Judge affirms dismissal of city of Little Rock in lawsuit over fatal police shooting | Arkansas Blog

Sunday, March 26, 2017

Judge affirms dismissal of city of Little Rock in lawsuit over fatal police shooting

Posted By on Sun, Mar 26, 2017 at 1:13 PM

JOSH HASTINGS; Remains only defendant in lawsuit over 2012 shooting death of Bobby Moore, a burglary suspect.
  • JOSH HASTINGS; Remains only defendant in lawsuit over 2012 shooting death of Bobby Moore, a burglary suspect.
Federal Judge Brian Miller has affirmed his decision to dismiss the city of Little Rock and former Police Chief Stuart Thomas as defendants in a lawsuit brought by the mother of Bobby Moore, killed by then-Office Josh Hastings in 2012.

In a 19-page decision filed Friday, the judge denied a motion to reconsider. He sharply contested arguments made by attorneys for Moore's mother, Sylvia Perkins, that they had established a pattern of poor investigation of use of force by the Little Rock police and that the hiring of Hastings was a mistake sufficient to include them as defendants in the case.

The judge's order faults Perkins' attorney for cherry picking some facts and misrepresenting others.

The judge addressed something I'd mentioned in an earlier item on the request for reconsideration, a "phantom quote" cited by Perkins' attorney, Mike Laux. Miller had cited an 8th Circuit case, but provided a quote from another case that said “investigation of a complaint is sufficient as a matter of law to defeat a claim that the city responded inadequately to information about . . . prior misconduct.” Miller acknowledged that the quote did not appear in the case he cited, but a different case. But he said his decision showed that he'd followed the 8th Circuit precedent that said deliberate indifference couldn't be supported if a matter was investigated and an officer exonerated or disciplined.

Moore, a suspect in a car burglary, was shot while driving a car on an apartment complex parking lot by Hastings. The police investigation concluded Hastings hadn't been truthful about events and he was prosecuted. Two manslaughter trials ended in hung juries and the case was dropped. He was fired from the police department and remains the sole defendant in the lawsuit alleging wrongful death.

Wrote Judge Miller:
The order granting summary judgment was based on the law of this circuit and it is the role of the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals to determine whether the law was correctly applied. It is not the role of this court to determine whether the city of Little Rock or its police department operates perfectly. The “arbitrary parsing” of the evidence, as Perkins calls it, was based on the legal elements of her claims and on the quality of the arguments
made by the parties.
Miller said, among others, that Laux's argument about a shoddy police investigation of Moore's shooting was irrelevant to the question of discriminatory behavior by police in past investigations of use of force. He faulted the "conclusory" testimony of an expert witness who said a finding of excessive force in only 6 percent of more than 500 reviews of force established a "pattern and practice."  The judge said no evidence of specific cases had been offered and the expert said he had not reviewed individual cases. Bare statistics alone are insufficient, he said.

I asked Laux for a comment. He said:

"We are disappointed by the court's ruling. However, we stand firmly by the assertions in the motion regarding the serious misstatement of the law, and we believe the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals will validate our position. "

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Sign up for the Daily Update email


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Readers also liked…

  • Speaking of the Clinton Foundation: Returns in maize and beans

    A reporter for Politifact, the Pulitzer Prize-winning fact-checking organization, sent a reporter to Africa to see where money given to the Clinton Foundation has been put to work. He found tangible results.
    • Sep 6, 2016
  • Greenbrier's paddling of student protester goes worldwide

    The paddling of Greenbrier High School students who joined in te national school walkout Wednesday has produced headlines worldwide.
    • Mar 17, 2018
  • A response to police arrests becomes a tutorial on race, class and policing in Little Rock

    John Walker, the 79-year-old civil rights lawyer, and his associate, Omavi Shukur, 29, a young lawyer devoted to criminal justice reform, talked to press this afternoon about their arrests Monday by Little Rock police for supposedly obstructing governmental operations in observing and attempting to film a routine police traffic stop. It was a tutorial on sharp views of race, class and governance in Little Rock.
    • Sep 29, 2016

Most Viewed

  • The yawning teacher pay gap between Arkansas school districts

    Before Arkansas congratulates itself for outpacing Oklahoma on teacher pay, we should take a look at the huge disparity in salaries within the state. New teachers in Bentonville may make almost $46,000 a year, but new teachers in many other districts will start the 2018-19 school year earning $31,800 — less than the starting salary in Tulsa.
  • Anonymous Harding University students relaunch LGBTQ publication, campus security removes copies

    A group of anonymous Harding University students on Friday published an "HU Queer Press 2.0" zine, covering issues of gay rights at the private, Churches of Christ-affiliated campus in Searcy. A similar publication, "The State of the Gay at Harding University," set off a firestorm of controversy at Harding seven years ago. Shortly after the publication was distributed, campus security officers began gathering the copies of the zine and throwing them in the trash.
  • Chelsea Clinton to come to Little Rock for Clinton School talk

    Chelsea Clinton will come to Little Rock Sunday, May 20, to talk about her new children's book, "She Persisted Around the World." It's a companion to her bestselling "She Persisted." The location is still to be determined. She'll be interviewed onstage and the Arkansas Repertory Theatre will do a reading of the book.
  • Attorney General Rutledge rejects full marijuana legalization ballot initiative

    Speaking of weed, Attorney General Leslie Rutledge today rejected a proposed ballot initiative to fully legalize marijuana in the state.

Most Recent Comments


© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation