Art and justice 

'Woman in Gold' too schmaltzy, but reaffirming nonetheless.

'WOMAN IN GOLD': Helen Mirren and Ryan Reynolds star image
  • 'WOMAN IN GOLD': Helen Mirren and Ryan Reynolds star.

"Woman in Gold," a cinematic glass of Chardonnay, pairs Helen Mirren and Ryan Reynolds as an odd-couple team out to right an old Nazi wrong. She's Maria Altmann, 80-something and living quietly in Los Angeles, an immigrant since escaping Vienna at the brink of World War II. Her wealthy family was dismantled, robbed and killed; the Nazis looted musical instruments, the silver and several now-priceless artworks by Gustav Klimt. One in particular, a gold-shellacked portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer, Maria's aunt, looks like a fever dream inspired by episodes of "Pimp My Ride" — but has become, in one character's words, "the Mona Lisa of Austria" since the war. Reynolds is her lawyer, Randy Schoenberg, the guy who really did help Maria get her paintings back in 2006 after years of fighting against the Austrian government.

The ingredients, then, are all here for a safe and ennobling courtroom drama, which in essence "Woman in Gold" is, with a parallel line of flashbacks to prewar Austria to round out the tale. For a Holocaust movie, it must get some credit for focusing on the lesser yet still monumental crimes against Europe's Jews. Austria as a state comes off looking quite the worse for it. So determined Austria was to cling to the big gold Klimt that it overlooked the glaring inconvenience that the painting was plucked off the walls of Maria's family home in a flurry of glorified looting; Hitler ended up with one of her family's paintings in his Swiss compound, and Goering got some of the jewels. Maria and Randy offer every opportunity for them to say "our bad." Instead, they cling to their spoils. And so the phrase "art restitution" gets a real workout in Alexi Kaye Campbell's script, based on the two protagonists' life stories.

There's not an overabundance of subtlety in "Woman in Gold," if only because there's only so much room for nuance when you're arguing against the criminal legacy of Nazism. Austria's argument for keeping the portrait comes down, in a nutshell, to "yes, but we really want it and we've now had it for so long." It's up to Reynolds and Mirren to pull something fun or unexpected out of the rhetoric. Turns out there's not much, in the abundant speeches they deliver, but the case is made quite clear, that stealing things and then keeping them while also killing people's families is not the right side of history, for the record.

Director Simon Curtis ("My Week with Marilyn") manages to wring most of the movie's pathos out of the flight story of the younger Maria (played by Tatiana Maslany) and her family's sudden dissolution. Rich though they were, something about being a refugee, fleeing without so much as a suitcase, has a way of laying a person low. Mirren is quietly commanding in her role, making sharp older-lady jokes and gently pushing her lawyer around.

Fairly early on, we bump against the outer limits of caring about Reynolds, however. Originally intrigued by the case because of its potential for a nine-figure settlement (the painting did later sell for $135 million) he finds himself drawn in after traveling to Austria and communing with his own dead relatives there. It's a powerful journey, though it's not really clear that Reynolds is the one to pull it off for us. He's a perfectly pleasant face, capable of feats of plausible earnestness, and in all, a big reason the movie turns out about 30 percent too sugary. At a certain level, it won't matter, really. The film's message is reaffirming and indisputable, and the story intriguing enough. You'll never look at "Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer I" on a refrigerator magnet quite the same way again.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Sam Eifling

  • 'True Detective' season 3 finale recap: Wins for Mahershala Ali, Northwest Arkansas

    Let’s appreciate for a moment what it means to a show like “True Detective” that you can stream TV now. Not simply to tape it, but watch it on devices as small as the pulpy paperback that it has, for many people, replaced. The ability to revisit it endlessly, to fast-forward and rewind and rewatch as easily as Wayne Hays’ memory skates through time. The third season of Nic Pizzolatto’s serial crime drama — destined to be remembered alongside its astonishing, fulgent first season, rather than the boggy, overcomplicated Season 2 — was a television story that skipped boldly between three timelines spread across 35 years, while living firmly in 2019.
    • Feb 25, 2019
  • 'True Detective' episode 7 recap: Penultimate payoff

    The sight of two broad-shouldered black Cadillacs in front of Wayne Hays’ house, and of a chicken tycoon phoning him to come outside, is the cliffhanger from the next-to-last episode of "True Detective’s" third season.
    • Feb 18, 2019
  • 'True Detective' episode 6 recap: Enter the chicken king

    Things are not going well for Tom Purcell, and that’s really saying a lot. Episode 6 of this third season of “True Detective” finds him mad as hell and not taking it anymore, and marks a high mark for Scoot McNairy, who till now has played the grieving father as the embodiment of cuckolded defeat.
    • Feb 11, 2019
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Wakanda for the win

    'Black Panther' is thoroughly, joyously, unabashedly black.
    • Feb 22, 2018

Latest in Movie Reviews

Most Viewed


© 2019 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation