Supreme Court merit selection proposal in legislative hands | Arkansas Blog

Friday, October 7, 2016

Supreme Court merit selection proposal in legislative hands

Posted By on Fri, Oct 7, 2016 at 10:19 AM

click to enlarge CHOOSING THE BOSSES: A proposal to appoint rather than elect members of the Arkansas Supreme Court is under study at the legislature.
  • CHOOSING THE BOSSES: A proposal to appoint rather than elect members of the Arkansas Supreme Court is under study at the legislature.

The Arkansas Bar Association's effort to craft a proposed constitutional amendment for so-called "merit selection" rather than election of members of the Arkansas Supreme Court has produced a draft now in the hands of the Bureau of Legislative Research.

It is leaking around to legislators, members of the Supreme Court and others. Forecast of outcome: Cloudy.

UPDATE: I've received a copy of the draft now.


Here's what I was told about the proposal:

* The governor would choose a person to fill a court opening from three names submitted by a panel composed of nine members — five from the Arkansas Bar Association (chosen in a procedure decided outside the Constitution by the Bar Association), two by the governor and one each from the House speaker and Senate president pro tempore. If the governor didn't like the choices, he or she could do nothing. Then the nominating committee would make the selection.

* Appointments would be for a single 14-year term. There'd be no second term. That means no "retention" election that might influence bench decision making.

* The amendment would be referred to voters in 2018. The first opening thus would be in 2020, current Justice Jo Hart's seat. Current court members would be eligible for appointment under the new scheme. All would complete existing elected terms, but there'd be some differences in lengths of the new appointed terms in the initial round so as to provide, in the future, for a selection every two years. Justices Robin Wynne, Karen Baker and Rhonda Wood have terms ending in 2022. The terms of Chief Justice Dan Kemp and Shawn Womack end in 2024. Justice Courtney Goodson's seat is on the ballot in 2018. The terms currently are eight years.

This would be sold as removing politics from the judiciary and replacing it with merit selection and providing a greater appearance of fairness. Money — particularly dark money from unknown sources — would no longer influence outcomes. Judges would be insulated both from elections and pure political appointment. A "level playing field" is one talking point I'd imagine we would hear.

Rep. Matthew Shepherd, who's been a champion of judicial appointment, reportedly is reasonably warm to this proposal, though I'd guess he recognizes the political shortcomings.

Republican Gov. Asa Hutchinson won't support it. He wants the "federal system."  In this, the governor makes the appointment, subject to confirmation by the Republican-controlled Senate. That would be far more political than the bar's appointment proposal. Advocates of the bar proposal will argue that political dynamics can change. You can be sure Hutchinson wouldn't have liked a "federal system" when Democrats controlled government top to bottom, they'd say. The nature of politicians with power, however, is to believe things will never change, for a thousand years or so or at least through their term of office. 

The ruling cabal on the Arkansas Supreme Court — Justices Jo Hart, Rhonda Wood, Karen Baker and Courtney Goodson -- is believed cool to the bar plan. For one thing, a nominating panel might find one or another of them unqualified for another term.

The biggest hurdle will be convincing Arkansas voters, who like elections, to give them up. I could provide a number of reasons why the mood should be different (nursing home influence particularly), I'm not aware of a great dissatisfaction with the Supreme Court as it now stands. The court's dodging of the same-sex marriage decision had just this political dynamic in mind.

Lots more to come in the legislative session, when the General Assembly puts amendments on the ballot. A complication could also be another lawyer battle — a renewed fight  over tort reform. This will be only partially addressed (and badly) if the nursing home protection amendment reaches the ballot and is approved by voters. The issues have a relationship. If you move to merit selection of a court that no longer controls its rules (as the business lobby and many in the legislature would like to achieve in sweeping tort reform), what difference does it make?

Tags: , , , , ,

From the ArkTimes store

Favorite

Comments (6)

Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • But what about the Clintons? Last refuge of Trump, New York Times

    Trying to compare Donald Trump's reaction to the Russia investigation with Bill Clinton's dealings with Kenneth Starr should be a non-starter if the facts mattered. But these days — and to the New York Times — it ain't necessarily so.
    • Jul 23, 2017
  • Football is king, Bentonville edition

    Good analysis in the Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette of an unannounced Bentonville School Board vote last week to put $2 million into a football stadium for West High School despite board assurances in last May's tax election that no money would go to a football stadium.
    • Jul 23, 2017
  • Dinner and dancing in Dogtown

    A good night out in Argenta. Looking for the theater? Consider "Sweet Charity."
    • Jul 23, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Al Gore remembers Dale Bumpers

    Former Vice President Al Gore, a former U.S. Senate colleague of Dale Bumpers, sent a statement on Bumpers' death Friday:
    • Jan 3, 2016
  • Is Arkansas in or out on Kobach voter data effort?

    The Washington Post has published a map that counts Arkansas as among states that will "partially comply" with a sweeping request for voter data by the so-called election integrity commission set up by Donald Trump in an effort to cast doubt on Hillary Clinton's 3 million-vote popular defeat of him in 2016.
    • Jul 2, 2017
  • Jason Rapert vs. Wikipedia

    Sen. Jason Rapert against the world: Wikipedia edition.
    • Jan 23, 2016

Most Shared

  • So much for a school settlement in Pulaski County

    The Arkansas Democrat-Gazette's Cynthia Howell got the scoop on what appears to be coming upheaval in the Pulaski County School District along with the likely end of any chance of a speedy resolution of school desegregation issues in Pulaski County.
  • Riverfest calls it quits

    The board of directors of Riverfest, Arkansas's largest and longest running music festival, announced today that the festival will no longer be held. Riverfest celebrated its 40th anniversary in June. A press release blamed competition from other festivals and the rising cost of performers fees for the decision.
  • Football for UA Little Rock

    Andrew Rogerson, the new chancellor at UA Little Rock, has decided to study the cost of starting a major college football team on campus (plus a marching band). Technically, it would be a revival of football, dropped more than 60 years ago when the school was a junior college.
  • Turn to baseball

    When the world threatens to get you down, there is always baseball — an absorbing refuge, an alternate reality entirely unto itself.

Most Viewed

  • Football is king, Bentonville edition

    Good analysis in the Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette of an unannounced Bentonville School Board vote last week to put $2 million into a football stadium for West High School despite board assurances in last May's tax election that no money would go to a football stadium.
  • But what about the Clintons? Last refuge of Trump, New York Times

    Trying to compare Donald Trump's reaction to the Russia investigation with Bill Clinton's dealings with Kenneth Starr should be a non-starter if the facts mattered. But these days — and to the New York Times — it ain't necessarily so.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Dinner and dancing in Dogtown

    • "Try Capeo for some excellent Italian"

      Always an excellent meal here.

    • on July 23, 2017
  • Re: Saturday open line

    • After Gerald Ford pardoned Nixon, it was not surprising to see Bush Senior pardon the…

    • on July 23, 2017
  • Re: Football is king, Bentonville edition

    • "Damn, the line for the Sonic will be out in the highway" In small-town rKen$aw,…

    • on July 23, 2017

Blogroll

 

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation