Wednesday, December 6, 2017
UCA profs doubt the benefit of a key element of Arkansas corporate welfare
Posted By Max Brantley on Wed, Dec 6, 2017 at 11:54 AM
Word comes from George Mason University, the mothership of conservative economic influencers, that a pair of Arkansas researchers have cast doubt on a key part of Arkansas's corporate welfare handouts — the quick action closing fund.
It's a report by Jacob Bundrick and Thomas Snyder of UCA, themselves part of an economic think tank that owes its existence to such funders as the Koch brothers. If you didn't know, the Kochs hate taxes and regulation, but through their Americans for Prosperity political organization have generally been a foe of taxpayer-funded corporate welfare.
The researchers target the quick action closing fund, money doled out to industrial prospects at the governor's discretion. Bundrick and Snyder conclude that these subsidies don't stimulate economic activity. One important point: a company that opened a factory after receiving the money might have done the project anyway. There are other factors to consider too: Impact on existing businesses, the impact of imposing the tax that produced the money and so on.
Since 2007 through the end of fiscal 2016, the legislature appropriated $156 million for the fund and it has been credited with creating 18,000 jobs. The credit is perhaps misplaced, the authors suggest. They write:
I find interesting in a scan of the report the wealth of other studies that have found the same thing that I've always argued — the value of corporate welfare in job creation is vastly overstated by the people handing it out.
It's a report by Jacob Bundrick and Thomas Snyder of UCA, themselves part of an economic think tank that owes its existence to such funders as the Koch brothers. If you didn't know, the Kochs hate taxes and regulation, but through their Americans for Prosperity political organization have generally been a foe of taxpayer-funded corporate welfare.
The researchers target the quick action closing fund, money doled out to industrial prospects at the governor's discretion. Bundrick and Snyder conclude that these subsidies don't stimulate economic activity. One important point: a company that opened a factory after receiving the money might have done the project anyway. There are other factors to consider too: Impact on existing businesses, the impact of imposing the tax that produced the money and so on.
Since 2007 through the end of fiscal 2016, the legislature appropriated $156 million for the fund and it has been credited with creating 18,000 jobs. The credit is perhaps misplaced, the authors suggest. They write:
However, despite the state’s monitoring of the number of jobs created or retained by the firms receiving subsidies, empirical research examining the relationship between QACF subsidies and the local economy is non-existent.
Broadly speaking, our results provide reason to be skeptical of the QACF as a job creator, at least at the county-level. These results are not only important for economic development policy in Arkansas, but for economic development policy across all 50 states.
I find interesting in a scan of the report the wealth of other studies that have found the same thing that I've always argued — the value of corporate welfare in job creation is vastly overstated by the people handing it out.
Comments (2)
Showing 1-2 of 2
More by Max Brantley
-
The dark and stormy open line
The line is open. Waiiting for Stormy Daniels and enjoying the unhappiness of the NRA about Saturday's marches.
- Mar 25, 2018
-
Cotton Plant, Ark., makes the big time thanks to marijuana
The hopes of tiny Cotton Plant to be revitalized by a medical marijuana cultivation facility is the subject of a feature article in today's New York Times.
- Mar 25, 2018
-
Crossett pollution: Does anybody care besides the newspaper?
There's an outstanding piece of reporting in today's Arkansas Democrat-Gazette by Eric Besson and Emily Walkenhorst about pollution at the Georgia-Pacific plant in Crossett. Will it join past investigative journalism in the dustbin?
- Mar 25, 2018
- More »
Readers also liked…
-
Satanic Temple: Make Rapert pay for Ten Commandments monument
A petition drive has begun to encourage a demand that Sen. Jason Rapert pay for the legal fees in defending his Ten Commandments monument proposed for the state Capitol grounds. It's more work by the Satanic Temple, which has fought church-state entanglement around the country.
- Aug 28, 2016
-
Antwan Phillips wants to make a difference in reducing Little Rock violence
KARK/Fox 16's push to do something about Little Rock violence includes a spotlight on people trying to make a difference — in this episode Antwan Phillips, a lawyer at Wright, Lindsey and Jennings.
- Aug 30, 2017
-
The inspiring Hillary Clinton
Hillary Clinton's campaign for president illustrates again the double standard applied to women. Some writers get it. They even find the supposedly unlikable Clinton inspiring.
- Oct 16, 2016
Site Index
News
Cover Story / Arkansas Reporter / The Week That Was / The Observer / Editorial / Max Brantley / Ernest Dumas / Gene Lyons / Jay Barth / Words / Guest Writer / Letters
Entertainment
A&E Feature / To-Do List / In Brief / Movie Reviews / Music Reviews / Theater Reviews / A&E News / Art Notes / Media / Dining Reviews / Dining Guide / Calendar / Gallery Listings
RT @LRpolice: UPDATE LRPD Homicide Detectives have made an additional arrest on a homicide that occurred at 7801 W 29th Street. Quincy B…
KARK4News
LR teen who disrupted court sent to adult jail for a week, a punishment that youth advocates and public defenders s… https://t.co/Gg5oljbu78
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
We sat down with "Scandal" actor and Little Rock native George Newbern to discuss the end of the show. Check it out… https://t.co/SGbJYNe6CA
KATV News
RT @Wess_Moore: Just minutes away from our Dallas Cowboys Pre Draft Special on @FOX16News. Join @Spags52, and @Boys_Vox and me for a look…
Fox16 News
Walmart’s top five execs paid $64.722 million in fiscal 2017
TalkBusiness.net
KARK4News
LR teen who disrupted court sent to adult jail for a week, a punishment that youth advocates and public defenders s… https://t.co/Gg5oljbu78
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
We sat down with "Scandal" actor and Little Rock native George Newbern to discuss the end of the show. Check it out… https://t.co/SGbJYNe6CA
KATV News
RT @Wess_Moore: Just minutes away from our Dallas Cowboys Pre Draft Special on @FOX16News. Join @Spags52, and @Boys_Vox and me for a look…
Fox16 News
Walmart’s top five execs paid $64.722 million in fiscal 2017
TalkBusiness.net
Most Viewed
-
UA Little Rock responds to "racially insensitive incident" involving video of fraternity and sorority
A video uploaded to Facebook shows members of the Chi Omega sorority and Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity singing along to the song "Freaky Friday." The white students repeatedly shout along to the n-word.
-
Jon Woods tried to direct marijuana money to Ecclesia College
The bombshells continue in the federal corruption trial against former Sen. Jon Woods, who federal prosecutors allege took kickbacks from from state money he guided to Ecclesia College and a mental health agency. Testimony yesterday confirmed previous reporting from the Arkansas Blog that Woods tried to steer marijuana cash to Ecclesia College.
-
DHS warns of end to entire at-home services program for disabled and elderly if court enjoins rule on allocation of hours
Both parties are seeking summary judgment on the ARChoices case, and Circuit Judge Wendell Griffen said he would issue a written ruling within the next ten days.
-
Popular Brinkley barbecue restaurant busted for suspected video gambling machines
Gene's Bar-B-Que & Restaurant in Brinkley has been raided by special agents with the First Judicial District Drug Task Force on suspicion of illegal gambling. Ten video arcade machines and cash were seized from the popular barbecue joint.
-
The Friday 4/20 open line
Have a good weekend, folks.
Most Recent Comments
-
Re: The Friday 4/20 open line
THIS DATE IN ARKANSAS HISTORY--Stephen Smith 20-Apr 1944 Little Rock Mayor Charles Moyer signs the…
- on April 20, 2018
-
Re: Popular Brinkley barbecue restaurant busted for suspected video gambling machines
I can understand GFTR s post. I should probably get a checkup
- on April 20, 2018
-
Re: Jon Woods tried to direct marijuana money to Ecclesia College
Didn't this dude's band have a song appear in a major motion picture or TV…
-
on April 20, 2018
This Week's Cover
Quick Links
Special Publications
RSS
Facebook
Twitter