Favorite

But is it legal? 

But is it legal? I’ve groused for years about the wisdom of corporate welfare, using public tax money to subsidize profitable private enterprises. So I was more than pleased to open the Dec. 13 New Yorker and find James Surowiecki’s article on such incentives. It contains information that is probably news to many people in these parts. If the folks in the governor’s office and Arkansas Department of Economic Development know about it, they’re keeping it quiet. The news: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has ruled that giving companies big financial incentives to locate in one state instead of another is unconstitutional because it interferes with interstate commerce. The case arose in Toledo. Ohio gave DaimlerChrysler jillions in tax incentives and direct aid to build a Jeep plant in Toledo. Local taxpayers, including some small businesses that create jobs in their own small, meaningful way, sued. Why should a Jeep plant be favored and not them? It is a question Arkansans should ask. State leaders are itching to unlimber new bonding authority by which the state legislature can pour $200 million or so into an industrial plant, preferably a car maker. No payback or job guarantee required. A promise of job creation is enough to get the loot. Surowiecki concedes that job creation has some merit as an argument for such handouts. He cites an academic study that shows that cities (our emphasis) that won competition for new plants generally experienced higher tax revenues and property values. Those are mostly local benefits, of course. The whole state will pay off the top of general revenues (schools will lose most) for the corporate welfare. It’s even less of a deal for an auto plant in East Arkansas, where much of the benefit likely will be enjoyed by Tennessee residents and the Tennessee businesses they patronize. More to the point, Surowiecki continues, “The problem is that though the city with the new plant may be better off, collectively we are all worse off, because the tax money spent on corporate welfare could otherwise go to more productive uses, such as education and infrastructure. For the American economy, it doesn’t matter whether Daimler builds Jeeps in Toledo or Kalamazoo; [or Toyota in Marion, Ark., or Milwaukee] whatever one city spends to outdo the other is money thrown away.” It’s unfair, Surowiecki says, for government to capriciously decide which sort of businesses to favor. Also, the bets sometimes fail. Surowiecki mentioned, as I have before, United Airlines’ recent closure of an Indiana maintenance facility that had enjoyed huge public subsidies. Manufacturing operations are even more risky, because of the competition from cheap overseas labor. Surowiecki concedes that governments have little choice but to compete in the corporate welfare sweepstakes even though tax breaks alone are rarely deal makers. He cites Irvine, Calif., which apparently has attracted many auto industries without offering any handouts at all. Surowiecki concludes that the Ohio court case, which will require lengthy appeals, could be the only hope to stop the mutually assured destruction. Meanwhile, Arkansas leaders are determined to give away the store — and soon. Taxpayers can only hope that legislators will close some of the biggest holes in the tragically leaky corporate welfare bonanza that voters wrote into the Constitution in November.
Favorite

From the ArkTimes store

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Max Brantley

Readers also liked…

  • Bootstraps for me, not thee

    Mean spirit, hypocrisy and misinformation abound among the rump minority threatening to wreck state government rather than allow passage of the state Medicaid appropriation if it continues to include the Obamacare-funded expansion of health insurance coverage for working poor.
    • Apr 14, 2016
  • Trump: The Obama of 2016?

    Conner Eldridge, the Democratic challenger to incumbent Republican U.S. Sen. John Boozman, launched an assault on Boozman Monday morning rich with irony and opportunity.
    • May 5, 2016
  • Double-talk

    A couple of instances of doublespeak cropped up in Little Rock over the weekend.
    • Jun 29, 2017

Most Shared

  • 'Cemetery angel' Ruth Coker Burks featured in new short film

    Ruth Coker Burks, the AIDS caregiver and activist memorably profiled by David Koon as the cemetery angel in Arkansas Times in 2015, is now the subject of a short film made by actress Rose McGowan.
  • Buyer remorse

    Out here in flyover country, you can't hardly go by the feed store without running into a reporter doing one of those Wisdom of the Heartland stories.
  • Not Whitewater

    Just think: If Democrats had turned out 78,000 more votes in three states in November, people could be reveling today in the prospect of impeaching and convicting President Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump, as some Republican lawmakers had promised to try to do if she won.
  • Head-shaking

    Another edition of so-much-bad-news-so-little space.

Latest in Max Brantley

  • Head-shaking

    Another edition of so-much-bad-news-so-little space.
    • Jul 27, 2017
  • Football for UA Little Rock

    Andrew Rogerson, the new chancellor at UA Little Rock, has decided to study the cost of starting a major college football team on campus (plus a marching band). Technically, it would be a revival of football, dropped more than 60 years ago when the school was a junior college.
    • Jul 20, 2017
  • We're No. 1! in vote suppression

    It's not often that Arkansas can claim national leadership, so give Secretary of State Mark Martin credit for something.

    • Jul 13, 2017
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

July

S M T W T F S
  1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31  

Most Viewed

  • Buyer remorse

    Out here in flyover country, you can't hardly go by the feed store without running into a reporter doing one of those Wisdom of the Heartland stories.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Buyer remorse

    • IBS, you're from Chicago, right? Hillary's from Chicago. Your monomania against Hillary is puzzling and…

    • on July 27, 2017
  • Re: Buyer remorse

    • When we had not one but TWO shit candidates running for president, is it really…

    • on July 27, 2017
  • Re: Buyer remorse

    • So Gene Lyons says all people who voted for Trump fall into just two categories…

    • on July 27, 2017
 

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation