Supreme Court refuses review of Rhonda Wood's participation in nursing home case | Arkansas Blog

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Supreme Court refuses review of Rhonda Wood's participation in nursing home case

Posted By on Thu, Jan 19, 2017 at 9:33 AM

INTERTWINED: Attorneys had argued that Justice Rhonda Wood's communication with former Republican Sen. Gilbert Baker on a controversial nursing home case that led to indictment of her friend Mike Maggio, then a circuit judge, should make her get off a pending case involving the same nursing home owner in the Maggio case. The Supreme Court refused today to hold a hearing or review her decision to stay on the case.
  • INTERTWINED: Attorneys had argued that Justice Rhonda Wood's communication with former Republican Sen. Gilbert Baker on a controversial nursing home case that led to indictment of her friend Mike Maggio, then a circuit judge, should make her get off a pending case involving the same nursing home owner in the Maggio case. The Supreme Court refused today to hold a hearing or review her decision to stay on the case.

The Arkansas Supreme Court today rejected a challenge to Justice Rhonda Wood's participation in a nursing home lawsuit because of significant contributions to her judicial campaign by the owner of the nursing home.

In December, the Supreme Court refused to have oral arguments in the case and said it would decide the issue on written arguments Today, in an unsigned order in which Wood did not participate, the court  denied all pending motions, including a request for an evidentiary hearing on Wood's refusal to get off the case and a request for the entire court to do a "neutral review."

click to enlarge MICHAEL MORTON: Fort Smith nursing home magnate funnels huge amounts of cash into campaigns of judicial candidates, including Justice Rhonda Wood.
  • MICHAEL MORTON: Fort Smith nursing home magnate funnels huge amounts of cash into campaigns of judicial candidates, including Justice Rhonda Wood.
Pending before the Supreme Court is a request for a class action certification in a lawsuit alleging poor care by the Robinson Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, owned by Michael Morton of Fort Smith. Lawyers for the plaintiffs don't want Wood to hear the case because Morton contributed $40,000 to her campaign. Combined with other nursing home contributions about half the money raised by Wood came from nursing homes. Her money was raised by Gilbert Baker, who also helped raise contributions for Wood's friend, former Judge Mike Maggio. Maggio pleaded guilty to reducing a $5.2 million judgment against a Morton nursing home in return for the money, though he has since tried to withdraw the plea. No one else has been charged, but evidence gathered during that investigation show frequent communication between Baker and Wood during the relevant time.

In November, Wood said circumstances didn't require her to recuse from the case. She said enough time had passed and Morton hadn't had a significant role in the 2014 campaign. She also said the attorneys, Brian Reddick and Greg Campbell, hadn't argued that the class action was an issue on which recusal was necessary.

After Wood issued that opinion, the attorneys asked for a neutral review by the whole court. She said there's evidence of bias in the Maggio case reflected in what Baker said Wood had told him about the verdict reduction by Maggio.  Baker gave sworn testimony in a civil lawsuit over the verdict reduction. They said her participation presents a "horrible" appearance of conflict in being at the center of characters in the scandfal. They also challenged her representation she didn't know campaign contributors because she'd signed the finance reports that contained that information. The Supreme Court recently adopted new rules of conduct that no longer prevent a judge such as Wood from knowing who contributes to her campaign. It also spurned a recommendation from the Arkansas Bar Association to adopt specific standards for recusal based on campaign supporters. Instead, the court, including Wood, adopted this standard:

The fact that a lawyer in a proceeding, or a litigant, contributed to the judge's campaign, or publicly supported the judge in his or her election does not of itself disqualify the judge. However, the size of contributions, the degree of involvement in the campaign, the timing of the campaign and the proceeding, the issues involved in the proceeding, and other factors known to the judge may raise questions as to the judge's impartiality
The court hasn't released a copy of the order yet and so I don't know if there's any commentary beyond the denial, which is often the case in so-called per curiam orders.

This may not be the end of the matter, though it completes the issue of Wood's participation at the state level. There's precedent for challenging a judge's participation in a federal lawsuit.

UPDATE: The unsigned order was a one-sentence denial without elaboration.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

From the ArkTimes store

Favorite

Comments (11)

Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-11 of 11

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

  • An Arkansan sees Sarah. Detects True Grit.

    Kyle Brazzel, a former Arkie writer who now lives in Brooklyn, beholds White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders in an article in The Awl. He finds Mattie Ross and a little True Grit. Her mother's daughter, too.
    • Jul 27, 2017
  • Trump voter panel renews request for information

    The hotly controversial request for voter information from an ad hoc panel working for Donald Trump has been renewed. No word yet if Arkansas will again be among the first to comply.
    • Jul 27, 2017
  • Boy Scout executive posts 'apology' for Trump's political remarks at jamboree

    Mike Surbaugh, the chief executive of Boy Scouts of America, has posted a letter of apologize on the group's Facebook page for the political tenor of Donald Trump's remarks earlier this week at the National Jamboree.
    • Jul 27, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Federal judge wants John Goodson to explain class action maneuvering

    A show-cause order filed Monday by federal Judge P.K. Holmes of Fort Smith indicates class action attorney John Goodson has some explaining to do about the move of a class action complaint against an insurance company from federal to state court with an instant pre-packaged settlement that has been criticized as a windfall for Goodson.
    • Dec 22, 2015
  • Federal judge reprimands John Goodson for misconduct in class-action case

    John Goodson  — the Texarkana attorney, D.C. lobbyist, and husband of Arkansas State Supreme Court Justice Courtney Goodson — was reprimanded today by a federal judge for his conduct in a class-action case.
    • Aug 3, 2016
  • Al Gore remembers Dale Bumpers

    Former Vice President Al Gore, a former U.S. Senate colleague of Dale Bumpers, sent a statement on Bumpers' death Friday:
    • Jan 3, 2016

Most Shared

  • 'Cemetery angel' Ruth Coker Burks featured in new short film

    Ruth Coker Burks, the AIDS caregiver and activist memorably profiled by David Koon as the cemetery angel in Arkansas Times in 2015, is now the subject of a short film made by actress Rose McGowan.
  • Buyer remorse

    Out here in flyover country, you can't hardly go by the feed store without running into a reporter doing one of those Wisdom of the Heartland stories.
  • Not Whitewater

    Just think: If Democrats had turned out 78,000 more votes in three states in November, people could be reveling today in the prospect of impeaching and convicting President Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump, as some Republican lawmakers had promised to try to do if she won.
  • Head-shaking

    Another edition of so-much-bad-news-so-little space.

Most Viewed

Most Recent Comments

Blogroll

 

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation