Legislature subpoenas judge to testify about child custody decisions. | Arkansas Blog

Tuesday, August 30, 2016

Legislature subpoenas judge to testify about child custody decisions.

Posted By on Tue, Aug 30, 2016 at 6:30 PM

JUDGE PATRICIA JAMES: Subpoenaed before legislative committee.
  • JUDGE PATRICIA JAMES: Subpoenaed before legislative committee.
First, the straight journalism lede courtesy of KARK:

The Legislative Joint Performance Review Committee has subpoenaed Circuit Judge Patricia James, who handles juvenile cases in Pulaski and Perry County, to testify to explain her child custody decisions.

Now the truth: This is the latest example of a power-thirsty Republican legislature run amok. The constitutional power it gave itself under voters' approval of institutionalization of legislative review was already breathtaking. It further diminished an executive weak because of the 51 percent veto override provisions in the Constitution.

But now the legislature wants to tell the court what to do. The amendment to cripple lawsuits against nursing homes will end court control of court rules and pass it to the legislature. But this James subpoena is an even more audacious flexing of unconstitutional muscle.

Republican Sen. Alan Clark of Hot Springs seems to be driving the train, as part of his crusade against judges who put the safety interest of children ahead of parents whose religion or simple nuttiness favors physical punishment, weird food supplements and other strange ideas. DHS also doesn't like to be called down in court by judges when they fail to follow court rules and procedures, and their unhappiness is the root of some of this. (We all know what a great job they've done looking after children in the past; Justin Harris, anyone?) They've complained about some of James' rulings.

First. Of course, she should answer a legal subpoena. She must. The system demands it. And then she should tell legislators, in polite terms, to get f****ed. The ethical rules that govern judges prohibit her from discussing why she made certain rulings. She is not obliged to defend or explain them.

If DHS doesn't like Judge James rulings, there is an established procedure to follow. They may appeal them to the Arkansas Supreme Court. As beholden as that court has proven lately of legislative wishes, they might get some relief.

I need know NOTHING of the particulars of the cases that James has handled that have prompted this unprecedented subpoena and the threat to hold her "in contempt of court" as KARK put it, if she doesn't answer. The legislators are daily in contempt of the separation of powers doctrine of the Constitution. Patty James may not call them on it, but I will.

On issue of contention is this: James has previously explained that while Arkansas law gives preference for placement of children with relatives, judges must first weigh the safety of those decisions and sometimes decide state custody is preferable. Again, if DHS or someone else believes the judge erred in deciding the safest place for a child, they may appeal. In court.

Judge James responded in writing:
"All I can comment is that I have not seen the subpoena yet, but once it is received, it will be forwarded to the appropriate people to respond to it."
It would have been injudicious to say, "stick it where the sun don't shine." I am reminded of the famous George Fisher cartoon of the place where the sun doesn't shine being the brain of Tommy Robinson. If only George were around to update the cartoon with Alan Clark.

Tags: , , , ,

From the ArkTimes store

Favorite

Comments (19)

Showing 1-19 of 19

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-19 of 19

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • Thursday: The open line and the video report

    Here's the open line and the day's video, leading with discussion of Snowflake Tom Cotton.
    • Jan 18, 2018
  • NLR police identify officers in shooting of teen

    KARK reports that the North Little Rock Police Department has released the names of officers at the scene when a 17-year-old teen was fatally shot after he pulled a gun and fired it when being taken into custody after a traffic stop.
    • Jan 18, 2018
  • Rutledge's man protects the usurious payday lenders

    Attorney General Leslie Rutledge's support for Mick Mulvaney to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau was rewarded today with CFPB action bad for consumers, but good for payday lenders.
    • Jan 18, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Lawyers plead for mercy in Fort Smith forum shopping case

    Twelve of the lawyers facing punishment by federal Judge P.K. Holmes in Fort Smith for moving a class action case against an insurance company out of his court to a state court where it was speedily settled have filed their argument against sanctions.
    • Jun 16, 2016
  • City Board votes to table homeless feeding ordinance for 8 weeks, study with commission

    The Little Rock Board of Directors voted tonight to table for eight weeks an ordinance that homeless advocates say would severely limit the ability of charities to feed homeless people in city parks. Before the ordinance was punted, Vice Mayor Kathy Webb proposed a nine-member commission to study the issue and make recommendations to the board.
    • May 16, 2017
  • Lawsuit filed over settlement in forum-shopping class action case

    The lawyers facing disciplinary action by federal Judge P.K. Holmes in Fort Smith over their settlement of a class action lawsuit against the USAA insurance company have a new legal headache.
    • Jun 21, 2016

Most Shared

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation