at issue, Griffen would insist on a prison sentence on conviction for someone prepared to take probation.

Deputy Public Defender Mac Carder, representing Mashieka Murphy, objected to Griffen's refusal to accept a plea bargain calling for a probationary sentence in a battery case.

He wrote:

The Court’s application of its “my dog bite rule” policy of not considering alternative sanctions - where they are either presumed or available - based only upon the title or category of the charged offense, violates the fundamental rights of Due Process of Law under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution of not only Defendant Murphy but of all defendants appearing before this Honorable Court who are subject to this Court’s stated policy ….

Carder argued it was an abuse of discretion for the judge to refuse a bargain without hearing any basis for it. Carder's request for Griffen to discontinue the "rigid and arbitrary" practice quotes concerns from the prosecutor's office.

MS. ABBOTT: Your Honor, just from the State's perspective, I think the State's concern on the Court's stance on the D felonies is that the creating of a black letter rule on this - and, as you know, in prosecuting these cases, we have to take them on a case-by-case basis with what the facts are and there is a wide range of things that can fall into the category of a D felony battery second.
And I think it might be a little bit, from the State's perspective, premature to say that on no - there is no battery second that will ever be a candidate for probation when what you're actually saying is that in every D felony battery second, you are going to put the defense in a perspective to where they know that, without hearing the facts of the case, without hearing the allegations, you are telling the defendants that you are always going to do an upward departure from the sentencing guidelines.

More to come on this, undoubtedly, as the request moves through the system. The dog bite rule, or "country dog bite rule," isn't explained as to origin in the pleading, but Carder said it apparently arose in rural Pike County.

Carder argues that Griffen should end his rule or disqualify from all cases in which he'd apply it because it infringes on fair trial rights for defendants. Because Griffen wouldn't withdraw, Carder withdrew the plea bargain request and asked for a jury trial.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Sign up for the Daily Update email

Comments (11)

Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Trump Tweets threat to Iran

    Donald Trump declared a Twitter war on Iran Sunday night. He's angry about the FISA warrant information, too, which didn't help his cause.
    • Jul 23, 2018
  • The Mondo Trumpe open line

    A world of the dogs? Check out Trump's latest poll ratings.
    • Jul 22, 2018
  • University pay ranking puts UA System chief at 57

    The Chronicle of Higher Education recently released its survey of pay of top public and private university leaders in 2016-17. Donald Bobbitt, president of the University of Arkansas System, checked in at No. 57 on the list of 251 public university leaders.
    • Jul 22, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Your daily dose of Jason Rapert

    Sen. Jason Rapert really, really didn't like it when a KATV reporter asked him about the hypocrisy of his political arguments.
    • Feb 4, 2017
  • The LR chamber does the public's business. Is it accountable? Blue Hog on the case.

    Matt Campbell, lawyer and Blue Hog Report blogger, has sent a Freedom of Information Act request to Jay Chessir, director of the Little Rock Regional Chamber of Commerce, and Mayor Mark Stodola related to the publicity stunt yesterday  built around withdrawing from the mayor's rash pronouncement that the city would seek an Amazon HQ2 project even though the city  didn't meet the company's criteria.
    • Oct 20, 2017
  • Campus gun bill clears committee

    The so-called compromise amendment that will allow anyone 25 or older with a training certificate carry a concealed weapon on public college campuses was approved in a Senate committee this afternoon.
    • Feb 21, 2017

Most Viewed

  • Corruption probe nets another guilty plea, implicates another senator

    Jerry Walsh, 72, who ran the now-defunct South Arkansas Youth Services, has pleaded guilty to paying $120,000 to an unnamed Arkansas state senator in return for action favorable to the agency, Walsh and others.He pleaded guilty today in federal court in El Dorado. The scheme altogether diverted $380,000 in public money.

Most Recent Comments



© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation