Reform to private option could cost more than it produces | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Reform to private option could cost more than it produces

Posted By on Thu, Jan 1, 2015 at 6:58 AM

The Human Services Department announced yesterday that the federal government had signed off on a couple of changes to the private option Medicaid expansion pushed by legislators hoping to make the program more to the liking of conservatives

One cut back on non-emergency transportation by limiting payments for trips to the doctor. You can still find some legislators who think this is an unfair burden on people who live in rural areas far removed from medical services providers. And they think reducing health visits can have expensive consequences. But their number has decreased substantially.

Another was the so-called "independence account." This requires poor people to pay $5 to $15 a month into a savings account to offset medical co-pays and to save for a day when they might be able to buy purely private insurance.

Legislators don't like the idea of anybody receiving something for nothing — unless you are talking about free meals and drinks served up by lobbyists daily during the legislative session. Or the state-paid health insurance lawmakers enjoy.

Legislators hope poor folks' investment in health care will make them more responsible and wise about health decisions.

A couple of thoughts: Payments are required of an individual making as little as $5,500 a year, or as little as $12,000 for a family of four. $15 doesn't seem like much money unless you are making $1,000 a month to support four people.

Then there's this simple arithmetic: It has been estimated that the cost of administering the independence accounts is $15 million, paid from state and federal money. The program will require savings accounts for 97,000 people. Even if all had to pay the full $15 every month or $180 a year — and they won't all be required to pay the full amount and many won't be able to make payments — the savings accounts would add up to about $17.5 million, not much more than the cost of running the program. Robbing Peter to pay Paul, sounds like.

Legislators have always loved to extract a little flesh from poor people before giving them alms. Much more of this is to come in the effort to sell continuation of the private option in the 2015 legislative session. You'll remember that national Republican orthodoxy is to turn all social programs into "savings accounts." In return for a tax credit for savings, poor folks would theoretically save enough from their sporadic minimum wage earnings to pile up the cash necessary to pay for their medical needs (doctors surely would cooperate by cutting fees to accommodate their hard-pressed patients). The Arkansas "independence account" is just the first baby step down that mythical path.

We already know the sum of the arithmetic. It means a reduction in government expense for health care. That means a reduction in health care for poor people. Poor people have few lobbyists.

Tags: , , ,


Comments (6)

Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Clarke Tucker challenges French HIll to series of debates

    Clarke Tucker, the Democratic candidate for 2nd District Congress, has called on Republican incumbent Rep. French Hill to reconsider his refusal to participate in a televised debate in September and to join him for a series of three debates.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • Abduction suspect arrested during threatened jump from bridge

    Danny Trent Barrows, 38, wanted for abducting his child earlier in the week, was arrested Wednesday as he attempted to jump off an Interstate 49 bridge near Mountainburg.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • Wage campaign reports financial backer

    Arkansans for a Fair Wage, the committee backing an increase in the state minimum wage, reported this month a $350,000 contribution from the Sixteen Thirty Fund, a Washington-based nonprofit that has funded advocacy campaigns for social and environmental causes around the country.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments



© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation