Monday, March 3, 2014
Religion Science bests religion in Texas textbook battle; decision trickles down to Arkansas
Posted By Max Brantley on Mon, Mar 3, 2014 at 10:15 AM
Texas Monthly reports that, after years of control by religionists, the Texas science textbook battle has been won by scientists. This is a development that has implications in Arkansas,
Texas, because it buys so many books, has had inordinate influence on content of textbooks nationwide, so this is a big deal. But as the article says, the creationists haven't given up the battle. And the Texas religionists have reached firmly into Arkansas. The article notes:
We've reported recently on Responsive Education, which has won licenses to own and operate four charter schools in Arkansas — Pine Bluff, Little Rock (2) and Bentonville — and to get paid to manage three more for public school districts in Fountain Lake, Pea Ridge and West Memphis. They were faulted in Slate not only for lack in biology, but also in history. And I reported recently that they won approval for the Quest Little Rock charter middle school represented to be located on Rahling Road in Chenal Valley while they were working on moving the site seven miles east without notice to the state Board of Education hearing their application.
Responsive Ed has taken steps after the Slate article to change its biology material and that new material has arrived, I was told by one of its teachers last week. Perhaps the new rules in Texas, where Responsive Ed gets public money to operate 60 schools, had more influence than the Slate article. Responsive Ed has defended its past teaching of creationism by saying it complied with Texas law.
Responsive Ed, with deep religious advocates among its leaders, is by no means alone in pushing a religious view of the origins of life. It crops up periodically in other public schools in Arkansas and many schools don't teach the subject at all, lest they rile people with talk of evolution.
The Texas Monthly article doesn't mention it, directly but the textbook author, Kenneth Miller, who teaches at Brown, is one of the country's leading evolution defenders. I encountered him while my son was a student there in this alumni magazine article about him. Recommended.
The final shot of the last battle of the Great Texas Textbook War has been fired. The clash did not end in a blaze of glory, exactly, more like a flurry of memos. Still, the occasion deserves to be marked. What happened was this: three experts, selected by the State Board of Education, struck down an attempt to insert doubt about evolution into a high school biology textbook, thereby preventing creationists from having any voice in how the origin of life is presented in its pages.
Science didn’t just win. It crushed.
Texas, because it buys so many books, has had inordinate influence on content of textbooks nationwide, so this is a big deal. But as the article says, the creationists haven't given up the battle. And the Texas religionists have reached firmly into Arkansas. The article notes:
Yet while the Great Texas Textbook War may be over, there are signs of new battles over evolution on other fronts. Slate recently reported that one of the state’s largest charter-school companies, Responsive Education Solutions, which has more than sixty campuses in Texas, bypasses the board of education’s approval process and uses textbooks that include classic creationist rhetoric. This shouldn’t be a huge surprise considering that charter schools often have strong religious ties and, in some cases, are even housed in churches.
We've reported recently on Responsive Education, which has won licenses to own and operate four charter schools in Arkansas — Pine Bluff, Little Rock (2) and Bentonville — and to get paid to manage three more for public school districts in Fountain Lake, Pea Ridge and West Memphis. They were faulted in Slate not only for lack in biology, but also in history. And I reported recently that they won approval for the Quest Little Rock charter middle school represented to be located on Rahling Road in Chenal Valley while they were working on moving the site seven miles east without notice to the state Board of Education hearing their application.
Responsive Ed has taken steps after the Slate article to change its biology material and that new material has arrived, I was told by one of its teachers last week. Perhaps the new rules in Texas, where Responsive Ed gets public money to operate 60 schools, had more influence than the Slate article. Responsive Ed has defended its past teaching of creationism by saying it complied with Texas law.
Responsive Ed, with deep religious advocates among its leaders, is by no means alone in pushing a religious view of the origins of life. It crops up periodically in other public schools in Arkansas and many schools don't teach the subject at all, lest they rile people with talk of evolution.
The Texas Monthly article doesn't mention it, directly but the textbook author, Kenneth Miller, who teaches at Brown, is one of the country's leading evolution defenders. I encountered him while my son was a student there in this alumni magazine article about him. Recommended.
Comments (2)
Showing 1-2 of 2
More by Max Brantley
-
More criticism of Little Rock police no-knock drug raids
Radley Balko of the Washington Post has written at length about the legal issues underlying whether Little Rock police have been acting constitutionally in no-knock drug raids (never mind that they have often come up empty-handed, relied on a liar and disproportionately busted black people.)
- Oct 20, 2018
-
Judicial election watchdog blasts ads targeting Justice Courtney Goodson
A volunteer group established to police campaigns for judicial elections is blasting a Republican group's advertising aimed at supporting David Sterling's attempt to unseat Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Courtney Goodson.
- Oct 20, 2018
-
Clarke Tucker to French Hill: Where is the decency?
Speaking of campaign advertising: Clarke Tucker, the Democratic candidate for 2nd District Congress, has issued his toughest TV yet against Republican incumbent Rep. French Hill.
- Oct 20, 2018
- More »
Readers also liked…
-
Hospitality, restaurant groups oppose bathroom bill
Add the restaurant and hospitality association to those opposed to Sen. Linda Collins-Smith's bill to keep transgender people out of public restrooms that match their gender identity.
- Mar 16, 2017
-
Honeymoon appears over for Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Baghdad Barbie of Trump White House
The reviews aren't kind for Sarah Huckabee Sanders' honesty as White House press secretary
- Feb 9, 2018
-
The two cities of Little Rock: East/west, black/white
The Little Rock City Board illustrated this week a community divided over public schools, another blow to the Little Rock School District and another illustration of the need for ward elections to the board.
- Mar 23, 2017
Slideshows
-
Arkansas vs Ole Miss at War Memorial stadium in Little Rock, Saturday, Oct. 13, 2018. After leading for much of the game, Arkansas lost 37-33 when Ole Miss scored the game winning Touchdown with less that 2 minutes left.
-
Margaret Clark Adventure Park
New sculptures, preschoolers play area dedicated in Riverfront Park in Little Rock.
Site Index
News
Cover Story / Arkansas Reporter / The Week That Was / The Observer / Editorial / Max Brantley / Ernest Dumas / Gene Lyons / Jay Barth / Words / Guest Writer / Letters
Entertainment
A&E Feature / To-Do List / In Brief / Movie Reviews / Music Reviews / Theater Reviews / A&E News / Art Notes / Media / Dining Reviews / Dining Guide / Calendar / Gallery Listings
PS: All this because I didn't like a TV show. You and your dad might be interested to know I"ve now read a review t… https://t.co/VbY6eVWGXn
Arkansas Blog - Max Brantley
Today's Democrat-Gazette front page. Read the day's top stories at https://t.co/3gbuqQKTqj https://t.co/GwWjDbwQ01
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
World Reacts With Skepticism To Saudi Confirmation Of Jamal Khashoggi's Death
KUAR Newsroom
RT @AustinKellerman:
Fox16 News
RT @AustinKellerman:
KARK4News
Arkansas Blog - Max Brantley
Today's Democrat-Gazette front page. Read the day's top stories at https://t.co/3gbuqQKTqj https://t.co/GwWjDbwQ01
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
World Reacts With Skepticism To Saudi Confirmation Of Jamal Khashoggi's Death
KUAR Newsroom
RT @AustinKellerman:
Fox16 News
RT @AustinKellerman:
KARK4News
Most Recent Comments
-
Re: Clarke Tucker to French Hill: Where is the decency?
Hill has made his bed with rich power brokers, we need to vote him out.
-
on October 20, 2018
-
Re: Truth in state contracting an issue in $342 million computer deal
Max, I've already gone down that rabbit hole (SOS Martin's joke) and Deloitte does not…
- on October 20, 2018
-
Re: Truth in state contracting an issue in $342 million computer deal
Good question. Secretary of State Mark Martin's online lobby search is useless in my experience…
- on October 20, 2018
This Week's Cover
Quick Links
Special Publications
RSS
Facebook
Twitter