Supreme Court reverses sobriety checkpoint conviction | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Supreme Court reverses sobriety checkpoint conviction

Posted By on Thu, Oct 20, 2016 at 10:50 AM

click to enlarge dwi-checkpoint-baton-rouge.jpg
The Arkansas Supreme Court today reversed a DWI conviction in Sebastian County because the highway sobriety checkpoint was unconstitutionally operated. The decision set a standard for such checkpoints in the future.

Jeremy Whalen challenged his first offense  conviction in 2012 on the ground that the State Police sobriety checkpoint was unconstitutional. The Arkansas Court of Appeals agreed and overturned the conviction, but the Supreme Court was asked to review that decision by the state because of, among others, a need for clarification and "substantial public interest."

Cpl. Dwight Lee testified that sobriety checkpoints were set up most weekends, generally at a trooper's discretion, and information was compiled about them after the fact.

Whalen argued that the checkpoint wasn't conducted according to a "neutral and explicit" plan and individual officers had too much discretion in the operation. The state argued that the stop was conducted in compliance with State Police policies and procedures. But the Supreme Court refused the state's request to take judicial notice of State Police Policies and Procedures Manuals of 2012 and 2015 because they were not before the circuit court in this case.

The Arkansas Supreme Court held that the checkpoint didn't meet the test set out in U.S. Supreme Court rulings for vehicle stops made for less than reasonable suspicion of criminal activity. Whalen was stopped at a checkpoint on an Interstate 540 exit ramp. An officer said he smelled alcohol and Whalen refused a breath test.

The Arkansas court said the state had failed to show that this checkpoint was carried out pursuant to a previously established objective and neutral plan that was designed by supervising officers.  Cpl. Lee testified  that it was set up without such input. The court said it also found merit in Whalen's argument that the field officer exercised unfettered discretion. 

Without evidence of  criminal conduct, the checkpoint stop was unreasonable and so the conviction was reversed, with the case remanded to circuit court for dismissal.

Chief Justice Howard Brill and Justice Rhonda Wood joined in a concurring opinion supporting the reversal of the conviction in this case, but objecting to the majority's adoption of a Tennessee case's standard for review of  checkpoints. It lists two factors necessary to show a field officer's discretion was sufficiently limited: 1) the decision to set up a roadblock was not made by the officers establishing the checkpoint, and 2) the officers on the scene cannot decide procedures for themselves.

An opinion written by Wood said this would erode local discretion. "Neither the United States Constitution nor the Arkansas Constitution requires us to adopt factors that will inevitably result in micromanaging law enforcement."

Tags: , , ,

From the ArkTimes store



Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • University of Texas removes Confederate statues

    Confederate statuary was removed overnight from a prominent spot on the University of Texas campus because they symbolize white supremacy and neo-Nazism, the university president said.
    • Aug 21, 2017
  • Eclipse day. Woodstock?

    I was amused by the excitement of a NASA scientist over today's eclipse, as reported by CNN.
    • Aug 21, 2017
  • Open line and Civil War update

    More Confederacy defenders were on hand in Bentonville against imagined threats to a one of hte Confederate statues put up long after the Civil War to spin a narrative about the noble Lost Cause.
    • Aug 20, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Auditor Lea caught not telling the truth

    State Auditor Andrea Lea, who began her tenure in statewide office with a degree of competence unseen in some other Republican counterparts (think Treasurer Dennis Milligan particularly), is becoming more deeply mired in a political scandal.
    • Mar 4, 2016
  • The two cities of Little Rock: East/west, black/white

    The Little Rock City Board illustrated this week a community divided over public schools, another blow to the Little Rock School District and another illustration of the need for ward elections to the board.
    • Mar 23, 2017
  • Another Republican miracle-working governor

    Great piece in Washington Post on the budget crisis in Louisiana. Big tax cuts and corporate welfare will do that to a state, particularly to a state whose previous governor, Republican Bobby Jindal, refused to join the Obamacare-funded Medicaid expansion. There's a lesson there for Arkansas.
    • Mar 4, 2016

Most Shared

  • Take yourself there: Mavis Staples coming to LR for Central High performance

    Gospel and R&B singer and civil rights activist Mavis Staples, who has been inspiring fans with gospel-inflected freedom songs like "I'll Take You There" and "March Up Freedom's Highway" and the poignant "Oh What a Feeling" will come to Little Rock for the commemoration of the 60th anniversary of the desegregation of Central High.
  • Klan's president

    Everything that Donald Trump does — make that everything that he says — is calculated to thrill his lustiest disciples. But he is discovering that what was brilliant for a politician is a miscalculation for a president, because it deepens the chasm between him and most Americans.
  • On Charlottesville

    Watching the Charlottesville spectacle from halfway across the country, I confess that my first instinct was to raillery. Vanilla ISIS, somebody called this mob of would-be Nazis. A parade of love-deprived nerds marching bravely out of their parents' basements carrying tiki torches from Home Depot.
  • Lynchings hidden in the history of the Hot Springs Confederate monument

    Hot Springs twice erupted into the kind of violence that has its roots in the issues left unresolved by the Civil War, and both times, it happened right where that monument to Confederate soldiers stands today.

Most Viewed

  • Open line and Civil War update

    More Confederacy defenders were on hand in Bentonville against imagined threats to a one of hte Confederate statues put up long after the Civil War to spin a narrative about the noble Lost Cause.

Most Recent Comments



© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation