Arkansas Supreme Court rules predictably in case created to delay same-sex marriage ruling | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Arkansas Supreme Court rules predictably in case created to delay same-sex marriage ruling

Posted By on Thu, May 7, 2015 at 11:17 AM

click to enlarge RERUN: More redundancy from the state Supreme Court on the marriage question. - COURTS.ARKANSAS.GOV
  • RERUN: More redundancy from the state Supreme Court on the marriage question.

The Arkansas Supreme Court ruled today that the Court's current seven members should decide Smith v. Wright, the case challenging the state's ban on same-sex marriage.

The opinion issued by the Court today was in regards to a secondary case over the question of which justices should rule on the original lawsuit.

Here's the opinion, with Justice Karen Baker writing for the majority:

Three of the seven justices recused themselves from today's opinion: Justice Rhonda Wood because the decision directly concerned her participation, and Chief Justice Jim Hannah and Justice Paul Danielson because they were strongly opposed to hearing the secondary case at all. In Hannah's recusal letter, he said he believed the new case was created out of "whole cloth" by the majority of the court in order to delay the decision in the original marriage case.

In April, Governor Asa Hutchinson appointed Shawn Womack, Betty Dickey and Brett Watson as special justices to hear the secondary case. In a separate concurrence today, Watson said he believed the majority's opinion was written too broadly, though he agreed on the fundamental question of allowing Wood to participate in the marriage case.

Previously, Tippi McCullough of the Stonewall Democrats filed a complaint with the Judicial Discipline and Disability Commission against the remaining justices — Karen Baker, Courtney Goodson, Jo Hart and Robin Wynne — on the basis of the recusal letters from Danielson and Hannah. 

According to the Times' sources, the Court voted on the original case Nov. 20, with one justice drawing the majority opinion. That opinion wasn't completed by the end of the year, and soon thereafter the composition of the court changed due to the November elections.

Attorney General Leslie Rutledge filed a motion in April contending that the matter should be reargued and that the current members of the Court should decide the case. Plaintiffs' attorneys originally objected to the new panel deciding the case, but relented in hopes of speeding up the case (which further should've made the secondary case unnecessary). 

Special Justice Robert McCorkindale and now-retired Justice Donald Corbin were part of the panel of justices who heard the original appeal in November. McCorkindale served in place of former Justice Cliff Hoofman, who recused from the original case and now serves on the Arkansas Court of Appeals. Justice Wood filled Hoofman's place on the Court. Justice Wynne was elected to replace Corbin.

What's next? Either the current Court will conference again, vote again, assign a majority opinion again and so forth, or it'll ask for oral arguments again. In either case, as we've said before, don't expect a decision before the U.S. Supreme Court has its say.

Tags: , , , ,

Sign up for the Daily Update email

Comments (12)

Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

More by Lindsey Millar

  • The Dark Money Edition

    The coming primary and judicial elections, especially the dark money flowing into a race for an Arkansas Supreme Court position; also Leslie Rutledge and the ballot initiative process and the Razorbacks and War Memorial.
    • May 18, 2018
  • The Leslie Rutledge Sovereign Immunity Trap Edition

    The Democratic primary for the 2nd Congressional District, sovereign immunity and Leslie Rutledge and the Little Rock mayoral race — all covered on this week's podcast.
    • May 11, 2018
  • Samantha's again wins the Arkansas Times Second Annual Margarita Fest

    Congratulations to Samantha's Tap Room & Wood Grill for winning the Arkansas Times Second Annual Margarita Festival presented by Don Julio Tequila last night. The Pizzeria was the runner-up. Thanks to the 600 people who came out to the sold-out event, proceeds of which benefited the Downtown Partnership.
    • May 11, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • A response to police arrests becomes a tutorial on race, class and policing in Little Rock

    John Walker, the 79-year-old civil rights lawyer, and his associate, Omavi Shukur, 29, a young lawyer devoted to criminal justice reform, talked to press this afternoon about their arrests Monday by Little Rock police for supposedly obstructing governmental operations in observing and attempting to film a routine police traffic stop. It was a tutorial on sharp views of race, class and governance in Little Rock.
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • Donald Trump declares war on Hillary Clinton's marriage

    Donald Trump gave a remarkable interview to the New York Times yesterday in which he declared open season on the marriage of Bill and Hillary Clinton and Bill Clinton's past infidelity. Seems like a loser, but I've been wrong before.
    • Oct 1, 2016
  • Arkansas: Land of .......

    Welcome to Arkansas: Land of cowardly politicians, discriminatory laws, inhumane turkey drops and lots and lots of Trump voters.
    • Oct 8, 2016

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments



© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation