Stop the presses: Doubt from UA school 'reformer' about test scores as measure of future success | Arkansas Blog

Monday, March 19, 2018

Stop the presses: Doubt from UA school 'reformer' about test scores as measure of future success

Posted By on Mon, Mar 19, 2018 at 11:20 AM

click to enlarge JAY GREENE: UA school reformer raises important question about putting too much faith in school tests to evaluate schools and students.
  • JAY GREENE: UA school reformer raises important question about putting too much faith in school tests to evaluate schools and students.
Jay Greene, head of the Department of Education Reform at the University of Arkansas, has written a blog post drawing wide attention because it tends to rock the faith of many school "reformers" in the value of test scores in measuring students and schools.

I’ve written several times recently about how short term gains in test scores are not associated with improved later life outcomes for students. Schools and programs that increase test score quite often do not yield higher high school graduation or college attendance rates. Conversely, schools and programs that fail to produce greater gains in test scores sometimes produce impressive improvements in high school graduation and college attendance rates, college completion rates, and even higher employment and earnings. I’ve described at least 8 studies that show a disconnect between raising test scores and stronger later life outcomes.
Wow. (This by the way, parallels my own limited and admittedly unscientific observation some years ago that students at conventional Delta high schools seemed to be enjoying better success in college — based on retention of lottery scholarships — than graduates of a highly touted charter school in the region.)

To be sure I was reading this right, I asked Greene via Twitter:

Too much emphasis on test scores?

He responded:

(Greene notes a UA colleague and former students provided study basis for his article).

My hero — and consequently not normally a favorite of the Walton-financed education reform unit at UA — Diane Ravitch had this to say:

Jay Greene, chairman of the Department of Educational Reform at the University of Arkansas, reaches a startling conclusion: Higher test do not necessarily translate into higher graduation rates or other life outcomes that matter.

This post pretty much blows away the rationale for corporate reform. How many times did we hear from Michelle Rhee, Joel Klein, Wendy Kopp, Arne Duncan, Bill Gates, and other “reform” leaders that charter schools get higher test scores than public schools? How many times have we heard from the Friedman Foundation and other cheerleaders for vouchers that vouchers are the key to higher test scores? But what if the higher test scores do not translate into better outcomes for students? What if Jay Greene is right? Perhaps the goal of schooling should be to teach a well-rounded education, character, and citizenship? Test scores don’t measure that.

This is one of the most important posts I have read in a very long time. I encourage you to read it.

Thanks, Jay.

I have one more comment at the moment:

Commissioner Johnny Key: Give Little Rock its schools back. They are in state takeover because 3 of some four dozen schools fall short of arbitrary test score standards.

And to the state Board of Education: stop approving applications for unproven charter schools on the theory that choice must be better just, well, because that's what the Waltons say.

Oh and one more thing: The legislature should retreat from making ever higher ACT scores a prerequisite for lottery scholarships. This ensures a higher income and whiter cohort gets the money, a group least in need of it. While those most in need are left behind. Test scores measure test-taking ability. They don't measure college success.  My mother-in-law, a former teacher and supervisor of gifted and talented education in Arkansas, drummed this into my head years ago. And I knew from experience that she was just about always right about everything. And I mean that sincerely, not snarkily.

Tags: , , , , ,


Comments (15)

Showing 1-15 of 15

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-15 of 15

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Readers also liked…

  • Among the last words from Kenneth Williams: 'Finger Lickin' Good Fried Chicken'

    What's purported to be a final-words essay from condemned prisoner Kenneth Williams was distributed today by Deborah Robinson, a freelance journalist in Arkansas.  He reflects on his execution, his victims, reactions of inmates and big servings of fried chicken, which he says are given to all inmates on execution days.
    • Apr 27, 2017
  • The LR chamber does the public's business. Is it accountable? Blue Hog on the case.

    Matt Campbell, lawyer and Blue Hog Report blogger, has sent a Freedom of Information Act request to Jay Chessir, director of the Little Rock Regional Chamber of Commerce, and Mayor Mark Stodola related to the publicity stunt yesterday  built around withdrawing from the mayor's rash pronouncement that the city would seek an Amazon HQ2 project even though the city  didn't meet the company's criteria.
    • Oct 20, 2017
  • Presidential thriller, co-author Bill Clinton, coming to bookstores in 2018

    June 2018 is the expected publication date for a novel collaboration by former President Bill Clinton and crime writer James Patterson.
    • May 9, 2017


  • Arkansas vs Ole Miss at War Memorial stadium in Little Rock, Saturday, Oct. 13, 2018. After leading for much of the game, Arkansas lost 37-33 when Ole Miss scored the game winning Touchdown with less that 2 minutes left. 
  • Margaret Clark Adventure Park
    New sculptures, preschoolers play area dedicated in Riverfront Park in Little Rock.

Most Recent Comments


© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation