Favorite

Me or my 

An Arkansas Times editorial said "Regardless of your personal belief, I would hope that you shutting up about your personal belief and letting me decide these things is something we can all agree to." Richard W. Chapman finds fault.

"The gerund 'shutting up ... letting me decide these things' is treated as a noun and thus requires the possessive form of the preceding pronoun," Chapman writes. "The sentence should read 'I would hope that YOUR shutting up ...' ."

A shade-tree grammarian at best, I usually try to stay out of the minefield of gerunds, genitives and fused participles. But if we must, we must. We'll eschew technical terms as much as possible.

There is indeed an old rule that requires the use of the possessive in sentences such as the one from the editorial. Some people take the rule seriously; some less so. One prominent grammarian has said "It's a niggling point, but one on which many people niggle." My attitude is the same as my attitude toward the old rules about not splitting infinitives and not ending sentences with prepositions. I don't go looking for occasions to break the rules, but if I think a sentence sounds and reads better with the infinitive split and the preposition at the end, that's the way I do it. Jane Austen was a great writer, and a grammatically correct one, but who today would write, as she did, "Elinor was prevented from making any reply to this ... by the door's being thrown open, the servant's announcing Mr. Ferrars, and Edward's immediately walking in"? This, on the other hand, sounds right, even if ungrammatical: "The rage and uproar over me becoming a Muslim was still at a fever pitch." That's from "The Greatest," by Muhammad Ali. If I have to fight, I'd rather fight Jane Austen than Muhammad Ali.

Maybe the Times editorialist shares my view. Maybe he didn't want to put two "your"s so close together. Maybe he dozed off while writing. Editorials can do that.

People who want more on this subject should check the "Fused Participles" entry in Garner's Modern American Usage. More respectful of the old rule than I, and knowing far more about it, Garner says, in part, "Especially in formal prose, the possessive ought to be used whenever it is not unidiomatic or unnatural."

Favorite

From the ArkTimes store

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Most Shared

  • 'Cemetery angel' Ruth Coker Burks featured in new short film

    Ruth Coker Burks, the AIDS caregiver and activist memorably profiled by David Koon as the cemetery angel in Arkansas Times in 2015, is now the subject of a short film made by actress Rose McGowan.
  • Buyer remorse

    Out here in flyover country, you can't hardly go by the feed store without running into a reporter doing one of those Wisdom of the Heartland stories.
  • Not Whitewater

    Just think: If Democrats had turned out 78,000 more votes in three states in November, people could be reveling today in the prospect of impeaching and convicting President Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump, as some Republican lawmakers had promised to try to do if she won.
  • Head-shaking

    Another edition of so-much-bad-news-so-little space.

Latest in Words

  • The L word and the C word

    I was excited to see the newspaper headline "Bielema liberal." "After all those neo-Nazis, we've finally got a coach who thinks right," I told friends. "I wonder if he belongs to the ADA."
    • May 1, 2014
  • Who's exasperated?

    Jim Newell was gripped by exasperation himself after reading this item in the business section. "Exacerbated" is the word the writer wanted, he sagely suggests.
    • Apr 24, 2014
  • We will run no race before it's ripe

    "What year would Oaklawn recognize as its 100th anniversary? After all, Oaklawn's advertising material is ripe with 'Since 1904,' but it's widely reported the first race wasn't run until 1905."
    • Apr 17, 2014
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »

July

S M T W T F S
  1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31  

Most Viewed

  • Narrow opening for Arkansas Democrats

    "Somebody in this room — it's time to go big or go home." At the Democratic Party of Arkansas's Clinton Dinner last weekend, Gov. John Bel Edwards of Louisiana used his platform as keynote speaker to embolden a candidate to step up to run for governor against incumbent Republican Governor Hutchinson.
  • Not Whitewater

    Just think: If Democrats had turned out 78,000 more votes in three states in November, people could be reveling today in the prospect of impeaching and convicting President Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump, as some Republican lawmakers had promised to try to do if she won.
  • Buyer remorse

    Out here in flyover country, you can't hardly go by the feed store without running into a reporter doing one of those Wisdom of the Heartland stories.
  • Head-shaking

    Another edition of so-much-bad-news-so-little space.

Most Recent Comments

 

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation