Judge invalidates state's criminal eviction statute | Arkansas Blog

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Judge invalidates state's criminal eviction statute

Posted By on Tue, Jan 20, 2015 at 4:27 PM

Pulaski Circuit Judge Herb Wright today found that the state's criminal eviction statute violates the U.S. Constitution's prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment.

Arkansas is the only state that has a criminal as well as civil eviction statute. It is among the worst states in affording few protections to tenants, but plenty to landlords.

David Koon wrote last week about this lawsuit and the effort to invalidate  the criminal statute, which allows eviction on being as little as one day late on a rent payment. The article noted:

In Arkansas, if a tenant seeks to contest the charges and plead not guilty, the current law — Arkansas Code annotated 18-16-101 — requires the tenant to deposit the entire amount of rent he or she allegedly owes with the registry of the court, which will hold the funds until the case is decided. If the tenant is found guilty of the misdemeanor, he or she will forfeit the money placed with the court to the landlord, and will be liable for $25 per day for every day he or she stayed in the residence after being served with the eviction notice. If the tenant does not place the alleged back rent with the registry of the court and is eventually found guilty of the nonpayment of rent and failure to vacate, then the law says the renter is guilty of a more serious Class B misdemeanor, punishable by a $1,000 fine and 90 days in jail.

Wright said Arkansas's singular position with a criminal statute supported the argument that the punishment was unusual. 

The judge noted a commission had unanimously recommended repeal of the law. The legislature resisted, at the instigation of the real estate lobby. If the requirement of remitting money to the registry was a violation of due process alone, the judge said he could invalidate that and try the defendant on a misdemeanor charge without forcing compliance with that part of the law. But the judge said any application of the law was unconstitutional under the ban on debtor's prisons. The one of a kind law is, on its face, unconstitutional, he said.

He dismissed the case brought against Artorio Smith for failure to vacate in 10 days after the landlord, Primo Novero, declared Smith failed to make rent payment. The state, in response, noted a lack of Arkansas Supreme Court guidance on the current statute and the potential for unconstitutional treatment of defendants based on differing abilities to pay. Central Arkansas Legal Services has represented Smith in the case.

A similar case was filed in Washington County and decided differently. A state appeal would settle the question. I've asked the attorney general if it plans, as is customary, to continue to defend the state statute until a final ruling. Judd Deere, spokesman for the office, replied:

"A decision as to whether the state files an appeal will be made once the Attorney General's office has thoroughly reviewed the decision of the circuit court and discussed the case with the local prosecutor."

Tags: , ,


Favorite

Comments (29)

Showing 1-29 of 29

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-29 of 29

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Clarke Tucker challenges French HIll to series of debates

    Clarke Tucker, the Democratic candidate for 2nd District Congress, has called on Republican incumbent Rep. French Hill to reconsider his refusal to participate in a televised debate in September and to join him for a series of three debates.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • Abduction suspect arrested during threatened jump from bridge

    Danny Trent Barrows, 38, wanted for abducting his child earlier in the week, was arrested Wednesday as he attempted to jump off an Interstate 49 bridge near Mountainburg.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • Wage campaign reports financial backer

    Arkansans for a Fair Wage, the committee backing an increase in the state minimum wage, reported this month a $350,000 contribution from the Sixteen Thirty Fund, a Washington-based nonprofit that has funded advocacy campaigns for social and environmental causes around the country.
    • Aug 15, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

People who saved…

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Slideshows

 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation