Planned Parenthood analysis: Videos deceptively edited | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, August 27, 2015

Planned Parenthood analysis: Videos deceptively edited

Posted By on Thu, Aug 27, 2015 at 12:50 PM

click to enlarge pp.jpg
Planned Parenthood has issued an extensive rebuttal to undercover videos by an anti-abortion group elaborating with some specifics on its allegations from the first that the videos — including some described as "full" videos — were edited to be misleading.

The report, submitted to Congress, said the videos "significantly distort and misrepresent" actual events. Planned Parenthood,

Governor Asa Hutchinson has used the video attacks to end Planned Parenthood's Medicaid contract with the State of Arkansas, endangering access to valuable health care services. This new report lays out the facts and details that these videos are deceptively edited, should not be used as evidence in a legal context and have no journalistic value.

Key quotes from the expert report:

● “The short videos take a great deal of dialog out of context so as to substantively and significantly alter the meaning of the dialog contained in the long videos.”
● “CMP [Center for Medical Progress] edited content out of the alleged “full footage” videos, and heavily edited the short videos so as to misrepresent statements made by Planned Parenthood representatives.”
● “The short videos significantly distort and misrepresent the conversations in the full footage. Mr. Fredericks notes that the short videos contain ‘edited conversations where some spoken words are eliminated and some spoken words are added out of context.’”
● “At this point, it is impossible to characterize the extent to which CMP’s undisclosed edits and cuts distort the meaning of the encounters the videos purport to document. However, the manipulation of the videos does mean they have no evidentiary value in a legal context and cannot be relied upon for any official inquiries unless supplemented by CMP’s original material and forensic authentication that this material is supplied in unaltered form.”

Along with the expert report, Planned Parenthood compiled a short breakdown of the heavy, deceptive editing in the five videos.

Gov. Hutchinson has ordered the state to stop providing Medicaid reimbursement for gynecological and other medical services provided by Planned Parenthood in Arkansas. Medicaid does not pay for abortions provided by Planned Parenthood in Arkansas, which distributes pills to prompt miscarriages in the first nine weeks of pregnancy, but does not perform clinical abortions. (Medicaid has exceptions for rape and incest and life of the mother.)

The funding stops Sept. 14. Unless Hutchinson reverses its decision, Planned Parenthood in Arkansas is expected to sue to stop the end of Medicaid funding, which provided about $50,000 worth of reimbursements last year. The organization has sued in Louisiana already and successfully sued against similar actions in Indiana and Arizona several years ago. The federal government has said states can't stop Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood and such a move could jeopardize state participation in the program..

The undercover group has contended Planned Parenthood is selling fetal tissue. Planned Parenthood says it is not and even released videos depict representatives talking only about legal reimbursement for shipping costs. The aim of the video is to cripple Planned Parenthood as a tool to ultimately end the availability of abortion. Use of fetal tissue is legal and has been important in a number of medical advances.

In a statement, the group that made the videos said cuts of waiting periods and bathroom breaks didn't change the meaning of dialogue and the use of "hand-picked 'experts'" was only meant to distract from "crimes." The group has yet to produce evidence of any illegal sales of fetal tissue.

I've asked the governor for a response. Following is the full release with links to relevant documents.



Report and Letter to Congress Outline Substantial Deceptive Editing in Anti-Abortion Video Campaign

At least 42 times, statements are spliced together and made to appear like seamless conversations; large chunks of video are missing

Heavily edited, widely reported videos ‘significantly distort and misrepresent’ actual events, expert report concludes

AUGUST 27, 2015; LITTLE ROCK, AR – Secretly recorded videos about Planned Parenthood and lifesaving fetal tissue donation, which have been reported on widely by the media for the last six weeks, were heavily edited and “significantly distort and misrepresent” actual events, according to an expert report submitted to congressional leadership today.

“A thorough review of these videos in consultation with qualified experts found that they do not present a complete or accurate record of the events they purport to depict,” wrote Glenn Simpson, a partner at the research firm Fusion GPS, in a 10-page report submitted to leadership of the House and Senate.

Fusion GPS assembled three teams of experts in video forensics, production and transcription to review five secretly recorded videos of Planned Parenthood staff that have been released as part of a three-year fraud by a group of anti-abortion activists with extremist ties. The experts, who include Grant Fredericks who is a contract instructor of video sciences at the FBI National Academy and one of the most experienced video experts in North America, reviewed the short videos (of eight to 15 minutes in length) that have been widely reported on and viewed, as well as the longer versions of those videos (which total 12 hours for all five) that were released hours or days later.

Governor Asa Hutchinson has used the video attacks to end Planned Parenthood's Medicaid contract with the State of Arkansas, endangering access to valuable health care services. This new report lays out the facts and details that these videos are deceptively edited, should not be used as evidence in a legal context and have no journalistic value.

Key quotes from the expert report:
● “The short videos take a great deal of dialog out of context so as to substantively and significantly alter the meaning of the dialog contained in the long videos.”
● “CMP [Center for Medical Progress] edited content out of the alleged “full footage” videos, and heavily edited the short videos so as to misrepresent statements made by Planned Parenthood representatives.”
● “The short videos significantly distort and misrepresent the conversations in the full footage. Mr. Fredericks notes that the short videos contain ‘edited conversations where some spoken words are eliminated and some spoken words are added out of context.’”
● “At this point, it is impossible to characterize the extent to which CMP’s undisclosed edits and cuts distort the meaning of the encounters the videos purport to document. However, the manipulation of the videos does mean they have no evidentiary value in a legal context and cannot be relied upon for any official inquiries unless supplemented by CMP’s original material and forensic authentication that this material is supplied in unaltered form.”

Along with the expert report, Planned Parenthood compiled a short breakdown of the heavy, deceptive editing in the five videos.

Key data from the summary:
● Collectively, the five videos of Planned Parenthood staff have at least 42 splices where content is cut and edited together to create the appearance of seamless conversations.
● In some cases, these splices completely change the meaning of statements. On one video, a Planned Parenthood staff member’s remarks about lab protocols were edited to make it sound like she was talking about changing abortion procedures. Phrases on the video were isolated and removed, stringing together unrelated sentences to change the meaning. Anti-abortion activists used the doctored “quote” to support false claims that she was talking about changing how an abortion would be done, and the “quote” was published by mainstream media as if it were real.
● On one video, a Planned Parenthood staff member in Colorado says 13 separate times that any arrangements related to fetal tissue donation need to be reviewed by attorneys and follow all laws – and all 13 are edited out of the video.
● On another video, a Planned Parenthood staff member in Texas says nine separate times that there is no “profit” related to fetal tissue donation – and all nine are edited out of the video.

The summary of edits and the expert report were submitted to Senate and House leadership with a letter from Planned Parenthood Federation of America that provides background and information on our involvement with fetal tissue research. The letter explains that fetal tissue research is critical for helping develop cures for serious diseases and advancing public health. Planned Parenthood affiliates in two states – 1% of Planned Parenthood’s health centers – currently offer tissue donation as an option for women who want it. Planned Parenthood of the Heartland does not participate in a tissue donation program.

The letter outlines the legal requirements of fetal tissue donation and quotes from Planned Parenthood Federation of America’s guidance for this work, which goes far above and beyond the legal requirements. The letter notes that, even with the deceptive edits to videos and misinformation campaign over the last six weeks, there is no evidence and no indication that Planned Parenthood has violated any laws or medical standards – and that, on the contrary, Planned Parenthood provides a full range of high-quality health care services to 2.7 million people a year, including birth control, cancer screenings, STD testing and abortion.

“Planned Parenthood is the nation’s leading provider of high-quality reproductive health care and sex education. Millions of people walk through our doors every year, all across this country, and trust us to give them the health care and information they need,” Planned Parenthood Federation of America President Cecile Richards said today. “Our commitment is to get all the facts and share them fully, and that’s what we’re doing today. We’ve said all along that these videos were heavily edited to deceive the public, and that’s what this expert analysis now shows. The more the public learns about this fraudulent, baseless attack on women’s health, the better, and that’s why today we’re laying everything out for leaders in Congress and for the public.”

“We’ve said from the beginning that the people behind these videos have been deceiving the public for years, and now expert analysis confirms the extent of their deception,” said Suzanna de Baca, president and CEO, Planned Parenthood of the Heartland. “Three teams of experts in video forensics, production and transcription have determined that the videos have no value in a legal context and no credibility. We urge lawmakers to stop using these wholly fraudulent videos to justify measures that threaten access to affordable, high-quality health care in Arkansas.”

To date, four separate committees in the House and Senate have launched investigations into Planned Parenthood. In the last two weeks, five states have concluded investigations into Planned Parenthood – and every one of them has found no wrongdoing. In two states – California and Texas – lawmakers have also called for investigations of the Center for Medical Progress (CMP). Last month, a bill to defund Planned Parenthood and block millions of women from having access to health care failed to pass in the U.S. Senate.

Links:

The letter to congressional leadership submitted today
The expert report on the deceptive editing of videos
A summary of the deceptive editing of videos
Fact sheet on public support for Planned Parenthood
Fact sheet on state investigations finding no wrongdoing

Tags: , , , ,

From the ArkTimes store

Favorite

Comments (12)

Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Readers also liked…

Most Shared

  • Guest Playlist: Flap Jones of "Not Necessarily Nashville" schools us on real country music

    "Not Necessarily Nashville," which airs on KUAR-FM 89.1 every Saturday, 7 p.m.-9 p.m., celebrates three decades of the "best of the rest of country music" Saturday, October 21 at the White Water Tavern with Brad Williams of The Salty Dogs & The Creek Rocks, and we asked host Flap Jones to curate a playlist for us ahead of that anniversary celebration.
  • Discussion: State killing of the mentally ill

    The Arkansas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty and others will have a forum on mental illness and the death penalty at 6:30 p.m. Monday at the Bowen School of Law's Friday Courtroom.

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Blogroll

 

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation